facebook instagram facebook instagram

Paulie's Pizza & Cafe

CLOSED
$ •

34 Easton Ave, New Brunswick

Paulie's Pizza & Cafe Reviews

This is NOT BROOKLYN pizza. That said, the Grandma Bianca (square, thin crust with caramelized onion, ricotta, and sesame seeds) has been our office favorite for parties four years now. The Grandma pizzas are also cut into slightly smaller squares and people eat only two (maybe three) of them instead of the larger slices from the round pies. The other pies are not bad, but we all seem to prefer the thin crusts. We always get delivery so I can not comment on the actual restaurant.
Paulie's Pizza is located near the intersection of Easton Avenue and Somerset Street. There is on-street parking, but no parking lot. I had not heard much about this establishment prior to eating here and I wish I had. The pizza here was pretty good! The plain slice had a good cheese to sauce ratio, sporting fresh cheese and quality sauce. The cheese on this pizza was especially stringy and stretchy. The slices are perfectly sized to fold in half for convenient eating. This is...read full review
Their pizza sucks. Their pasta is amazing! Best penne vodka in town. I also liked their spaghetti, but it wasn't consistent. The first time I ordered it, there wasn't an abundance of sauce, and it had a lot of parmesan. It was seasoned well and delicious! The second and third time I ordered the spagetti, there was much less parmesan, the sauce was oilier and had chunks of tomato in it, and the spaghetti was drowning in it! It was still delicious, and I finished the sauce by dipping...read full review

More Reviews(30)

Ratings

View all photos
Updated on: