Bloomfield Best Bagels

404 Broad St, Bloomfield
(973) 429-1146

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maria Estrella

I recently tried the rainbow bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese, and I was highly disappointed. The bagel was cold and not toasted, and it tasted stale, like it had been sitting out for a while. The eggs were clearly from the day before—dry and rubbery, lacking any freshness. The bacon was old, the sandwich was bland and unappetizing. I expected a colorful and flavorful breakfast experience, but instead, I got a sad, stale bagel that I couldn't even finish. I won't be ordering this again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lynda Jones

Very Nice people I still say these are nice people .. but it's a hit or miss .. two weeks ago I got an awesome Platte so I decided to give them a try this morning... unfortunately not going back ... I was so disappointed I ordered the same order as before ... eggs were a lil over cooked .. and the bacon well let's just say it was 3 lil gummy undercooked pieces ... the reason I won't return it was so embarrassing to serve that to my family. I usually go somewhere else but decided to give this place a chance again .. because the people are soooo nice and their coffee is really good .. but the food, not so much ... my husband said his bagel tasted fresh and good but the bacon was chewy not good and very sparse .. I need a new place .. .its sad because its is always a very pleasant visit...

Anthony Tony

My bagel was on the hard but 2 others with me had no issues with their food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Uriel Burwell

Great location and a very clean store.
The turkey bacon was very hard to chew and the roll was not fresh. It shredded into mini pieces when I went to pick it up.

Josette Josette

My first time ordering from here. I got a turkey sausage and egg and cheese sandwich. Opened my sandwich and part of the bagel was green with mold which I saw after taking a bite. I’m so disgusted i wish I researched the place before coming I would’ve seen the other bad reviews. Plus the bite I had wasn’t that good anyways. Definitely not worth my $6.50.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Tomasz Wojdyła

Always good and fresh bagels

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Phoenix Toliver

I’m so sorry to have to do this, but I am fed up with Bloomfield Bagels. I have ordered here, daily, for the past 2 years (my work breakfast/iced coffee) and up until recently, was always pleased. But today was the last straw. I’m DONE with this place. The BEC was disgusting. I always ask them to toast it, and they never do. The toppings were wrong and it was just gross. Inconsistency like this is a bummer, because with my AuDHD, I would have been a loyal, daily customer, for years. Now, I’ll never go back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich

Lillian R.

Ordered via Door Dash Western omelette was full of Red n Green peppers ? what happen to the Onions & Ham. So disappointed. Didnt get my coffee!! what is breakfast w/o coffee!!! Chicken Fingers n French Fries were ok. Fries overcooked. The best thing were the bagels. Bagels were perfect. Will noy order from here again. Get it together.

Food: 3

Service: 1

vincent tarney

Best bagel around, tried most bagel places in the area and still go back here for them. Crispy outside and chewy inside ???

Parking: Huge lot behind the store

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a wheel chair ramp to the front door

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Onion Bagel

Sahara Shabazz

Though i didn’t have any interaction with the staff im writing this review because when i walked in all i saw was FLIES all over the bagels I was so disgusted literally flies touching every last bagel i just feel bad because i saw so many DOORDASH orders too bad they couldn’t see the filth that touched their food PLEASE FIND A RESOLUTION TO THIS ITS DISGUSTING YOU HAVE PEOPLE EATING BAGELS THAT WERE TOUCHED by a species that carries so many diseases .. i wish i could’ve recorded a video it was so many flies but all i could do was take a picture and it’s not so clear

Lillian Richards

Ordered via Door Dash Western omelette was full of Red n Green peppers ? what happen to the Onions & Ham. So disappointed. Didnt get my coffee!! what is breakfast w/o coffee!!! Chicken Fingers n French Fries were ok. Fries overcooked. The best thing were the bagels. Bagels were perfect. Will noy order from here again. Get it together.

Food: 3

Service: 1

Adam Morley

Ordered ahead of time , still told have to wait on line. Then someone else walks in and they take him for pickup in front of me. Meanwhile there's a sign for door dash pickup. Pickup is pickup

Food: 4

Service: 1

Arianna Erraez

Truly, the best bagels in Bloomfield. A great place to grab a bagel in the morning or a sandwich in the afternoon. Affordable and tasty.

Vegetarian options: A egg and cheese sandwich is my go to, but there are plenty of other options. You could get a bagel and cream cheese, pancakes, an omelette, and so much more. It's simple to modify most menu items to be vegetarian.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich

Donna Cifelli

Excellent bagels and bagel sandwiches for breakfast or lunch. Decent prices and responsive staff.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Taylor Ham Egg & Cheese, Egg Sandwich

Douglas Brown

Great food and prices

Loading...