Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza and a Plain Pizza, Eggplant Parm
Mariya Kovalyov
This place is great! The people are super nice and the food is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
bigfigueroa
Fabios has historically been a go to place for a few years now. However more and more I find myself waiting for my food to be ready at the time promised. One of my biggest pet peeves is wasting my time as I take it as a form of disrespect. Stupidly I placed my order a day ahead of time for the superbowl and arrived at the promised time the day of. I waited a total of 2 and a half hours and finally walked away with no food because the superbowl was almost at halftime. It took a few weeks but I forgave them . I placed an order on a Friday afternoon. Once again I found myself waiting for a half hour. As much as it pains me to say, since I do enjoy the food and the staff, there are far to many other options in the area. I will no longer be disrespected and waste $40 to $50 an order just to waste my time. Enjoy the food if you order but be prepared to wait. We had a good run Fabios.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Lil D
If I can give zero, I will. I keep having bad experiences however keep giving chances because of the kids. Having experience the long wait we ordered early. If they are honest about the wait time and what's going on, I would have had a better understanding and respect for the efforts. I don't know where to begin with the experience. There was a time on a week day, it took 2 hours, we got there they couldn't locate the order, then they tell me 30 more minutes. I told them to disregard the order, I went somewhere else. There is no apology, do not concern them attitude. Months go by, we try them again long wait, no much change. Superbowl Sunday, I definitely know there will be long wait but I didn't want to go out. We ordered early about 5:50, slice says it was 30 mins we know from experience is not possible. Less than 1 min after the order was completed and confirmed, I received a text message that changed it to 6:52- 7:07. Then another change to 7:15 to 730. About 740 I called no answer. Called a few times no answer. My husband called right after me with his phone they pickup! Wow! I'm upset they were willing and ready taking new orders while avoiding calls from waiting customers. Again no apologies. She said it will take about 30 mins. About 45mins-1 hr we went to get the order, they couldn't find it then after some time searching all over locates it another maybe another 20 mins.We received very tasteless food. Kids managed to eat some of the pizza. The wings were a waste we ordered hot wings we received BBQ if it were good the kids would have eaten it, they took one bite and rejected it along with garlic knots.I was ready and willing to return the food, but kids too hungry. I feel Fabio's pizza owes me money for food that was not worth waiting for.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
The France Jr.
Classic Italian. Friendly, always courteousMy go to spot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Greg Mrozak
Pasta fah-julie like no other!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victor Pereira
2 hours for a pizza!!!!!! Seriously at least admit that you put it in when we finally called and they told us 20 mins. 35 minutes later it showed up. Luckily for you my wife had it on her card. I wouldve sent it back. Couldn’t eat the middle slices it was soup. Never again good luck across the street won’t see us there. At least Nola’s will tell you it’s 2 hours not lil over an hour
Service: 1
Stephen Landry
Fabio's has my favorite pizza in the area. It has a delicious thin crust. I usually order take out, as their dining room is quite small and usually busy, but I understand they are expanding this year.
Brian Tice
I ordered from Fabio’s off of Door Dash. The food was terrible! Calamari was rubbery and the “Brooklyn Style Square Pie” well the crust wasn’t thin, way too much sauce and the crust was undercooked. I’m not really sure if the crust was undercooked or there was just way to much sauce! Overall experience for 50+ dollars was absolutely horrendous!!! Completely disappointed….. Don’t really know how it has a 4.8 on Door Dash! 4.0 at best and that’s being generous!
Food: 1
Service: 2
Kevin Dulaney
Fabio’s is amazing. From the pies to the entrees, nothing is a miss. We love the chicken francese pie the best.
I feel upon this place waiting for my train back to NYC. The service was pleasantly great. I'm soooooo in heaven about my shrimp parm hero!!! Everyone doesn't hit it and they knocked it out the park!!! Everything was fresh, the mozzarella pull baaaaby and my bread was nicely toasted how I like it. GREAT ITALIAN
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ethan Allen
The food was great and the service was great. This is a must-go if you're in fanwood.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Marlena Karnowicz
The pizza pie I ordered was by far one of the worst pizzas I have ever had! The pepperoni was the size of a penny and more grease coming out of it than flavor. I just wasted 20 bucks! I do not recommend it to anyone.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Chanel Hanjra
Fabio’s is hands down the best place to get your pizza in and around Scotch Plains/Fanwood. Unfortunately their delivery system needs a major over haul. Waited almost three hours for our order tonight. When we finally got it, the pizza it was over cooked and the calamari was rubbery. Most likely from sitting on top of the oven for over two hours. Just was there for a quick slice the other day and it was fantastic. Online ordering should be shut down if they know their customers are going to have that long of a wait on a Friday. Hopefully getting into their new building in the future will alleviate these wait times.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Karolyn Buckridee
We ordered take out which was awesome! Always happy with Fabio’s!
The best pizza in jersey...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza and a Plain Pizza, Eggplant Parm
This place is great! The people are super nice and the food is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fabios has historically been a go to place for a few years now. However more and more I find myself waiting for my food to be ready at the time promised. One of my biggest pet peeves is wasting my time as I take it as a form of disrespect. Stupidly I placed my order a day ahead of time for the superbowl and arrived at the promised time the day of. I waited a total of 2 and a half hours and finally walked away with no food because the superbowl was almost at halftime. It took a few weeks but I forgave them . I placed an order on a Friday afternoon. Once again I found myself waiting for a half hour. As much as it pains me to say, since I do enjoy the food and the staff, there are far to many other options in the area. I will no longer be disrespected and waste $40 to $50 an order just to waste my time. Enjoy the food if you order but be prepared to wait. We had a good run Fabios.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
If I can give zero, I will. I keep having bad experiences however keep giving chances because of the kids. Having experience the long wait we ordered early. If they are honest about the wait time and what's going on, I would have had a better understanding and respect for the efforts. I don't know where to begin with the experience. There was a time on a week day, it took 2 hours, we got there they couldn't locate the order, then they tell me 30 more minutes. I told them to disregard the order, I went somewhere else. There is no apology, do not concern them attitude. Months go by, we try them again long wait, no much change. Superbowl Sunday, I definitely know there will be long wait but I didn't want to go out. We ordered early about 5:50, slice says it was 30 mins we know from experience is not possible. Less than 1 min after the order was completed and confirmed, I received a text message that changed it to 6:52- 7:07. Then another change to 7:15 to 730. About 740 I called no answer. Called a few times no answer. My husband called right after me with his phone they pickup! Wow! I'm upset they were willing and ready taking new orders while avoiding calls from waiting customers. Again no apologies. She said it will take about 30 mins. About 45mins-1 hr we went to get the order, they couldn't find it then after some time searching all over locates it another maybe another 20 mins.We received very tasteless food. Kids managed to eat some of the pizza. The wings were a waste we ordered hot wings we received BBQ if it were good the kids would have eaten it, they took one bite and rejected it along with garlic knots.I was ready and willing to return the food, but kids too hungry. I feel Fabio's pizza owes me money for food that was not worth waiting for.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Classic Italian. Friendly, always courteousMy go to spot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Pasta fah-julie like no other!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
2 hours for a pizza!!!!!! Seriously at least admit that you put it in when we finally called and they told us 20 mins. 35 minutes later it showed up. Luckily for you my wife had it on her card. I wouldve sent it back. Couldn’t eat the middle slices it was soup. Never again good luck across the street won’t see us there. At least Nola’s will tell you it’s 2 hours not lil over an hour
Service: 1
Fabio's has my favorite pizza in the area. It has a delicious thin crust. I usually order take out, as their dining room is quite small and usually busy, but I understand they are expanding this year.
I ordered from Fabio’s off of Door Dash. The food was terrible! Calamari was rubbery and the “Brooklyn Style Square Pie” well the crust wasn’t thin, way too much sauce and the crust was undercooked. I’m not really sure if the crust was undercooked or there was just way to much sauce! Overall experience for 50+ dollars was absolutely horrendous!!! Completely disappointed….. Don’t really know how it has a 4.8 on Door Dash! 4.0 at best and that’s being generous!
Food: 1
Service: 2
Fabio’s is amazing. From the pies to the entrees, nothing is a miss. We love the chicken francese pie the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I feel upon this place waiting for my train back to NYC. The service was pleasantly great. I'm soooooo in heaven about my shrimp parm hero!!! Everyone doesn't hit it and they knocked it out the park!!! Everything was fresh, the mozzarella pull baaaaby and my bread was nicely toasted how I like it. GREAT ITALIAN
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was great and the service was great. This is a must-go if you're in fanwood.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The pizza pie I ordered was by far one of the worst pizzas I have ever had! The pepperoni was the size of a penny and more grease coming out of it than flavor. I just wasted 20 bucks! I do not recommend it to anyone.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fabio’s is hands down the best place to get your pizza in and around Scotch Plains/Fanwood. Unfortunately their delivery system needs a major over haul. Waited almost three hours for our order tonight. When we finally got it, the pizza it was over cooked and the calamari was rubbery. Most likely from sitting on top of the oven for over two hours. Just was there for a quick slice the other day and it was fantastic. Online ordering should be shut down if they know their customers are going to have that long of a wait on a Friday. Hopefully getting into their new building in the future will alleviate these wait times.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
We ordered take out which was awesome! Always happy with Fabio’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5