Paulie's Pizza & Cafe

$ • Pizza, Italian, Mexican

34 Easton Ave, New Brunswick
(732) 227-0900


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Paulie's Pizza & Cafe

wishing I could give zero stars. Ordered Yucca fries thinking id be in for a treat, first off it took almost 15 minutes to make the fries with no on else in the restaurant. The fries literally tasted like oil. I squeezed one in my hand and oil was pouring down my fingers. They were inedible and im a very lenient person when it comes to food. This was a disgrace and left me very nauseous. do not recommend.

ZERO STARS!!!!!!!!!! HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!!!!!!!!!! We ordered for a delivery and they were 2 hours late with the delivery and to top it, they had the wrong order. We called them several times and they said ten more minutes and it was more like an hour EXTRA. The order arrived 2 hours later and it was WRONG!!!!!!!! We had specifically asked for no bread as the person had allergies. When we called the restaurant back, they were still not understanding the order and were full review
DO NOT EAT HERE OR ORDER FROM HERE....I will never order from this restaurant again, The delivery took over an hour. When my food finally got to me it was missing things that I obviously paid for and I had the wrong order. Knowing that things sometimes happen I called to tell them it was incorrect and at that time I was a little ticked off but not as angry as I was by the end of the call. When I called and told the lady what was wrong she said she was going to go check the reciept, full review

More Reviews(31)


Monday 9AM - 1AM
Tuesday 9AM - 1AM
Wednesday 9AM - 1AM
Thursday 9AM - 1AM
Friday 9AM - 3AM
Saturday 9AM - 3AM
Sunday 9AM - 12AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.