Brother's Pizza on Rt. 33

871 NJ-33, Hamilton
(609) 586-2707

Recent Reviews

Tom Zola

I did not want to write this but I had no choice. For the 3rd visit in a row they have screwed up our orders. I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt but they continually mess everything up. It seems to be impossible to get your soup or salad before your order comes out. Tonight we ordered soup and salad we have been here a half an hour and got neither. While sitting there they then brought out our entrées which they got incorrect. I’m sorry to say after many years of patronage we will not be returning . The manager was nice and took 15% off our bill, but it isn’t about that. Just want to eat dinner without continuous issues….

Stacia Quackenbush

Been going here for over 35 years and it's never stopped being delicious. The owners are friendly and make you feel like family.Have you tried Brothers?

Carey Kitchell

Stopped here because we were in the area and wanted Italian. Chicken Francese was amazing! Will definitely be back!!


Very good! Typical casual pizza restaurant with additional items like calzones, Stromboli, salads, etc. Pizza was very good, service was even better.

Thomas Brennan

Just ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza. The kids thought the cheese pizza was “disgusting.” The pepperoni pizza was the greasiest pizza I ever had. Do not recommend.

Arielle Nami

My number one go to when I am back home and need a good slice or even a whole pie. Fun fact, when you ask for a large pie in Oregon, they have no idea what you are talking about!Been going here since I was a little girl with all my aunts and uncles, and I will always bring my girls here for some nostalgia.The best places are the ones that are original ?

Matt Ferguson

Best pizza in the area, and that’s really saying something. Two of their special pies the Bee Sting (pepperoni with spicy honey on white pizza) and the MVP (marinara, vodka sauce, and pesto over mozzarella) are phenomenal


Ordered a pizza for lunch on a weekend afternoon. Went with a meatball pizza. Pizza arrived hot and fresh. We also ordered their Italian antipasto which had three meals work of anti in it, with a wide array of fixins. Absolutely delicious. The only thing that I'd pass on is the garlic knots. While they delivered on the pungent delight, they were so oily that they very quickly became too hard.

Anthony O.

Hot Honey Pizza is absolutely great l! By far my favorite pizza in the area! Would highly recommend trying if you haven't been there before.

Richard van Daal

Great pizza and chickenwings. Pizza very tasty. We order a portion of bbq wings, half pizza pepperoni and half prociutto. Very recommendable!!

Paul S.

Was pleasantly surprised with this place. We found ourself in the area and this place had great reviews so we stopped in. I really didn't have high expectations. First our server Alana was so nice and helpful. I ordered a traditional tomato pie and my wife ordered a Stromboli. Stromboli was excellent and the sauce that came with it made me wish I had ordered a bowl of pasta. The tomato pie was a really great pie . Thin FIrm crust with a lil bit of char. Tomato sauce was really fresh and good. Lady next to us got a pepperoni pie that made me jealous it looked so good. Prices were good and just an all round great experience. We will be back when in the area.


Currently, a doctor in Princeton, formerly raised in Manhattan, ordered a "the works" pizza from brothers pizza in west Windsor, which they charged Manhattan-like whopping $29 for, which ended up being an undercooked moist raw crust, not enough cheese or toppings, which obviously we paid for at the $29 price in the middle of nowhere NJ and the pizza tasted like raw garbage and to make it all worth we all got sick from whatever chemicals they used in their sauce/ or toppings. Absolutely dreadful. Do not get conned by whichever criminals own this establishment.

Angie Kamel

Looking at the crowd you would think it's nyc pizza. It's good but not worth the girl attitude on register or that insane line. Th hey should have pain press ready to put in over for walk in customers.


Great meal and experience at Brothers yesterday (12/31). Food was great and service exceptional. Hailey our server was friendly, prompt and very attentive! We will be visiting Brothers again soon!

Michael Mostardi

They have two prices for the food, one for Cash 1 for credit / debit card. Talk about cheap. The anti pasta salad what's the worst I ever had. I called and they told me to bring it back but it wasn't worth driving four miles for.

Load More

Brother's Pizza on Rt. 33

871 NJ-33, Hamilton, NJ 08619
(609) 586-2707