Gus & Co. Seafood Market

626 Valley Rd, Upper Montclair
(973) 783-3474

Recent Reviews

Andrew Wiese

Been here a couple times. My knowledge of fish is novice at best and, I believe it's the owner, explains things very well! He is also just friendly in general. The selection appears to be very high quality and has been delicious every time. Will be back next time I want some good seafood!

Cheryl T.

Freshest seafood ever'! So glad to have Dr.Arena recommend this place. So worth the trip. No other place even comes close. Our new go to place for the freshest seafood,

Julie Glassman

Top quality seafood and service. Gus is a hard working, lovely man that is personable, honest , and always looking to make his customers happy.

Kevin Broomell

Great spot. Gentleman (assuming owner) behind counter was very nice and helpful. I wanted to make a crudo and Sashimi dish - directed me to good selections. The scallops were insanely good. Salmon was very fresh - I was just popping raw pieces in my mouth as I was cutting for the dish. It really wasn't that expensive IMO for the quality $19 bucks for 3 large scallops and 1/2 lb salmon. To eat raw? That's a steal to me. Obviously market prices change this so please do not use this as pricing guides.

Alex

One of our favorite places in all of Jersey. Great fresh seafood, super nice guy.All around great experience!

Paul

Good fish but a little expensive . He allows one customer inside the shop at a time which is good during this Covid period .

Jason Gauvin

The best oysters around! Paul hooked me up with 3 dozen oysters yesterday and they were excellent. Everyone loved them on the half shell. They were fresh, briney with a sweet finish. Just what I was looking for. Fantastic!

Carl Hazen

Excellent seafood and service.

Michael H. G.

Great fresh fish, diverse collection. The proprietor is friendly, helpful and very well informed. Check the hours before you go.

A LG

One of our favorite places in all of Jersey. Great fresh seafood, super nice guy.All around great experience!

Nancy Chukwu

Mr FRANK JAMES HAS REALLY HELPED ME IN TRADING AND MAKING A LOT OF MONEY FOR THE SUPPORT OF MY BUSINESS,

Tim Frank

Fresh, price is worth it. If he has the Manhattan clam chowder you're in luck

Martha Orbach

Freshest seafood available

Miro

Always fresh fish with decent selection. If you need something special that’s not usually carried, call the day before and he’ll have it the next day.

lee m.

Pretty cool little fish market in an area with not many choices. The owner was very nice and informative. Prices are reasonable. Very clean!

Load More