Guess my opinion doesn't matter. They've closed since being under new ownership.
John C.
It appears that Paulie's is closed for Business:-(
Johnathn Forcht
wishing I could give zero stars. Ordered Yucca fries thinking id be in for a treat, first off it took almost 15 minutes to make the fries with no on else in the restaurant. The fries literally tasted like oil. I squeezed one in my hand and oil was pouring down my fingers. They were inedible and im a very lenient person when it comes to food. This was a disgrace and left me very nauseous. do not recommend.
Kelly Smith
ZERO STARS!!!!!!!!!! HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!!!!!!!!!! We ordered for a delivery and they were 2 hours late with the delivery and to top it, they had the wrong order. We called them several times and they said ten more minutes and it was more like an hour EXTRA. The order arrived 2 hours later and it was WRONG!!!!!!!! We had specifically asked for no bread as the person had allergies. When we called the restaurant back, they were still not understanding the order and were taking it incorrectly, which was extremely frustrating and hence were agitated. the guy on the phone was very rude and unprofessional and said that he would hang up on us if we didn't lower our voice. We were starving and it was not fair to be spoken with in that tone.We called back to ask for the manager and the guy replied very rudely saying the manager is away. VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE and very bad at handling crisis. WE HAVE NEVER EXPERIENCED SOMETHING LIKE THAT EVER BEFORE.
Louis L
-Good food here ,open 7 days
Charles M.
DO NOT EAT HERE OR ORDER FROM HERE....I will never order from this restaurant again, The delivery took over an hour. When my food finally got to me it was missing things that I obviously paid for and I had the wrong order. Knowing that things sometimes happen I called to tell them it was incorrect and at that time I was a little ticked off but not as angry as I was by the end of the call. When I called and told the lady what was wrong she said she was going to go check the reciept, Instead she placed the phone down and answered another call on another phone with another customer placing an order. I sat on the phone for 10 minutes listening to her take someone elses order. The fact that she didnt think that was very disrespectful baffled me. She never came back to to phone so I hung up and couldn't get through to anyone for 5 minutes. At this point I was furious. Here I am hungry and angry and she could careless. When I did get through it was like I didnt even call the 1st time. They had the nerve to say do you want us to send the food out or forget about it. Like I didnt want the extra $10 worth of food that I paid for. These people are rediculous and VERY VERY unprofessional, not to mention the food was below average with taste. To make matters worst i ordered this food around 10 a.m. and it is now 5pm and i still have not received my food nor a phone call back from the manager. This is THE WORST RESTAURANT IN NEW BRUNSWICK. A complete waste of time.
jay west
I miss the old ownership. Use to be the best pizza in town. Serves Halaal and pork food from the same kitchen.
Monica Higgins
The first time I ordered here was great. I just placed a order for $31 and it was terrible. Ordered a crispy chicken salad with extra ranch. They gave Caesar salad with a wack a** half filled dressing. Ordered a cheese steak stromboli and it was filled with onion peppers and mushrooms. No meat! Needless to say I will not waist my money here again. Thanks but no thanks.
hamster hamster
wishing I could give zero stars. Ordered Yucca fries thinking id be in for a treat, first off it took almost 15 minutes to make the fries with no on else in the restaurant. The fries were literally tasted like oil. I squeezed one in my hand and oil was pouring down my fingers. They were inedible and im a very lenient person when it comes to food. This was a disgrace and left me very nauseous. do not recommend.
Iman M.
I ordered the steak taco bowl and it was a huge disappointment. There were two different kinds of rice in it, no mozzarella cheese, no pico de gallo or sour cream. It was like they just threw things together. If they didn't have the ingredients they should have given me a ring. I would not recommend.
Delicious homemade pizza. Fresh ingredients. I had the Works pizza. It was so good. Pricing is okay, but I understand since it's a small business. I will be back!
Randi Z.
This is NOT BROOKLYN pizza. That said, the Grandma Bianca (square, thin crust with caramelized onion, ricotta, and sesame seeds) has been our office favorite for parties four years now. The Grandma pizzas are also cut into slightly smaller squares and people eat only two (maybe three) of them instead of the larger slices from the round pies. The other pies are not bad, but we all seem to prefer the thin crusts. We always get delivery so I can not comment on the actual restaurant.
Cody Obropta
Paulie's Pizza is located near the intersection of Easton Avenue and Somerset Street. There is on-street parking, but no parking lot. I had not heard much about this establishment prior to eating here and I wish I had. The pizza here was pretty good! The plain slice had a good cheese to sauce ratio, sporting fresh cheese and quality sauce. The cheese on this pizza was especially stringy and stretchy. The slices are perfectly sized to fold in half for convenient eating. This is the recommended way for eating this slice, as the bottom of the pizza has a tendency to bend easily and dip under the pressure of the sauce and the cheese. The peppers and onions slice was also quite good. Instead of just throwing the toppings on a plain slice, extra cheese was added to the slice to hold on the toppings better. The extra cheese not only changed the appearance of the slice, but really helped increase the flavor. This place serves a good slice for New Brunswick and should definitely look into doing some more advertising.
Seema D.
Their pizza sucks. Their pasta is amazing! Best penne vodka in town. I also liked their spaghetti, but it wasn't consistent. The first time I ordered it, there wasn't an abundance of sauce, and it had a lot of parmesan. It was seasoned well and delicious! The second and third time I ordered the spagetti, there was much less parmesan, the sauce was oilier and had chunks of tomato in it, and the spaghetti was drowning in it! It was still delicious, and I finished the sauce by dipping bread into it, but it was different. Each pasta order comes with free garlic knots. I keep going back for the penne vodka. I love it.
Mark Deavult
Downtown, at the epicenter of the New Brunswick college area, Paulie's offers the quintessential college town pizza: cheap, hot, and utterly ordinary. It's utilitarian and fast, but lacking in subtlety or unique taste. This isn't a tangy, tomato-forward sauce - it's thin and heavily laden with spices.
Guess my opinion doesn't matter. They've closed since being under new ownership.
It appears that Paulie's is closed for Business:-(
wishing I could give zero stars. Ordered Yucca fries thinking id be in for a treat, first off it took almost 15 minutes to make the fries with no on else in the restaurant. The fries literally tasted like oil. I squeezed one in my hand and oil was pouring down my fingers. They were inedible and im a very lenient person when it comes to food. This was a disgrace and left me very nauseous. do not recommend.
ZERO STARS!!!!!!!!!! HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!!!!!!!!!! We ordered for a delivery and they were 2 hours late with the delivery and to top it, they had the wrong order. We called them several times and they said ten more minutes and it was more like an hour EXTRA. The order arrived 2 hours later and it was WRONG!!!!!!!! We had specifically asked for no bread as the person had allergies. When we called the restaurant back, they were still not understanding the order and were taking it incorrectly, which was extremely frustrating and hence were agitated. the guy on the phone was very rude and unprofessional and said that he would hang up on us if we didn't lower our voice. We were starving and it was not fair to be spoken with in that tone.We called back to ask for the manager and the guy replied very rudely saying the manager is away. VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE and very bad at handling crisis. WE HAVE NEVER EXPERIENCED SOMETHING LIKE THAT EVER BEFORE.
-Good food here ,open 7 days
DO NOT EAT HERE OR ORDER FROM HERE....I will never order from this restaurant again, The delivery took over an hour. When my food finally got to me it was missing things that I obviously paid for and I had the wrong order. Knowing that things sometimes happen I called to tell them it was incorrect and at that time I was a little ticked off but not as angry as I was by the end of the call. When I called and told the lady what was wrong she said she was going to go check the reciept, Instead she placed the phone down and answered another call on another phone with another customer placing an order. I sat on the phone for 10 minutes listening to her take someone elses order. The fact that she didnt think that was very disrespectful baffled me. She never came back to to phone so I hung up and couldn't get through to anyone for 5 minutes. At this point I was furious. Here I am hungry and angry and she could careless. When I did get through it was like I didnt even call the 1st time. They had the nerve to say do you want us to send the food out or forget about it. Like I didnt want the extra $10 worth of food that I paid for. These people are rediculous and VERY VERY unprofessional, not to mention the food was below average with taste. To make matters worst i ordered this food around 10 a.m. and it is now 5pm and i still have not received my food nor a phone call back from the manager. This is THE WORST RESTAURANT IN NEW BRUNSWICK. A complete waste of time.
I miss the old ownership. Use to be the best pizza in town. Serves Halaal and pork food from the same kitchen.
The first time I ordered here was great. I just placed a order for $31 and it was terrible. Ordered a crispy chicken salad with extra ranch. They gave Caesar salad with a wack a** half filled dressing. Ordered a cheese steak stromboli and it was filled with onion peppers and mushrooms. No meat! Needless to say I will not waist my money here again. Thanks but no thanks.
wishing I could give zero stars. Ordered Yucca fries thinking id be in for a treat, first off it took almost 15 minutes to make the fries with no on else in the restaurant. The fries were literally tasted like oil. I squeezed one in my hand and oil was pouring down my fingers. They were inedible and im a very lenient person when it comes to food. This was a disgrace and left me very nauseous. do not recommend.
I ordered the steak taco bowl and it was a huge disappointment. There were two different kinds of rice in it, no mozzarella cheese, no pico de gallo or sour cream. It was like they just threw things together. If they didn't have the ingredients they should have given me a ring. I would not recommend.
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious homemade pizza. Fresh ingredients. I had the Works pizza. It was so good. Pricing is okay, but I understand since it's a small business. I will be back!
This is NOT BROOKLYN pizza. That said, the Grandma Bianca (square, thin crust with caramelized onion, ricotta, and sesame seeds) has been our office favorite for parties four years now. The Grandma pizzas are also cut into slightly smaller squares and people eat only two (maybe three) of them instead of the larger slices from the round pies. The other pies are not bad, but we all seem to prefer the thin crusts. We always get delivery so I can not comment on the actual restaurant.
Paulie's Pizza is located near the intersection of Easton Avenue and Somerset Street. There is on-street parking, but no parking lot. I had not heard much about this establishment prior to eating here and I wish I had. The pizza here was pretty good! The plain slice had a good cheese to sauce ratio, sporting fresh cheese and quality sauce. The cheese on this pizza was especially stringy and stretchy. The slices are perfectly sized to fold in half for convenient eating. This is the recommended way for eating this slice, as the bottom of the pizza has a tendency to bend easily and dip under the pressure of the sauce and the cheese. The peppers and onions slice was also quite good. Instead of just throwing the toppings on a plain slice, extra cheese was added to the slice to hold on the toppings better. The extra cheese not only changed the appearance of the slice, but really helped increase the flavor. This place serves a good slice for New Brunswick and should definitely look into doing some more advertising.
Their pizza sucks. Their pasta is amazing! Best penne vodka in town. I also liked their spaghetti, but it wasn't consistent. The first time I ordered it, there wasn't an abundance of sauce, and it had a lot of parmesan. It was seasoned well and delicious! The second and third time I ordered the spagetti, there was much less parmesan, the sauce was oilier and had chunks of tomato in it, and the spaghetti was drowning in it! It was still delicious, and I finished the sauce by dipping bread into it, but it was different. Each pasta order comes with free garlic knots. I keep going back for the penne vodka. I love it.
Downtown, at the epicenter of the New Brunswick college area, Paulie's offers the quintessential college town pizza: cheap, hot, and utterly ordinary. It's utilitarian and fast, but lacking in subtlety or unique taste. This isn't a tangy, tomato-forward sauce - it's thin and heavily laden with spices.