Really incredible pizza place! So many unique Pies to choose from, we've tried like 8 different slices so far & they've all been outstanding! Highly recommend! Best Pizza in New Jersey! ???
The roni pizza is so good. Better than the overrated pizzas in Brooklyn. The crust is perfect and each bite is ?
Food: 5
Chris
Stopped in for the first time. This pizza is so good I can’t imagine going anyways else when I’m in Montvliar. .
Dan Kesiro
Josh gave excellent Service and was very friendly and ga6me a greadeal. The food was excellent: )
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wynona Luz
People at the front were so pleasant! Currently obsessed over this pizza. The crust and the sauce alone are magnifique, which are the foundation of all great pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Jersey Pizza, Sweet Heat
JJ Bremberg
Awesome Roman-style pizza. Less greasy than Detroit-style and just as
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
rharuckus
Found this spot a few weeks ago and am hooked on there cheeseless veggie slice. For some reason last time the girl served it to me cold. I thought maybe it was already warm but was disappointed when I took the first bite. Definitely will not go back there if I see her working. Other experiences were great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Genevieve W.
Good pizza!!!! Crust was crisp and most importantly the sauce was flavorful. I recommend this place. Please note the pizza is in the Sicilian squares only.
Matthew J.
This is the best pizza in Montclair in my opinion. They make great square pizzas but unfortunately not as tasty as the L&B style of squares. It's a little oily for my taste. But still good for what it is. I do think it's a little pricey for what it's worth. And the staff are nice but it seems they don't always have it together. Regardless, they've been great for the most part.
Greg A.
We've only ordered take out pizza. The rectangular pan pizza is larger than you might think. 8 good sized slices. Our favorite is the "Dew".
A really small dive pizzeria that has a small counter with a few stools, a few vintage magazine clippings on the wall and some pretty frigging spectacular pizza. And isn't that the point? It's the pizza, damn it and this ranks among the very best. Again, nothing fancy and typical shitty Montclair parking but the pizza was on point. Kudos.
Jersey Garbage Can Cleaners
Simply outstanding. Never tasted crust with such a great combo of crunch and chew. Wonderfully nice people as well!
chris s
Brilliant! That crust is incredible! Best tomato sauce I have ever had on pizza! Amazing!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony I.
Don't know anything about this pizza place, but was trying to give it a try today and showed up at 12:10 PM and there were no pizzas ready at all for lunch. I only get a half hour lunch break and I was told I would have to come back in 20 minutes or so. Never even got to try the pizza and will now have to find somewhere else to eat. SMH wildP.S, incredibly small place
Kirill Ivanov
New Review:The Best Slice In TownTeglia has been my go to lunch spot for the last year or so. I usually hang out at the cigar shop across the street and come over for a quick slice.Sweet Heat has become my favorite slice and it’s a true staple to the restaurant. The ingredients have been consistent time after time, when you walk in there you know you’re getting a great slice. By far the best slice in town there is no denying that.Looks like Portnoy did review this place too! I guess he must have read my old review!If you are looking for a quick bite or order out this is the place to go!Old Review:I walked out of the cigar shop across the street and noticed this new Pizza place just opened up, so I decided to walk in and give it a go. Even though they don't open until 4:00 pm they were nice enough to make a whole fresh pie just for me. Most places would just turn you around, not these guys, excellent customer service! Now for the real deal, the pizza. I ordered the Classic Jersey Pizza, the first slice just blew me away, this is not your typical pizza joint, hand crafted and top notch quality that you can smell taste and feel. These guys are the real deal, they know how to make a fantastic pizza, SOMEONE GET DAVE PORTNOY HERE HE NEEDS TO TRY THIS PIZZA!
Really incredible pizza place! So many unique Pies to choose from, we've tried like 8 different slices so far & they've all been outstanding! Highly recommend! Best Pizza in New Jersey! ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: True Sicilian, Sweet Heat, Mushroom Pie, Mushroom and Onion Pizza, Artichoke & Spinach Pizza
The roni pizza is so good. Better than the overrated pizzas in Brooklyn. The crust is perfect and each bite is ?
Food: 5
Stopped in for the first time. This pizza is so good I can’t imagine going anyways else when I’m in Montvliar. .
Josh gave excellent Service and was very friendly and ga6me a greadeal. The food was excellent: )
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
People at the front were so pleasant! Currently obsessed over this pizza. The crust and the sauce alone are magnifique, which are the foundation of all great pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Jersey Pizza, Sweet Heat
Awesome Roman-style pizza. Less greasy than Detroit-style and just as
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Found this spot a few weeks ago and am hooked on there cheeseless veggie slice. For some reason last time the girl served it to me cold. I thought maybe it was already warm but was disappointed when I took the first bite. Definitely will not go back there if I see her working. Other experiences were great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Good pizza!!!! Crust was crisp and most importantly the sauce was flavorful. I recommend this place. Please note the pizza is in the Sicilian squares only.
This is the best pizza in Montclair in my opinion. They make great square pizzas but unfortunately not as tasty as the L&B style of squares. It's a little oily for my taste. But still good for what it is. I do think it's a little pricey for what it's worth. And the staff are nice but it seems they don't always have it together. Regardless, they've been great for the most part.
We've only ordered take out pizza. The rectangular pan pizza is larger than you might think. 8 good sized slices. Our favorite is the "Dew".
Restaurantji Recommends
A really small dive pizzeria that has a small counter with a few stools, a few vintage magazine clippings on the wall and some pretty frigging spectacular pizza. And isn't that the point? It's the pizza, damn it and this ranks among the very best. Again, nothing fancy and typical shitty Montclair parking but the pizza was on point. Kudos.
Simply outstanding. Never tasted crust with such a great combo of crunch and chew. Wonderfully nice people as well!
Brilliant! That crust is incredible! Best tomato sauce I have ever had on pizza! Amazing!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don't know anything about this pizza place, but was trying to give it a try today and showed up at 12:10 PM and there were no pizzas ready at all for lunch. I only get a half hour lunch break and I was told I would have to come back in 20 minutes or so. Never even got to try the pizza and will now have to find somewhere else to eat. SMH wildP.S, incredibly small place
New Review:The Best Slice In TownTeglia has been my go to lunch spot for the last year or so. I usually hang out at the cigar shop across the street and come over for a quick slice.Sweet Heat has become my favorite slice and it’s a true staple to the restaurant. The ingredients have been consistent time after time, when you walk in there you know you’re getting a great slice. By far the best slice in town there is no denying that.Looks like Portnoy did review this place too! I guess he must have read my old review!If you are looking for a quick bite or order out this is the place to go!Old Review:I walked out of the cigar shop across the street and noticed this new Pizza place just opened up, so I decided to walk in and give it a go. Even though they don't open until 4:00 pm they were nice enough to make a whole fresh pie just for me. Most places would just turn you around, not these guys, excellent customer service! Now for the real deal, the pizza. I ordered the Classic Jersey Pizza, the first slice just blew me away, this is not your typical pizza joint, hand crafted and top notch quality that you can smell taste and feel. These guys are the real deal, they know how to make a fantastic pizza, SOMEONE GET DAVE PORTNOY HERE HE NEEDS TO TRY THIS PIZZA!