Fat sandwich delivery used to be cool until you started paying double the cost of the order in delivery fees. Hopefully things might change and this will be worth it again in the future! Best of
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ryan Doorley
Amazing customer service that you just don't get elsewhere anymore. Above and beyond. Both locations. Love these owners and their teams.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries, Mac 'N Cheese Bites, Onion Rings, Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, Hot, Fat Tony Sandwich
Svetlana K
The food is very good. But the sauces I've ordered with Uber Eats don't always show up. This evening, I requested 2 different sauces. What showed up was a handful of ketchup packets.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Graphic Impulse
Ordered 12" fat sandwich that included 4 different items inside of it - Only came with 2 out of 4 of the expected items, this isn't even a "fat" sandwich, just a sandwich with chicken and fries. Barely any inside the sandwich at that. Ridiculous.
Food: 1
Amanda Akseli
It's a take out place with amazing burgers and shakes. It does take longer than I expected for food, they also have an ap so would use that next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Beef Burger
Evon S.
Nice place to get shakes and fat sandwiches. The sandwiches are decent. Service could have been a bit better. The ambiance is decent with nice lights and the interior design. 4 stars because they are overpriced in my opinion and the service was a bit slow.
Luigi Carchia
Cheesesteak was fresh and delicious! Good job Cars!! If you need late night fix, this is the place.
Food: 5
Bichelle Harrison
I walked into this establishment to order food and asked for a Chicken Mac Burger, but instead received a Beef Burger sandwich. I called them back to make them aware and they informed me to come back in order to give me the correct sandwich and the manager on duty apologized for it. I told her that I was not able to pick up the burger until I’m finished with my clients today or either will be able to pick it up tomorrow before my sessions. She said ok and told me to bring the burger back in order for them to acknowledge their mistake when entering the order. For clarity I asked her so you want me to keep a soggy burger marinating in my vehicle and bring it back whether it’s tonight or tomorrow? She said yes. I just tossed it away and that will be the last time I go there. I only eat this way when I’m stressed anyhow so no need. I’ve never heard on a place who asks the customer to keep the food for proof to get the correct burger. So instead I’ve decided to post their mistake so here’s the proof. Poor decision from the manager. SMH
Service: 1
Abigayle “Abby” Gonzalez
I agree with some of the other reviewers this place was better 5 yr ago than it is today. For a place serving mostly fried food, it seemed like their oil was old and food not fried to correct temperature. There are other fat sandwich places that are better quality for the same price.
Average munchies/junk food. The beverage menu is my favorite aspect. Fun flavored sodas, iced teas, and lemonades. The milkshakes are the best thing on the entire menu. OG grease trucks >
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Anna S.
Too short staffed to make a milkshake. So ridiculous. It's literally half of what this place does.
Maureen R.
Good messy sandwiches. I think they need a better variety of choices. Not just gimmick sandwiches.
Michael Sabato
The food is great. Everything is fresh, not frozen. Super clean. Great variety!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Canaval
"My experience at CARS in Montclair, NJ was quite disappointing. The lady we suspect to be the manager, along with the cashier, spoke in hushed tones and seemed disinterested in being there. It's worth mentioning that we used to work there, so we're familiar with the place. To make matters worse, the onion rings I ordered were undercooked. The overall vibe was far from pleasant, and I feel compelled to call out Rich and AJ. The decline in quality is evident – the food and service no longer match what CARS used to be. It's unfortunate to see such a shift in standards."
Save your time and money!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fat sandwich delivery used to be cool until you started paying double the cost of the order in delivery fees. Hopefully things might change and this will be worth it again in the future! Best of
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Amazing customer service that you just don't get elsewhere anymore. Above and beyond. Both locations. Love these owners and their teams.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries, Mac 'N Cheese Bites, Onion Rings, Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, Hot, Fat Tony Sandwich
The food is very good. But the sauces I've ordered with Uber Eats don't always show up. This evening, I requested 2 different sauces. What showed up was a handful of ketchup packets.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ordered 12" fat sandwich that included 4 different items inside of it - Only came with 2 out of 4 of the expected items, this isn't even a "fat" sandwich, just a sandwich with chicken and fries. Barely any inside the sandwich at that. Ridiculous.
Food: 1
It's a take out place with amazing burgers and shakes. It does take longer than I expected for food, they also have an ap so would use that next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Beef Burger
Nice place to get shakes and fat sandwiches. The sandwiches are decent. Service could have been a bit better. The ambiance is decent with nice lights and the interior design. 4 stars because they are overpriced in my opinion and the service was a bit slow.
Cheesesteak was fresh and delicious! Good job Cars!! If you need late night fix, this is the place.
Food: 5
I walked into this establishment to order food and asked for a Chicken Mac Burger, but instead received a Beef Burger sandwich. I called them back to make them aware and they informed me to come back in order to give me the correct sandwich and the manager on duty apologized for it. I told her that I was not able to pick up the burger until I’m finished with my clients today or either will be able to pick it up tomorrow before my sessions. She said ok and told me to bring the burger back in order for them to acknowledge their mistake when entering the order. For clarity I asked her so you want me to keep a soggy burger marinating in my vehicle and bring it back whether it’s tonight or tomorrow? She said yes. I just tossed it away and that will be the last time I go there. I only eat this way when I’m stressed anyhow so no need. I’ve never heard on a place who asks the customer to keep the food for proof to get the correct burger. So instead I’ve decided to post their mistake so here’s the proof. Poor decision from the manager. SMH
Service: 1
I agree with some of the other reviewers this place was better 5 yr ago than it is today. For a place serving mostly fried food, it seemed like their oil was old and food not fried to correct temperature. There are other fat sandwich places that are better quality for the same price.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Average munchies/junk food. The beverage menu is my favorite aspect. Fun flavored sodas, iced teas, and lemonades. The milkshakes are the best thing on the entire menu. OG grease trucks >
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Too short staffed to make a milkshake. So ridiculous. It's literally half of what this place does.
Good messy sandwiches. I think they need a better variety of choices. Not just gimmick sandwiches.
The food is great. Everything is fresh, not frozen. Super clean. Great variety!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
"My experience at CARS in Montclair, NJ was quite disappointing. The lady we suspect to be the manager, along with the cashier, spoke in hushed tones and seemed disinterested in being there. It's worth mentioning that we used to work there, so we're familiar with the place. To make matters worse, the onion rings I ordered were undercooked. The overall vibe was far from pleasant, and I feel compelled to call out Rich and AJ. The decline in quality is evident – the food and service no longer match what CARS used to be. It's unfortunate to see such a shift in standards."
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1