Haven't tried their cakes yet, but their carrot cake cupcakes and pistachio macaroons are excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Gift Box, Red Velvet Cupcakes
shilpa nair
omg the best decision i made was to chose your bakery, i ordered the barbie cake with red velvet and strawberry buttercream frosting,the cake was sooo good , it was soo moist and daughter absolutely loved it , would definitely come back for more , thank you very
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julia Tyrie
Fantastic cupcakes! They were absolutely delicious and a high quality product. I look forward to trying Blue Sheep’s other products!
Brittany Alcaro
Karin & the team at Blue Sheep Bake Shop nailed my husbands surprise 40th birthday cake! The whole process from my initial inquiry to Karin delivering the cake was a breeze. All of my guests had no idea the whiskey barrel was a cake and we’re all blown away by the craftsmanship (and taste!!), all of the intricate detail on the fondant really made this cake look like an authentic whiskey barrel.I can’t wait for Karin & her team to bring my next vision to cake-life!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diane Tracy
Best cupcakes ever! Highly recommend! Ordered chocolate cupcakes with cream cheese icing and everyone said they were the best they ever tasted!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Gift Box
Maureen Ciufo
I can’t Thank Blue Sheep bakery enough for the awesome Basketball cake we had made for a Birthday party today. Not only was the cake identical to a full size basketball it was absolutely delicious. People came back for seconds and it was gone. If you want an amazing cake to enhance your party check out Blue Sheep Bakery in Somerville, NJ!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
Brittany Melville
Amazing! My husband ordered a birthday cake for himself (he loves to do that) but didn’t request anything specific beyond what was on the inside of the cake. The business texted him a few days before his special day to confirm his birth year because they wanted to surprise him. Well, they certainly went above and beyond by personalizing the cake design and making it super special (and absolutely gorgeous). Not to mention this was hands down the best ice cream cake I’ve ever had. And hubby loved it!Would 100% recommend Blue Sheep, but make sure you order well in advance if you want a custom cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dale Melville
First off I rarely write reviews but after a number of experiences with blue sheep bake shop I felt compelled. I placed an order for another ice cream cake and Karin from Blue sheep reached out to me to talk about my design. After some discussion I told them to surprise me because I am not that creative when picking out a cake for myself. I was surprised and everyone loved the design. My wife said it was the best ice cream cake she has ever had and we found out that they make their own ice cream. Needless to say we will be placing a few more orders for the kids bday and maybe even the wife's! Word of advice for custom orders, make sure you order in advance and you won't be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deborah Campano
A friend got a variety of cupcakes for my birthday. They were delicious!
Food: 5
Kelly McMahon
Absolutely delicious and always exceeding expectations. Elise, one of the bakers is an absolute master at her craft!
Blue Sheep never ever disappoints! We have used them for my bridal shower, baby shower, and daughter's first birthday. We will be returning for them for any and all future events! Their are not only stunning, they taste even better than they look!Working with Karin is a pleasure. She takes the time to understand the vision for each and every cake to get every detail right. You will not regret getting your cakes & treats from Blue Sheep!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chad Fandel
The cake was perfect! Everyone loved it. And you have to get the macaroons. Will be back again and again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Megan Chase
If I could give service ten stars I would! I ordered a birthday cake as a surprise for my sister. She unknowingly changed our plans so I called Blue Sheep the day of to ask if there was any way I could pick it up hours earlier. They assured me it would be no problem and when I arrived assured me that it was not a big deal. I was relieved and my sister was blown away! Then we tasted it and it was even better. I can’t thank everyone at Blue Sheep enough, it really made my sister’s birthday even better!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Specialty Cakes
Jennifer Williams
Words can't express the gratitude I have for Blue Sheep Bake Shop. From start to finish working with Karin was an absolute pleasure. Her expertise and professionalism were top notch! When I walked into my party and saw the cakes and cupcakes for the first time, my jaw dropped!! They were amazingly beautiful and Soooo delicious!! I had guests asking me if I still had leftovers of them the next day!!! Blue Sheep you EXCEEDED my expectations, and I would highly recommend you to everyone!!!! 5+star rating!!! Thank you for being apart of making my 40th birthday a special one!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Degenator
An outstanding experience ordering a cake for Mom's 90th birthday party. Excellent service from finding the right cake, guidance on what size, pick up and best of all, the cake itself. It was spectacular! Beautiful and so delicious. So many party guests raved about the cake and wanted to know where it came from. An excellent bakery!!!
Haven't tried their cakes yet, but their carrot cake cupcakes and pistachio macaroons are excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Gift Box, Red Velvet Cupcakes
omg the best decision i made was to chose your bakery, i ordered the barbie cake with red velvet and strawberry buttercream frosting,the cake was sooo good , it was soo moist and daughter absolutely loved it , would definitely come back for more , thank you very
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic cupcakes! They were absolutely delicious and a high quality product. I look forward to trying Blue Sheep’s other products!
Karin & the team at Blue Sheep Bake Shop nailed my husbands surprise 40th birthday cake! The whole process from my initial inquiry to Karin delivering the cake was a breeze. All of my guests had no idea the whiskey barrel was a cake and we’re all blown away by the craftsmanship (and taste!!), all of the intricate detail on the fondant really made this cake look like an authentic whiskey barrel.I can’t wait for Karin & her team to bring my next vision to cake-life!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best cupcakes ever! Highly recommend! Ordered chocolate cupcakes with cream cheese icing and everyone said they were the best they ever tasted!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Gift Box
I can’t Thank Blue Sheep bakery enough for the awesome Basketball cake we had made for a Birthday party today. Not only was the cake identical to a full size basketball it was absolutely delicious. People came back for seconds and it was gone. If you want an amazing cake to enhance your party check out Blue Sheep Bakery in Somerville, NJ!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Cakes
Amazing! My husband ordered a birthday cake for himself (he loves to do that) but didn’t request anything specific beyond what was on the inside of the cake. The business texted him a few days before his special day to confirm his birth year because they wanted to surprise him. Well, they certainly went above and beyond by personalizing the cake design and making it super special (and absolutely gorgeous). Not to mention this was hands down the best ice cream cake I’ve ever had. And hubby loved it!Would 100% recommend Blue Sheep, but make sure you order well in advance if you want a custom cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First off I rarely write reviews but after a number of experiences with blue sheep bake shop I felt compelled. I placed an order for another ice cream cake and Karin from Blue sheep reached out to me to talk about my design. After some discussion I told them to surprise me because I am not that creative when picking out a cake for myself. I was surprised and everyone loved the design. My wife said it was the best ice cream cake she has ever had and we found out that they make their own ice cream. Needless to say we will be placing a few more orders for the kids bday and maybe even the wife's! Word of advice for custom orders, make sure you order in advance and you won't be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A friend got a variety of cupcakes for my birthday. They were delicious!
Food: 5
Absolutely delicious and always exceeding expectations. Elise, one of the bakers is an absolute master at her craft!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery
Restaurantji Recommends
Blue Sheep never ever disappoints! We have used them for my bridal shower, baby shower, and daughter's first birthday. We will be returning for them for any and all future events! Their are not only stunning, they taste even better than they look!Working with Karin is a pleasure. She takes the time to understand the vision for each and every cake to get every detail right. You will not regret getting your cakes & treats from Blue Sheep!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cake was perfect! Everyone loved it. And you have to get the macaroons. Will be back again and again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If I could give service ten stars I would! I ordered a birthday cake as a surprise for my sister. She unknowingly changed our plans so I called Blue Sheep the day of to ask if there was any way I could pick it up hours earlier. They assured me it would be no problem and when I arrived assured me that it was not a big deal. I was relieved and my sister was blown away! Then we tasted it and it was even better. I can’t thank everyone at Blue Sheep enough, it really made my sister’s birthday even better!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Specialty Cakes
Words can't express the gratitude I have for Blue Sheep Bake Shop. From start to finish working with Karin was an absolute pleasure. Her expertise and professionalism were top notch! When I walked into my party and saw the cakes and cupcakes for the first time, my jaw dropped!! They were amazingly beautiful and Soooo delicious!! I had guests asking me if I still had leftovers of them the next day!!! Blue Sheep you EXCEEDED my expectations, and I would highly recommend you to everyone!!!! 5+star rating!!! Thank you for being apart of making my 40th birthday a special one!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
An outstanding experience ordering a cake for Mom's 90th birthday party. Excellent service from finding the right cake, guidance on what size, pick up and best of all, the cake itself. It was spectacular! Beautiful and so delicious. So many party guests raved about the cake and wanted to know where it came from. An excellent bakery!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5