Papa Johns Pizza

2102 E Hwy 66, Gallup
(505) 722-2323

Recent Reviews

Cookie Etheridge

Went for the ny style got a regular pie. Was good, but a bit undercooked I guess. Whatever pizza is pizza I guess.

Cari Seoma

Amazing pizza got the special and it fed the family perfectly

Dylan A.

No answer, waiting for someone to answer for 15 minutes. Thought they were closed turns out they were open for Delivery. 1 star, don't recommend for Gallup residents

Tracine F.

The food was actually pretty good, but our order was completely wrong even though the girl behind the counter told us something completely different. I paid in full online and when my husband went to pick it up he paid then as well so we paid twice for an order that was not at all what was suppose to be. We will not be going back, on the bright side maybe someone got a free meal on us that night.

Ricky White

Good pizza. Excellent service.

Amy Ramos

Pizzas are always good from Papa Johns ...but I swear it's the service.. The guys have more good manners ..but not so much for the ladies .. Be friendly ..Be helpful .. suggest some ideas ?.. and tell the customers..thank you for letting us prepare your pizza the way you want it ..and tell them thank you for calling and have a nice evening or day , afternoon ..don't just hang up ..Jeez ..bad customer service

Trina Baine

I personally worked for Papa Johns for 20 years. I ordered from the Papa Johns in Gallup NM. on a snowy night. Not only did the pizza arrive on time, it arrived hot and the driver was awesome. What I really want to say is this was the best looking and tasting Papa Johns Pizza I have had in years. Keep up the great work.

Isaac Gray

Ordered my pizzas, waited and came fresh with the little sticker of freshness

Adrial Hopkins

We ordered delivery to our hotel room and it got here much faster than the estimated time. Delivery driver brought us plates, cups and napkins (without us asking for them). Our order was perfect. Excellent service!

Richard Owens Sr

Bacon mania, is the bestest.

Sharon Hardy

Great pizza always tastes very fresh and never dull. The best place to order pizza for a large family. I surely hope Papa Johns continue to keep the large orders on the menu for quite a long time. It surely helps to feed a family and save some money. Great place. Love the service, staff are friendly, and courteous.

Stacie Stagg

We went there in person and they told us it would be a 10-15 min wait. No problem for us. I mentioned I'd wait in my car and they brought it out to our car when it's ready. They brought us red pepper and parmesan cheese packets with napkins and paper plates. I've never had a Pappa John's do that. They were very patient, sweet, and understandable. If you want great service, ask for Tristan. They did an amazing job with us ^w^

CrAfty KiiD

I recommend this place the lady was nice enough to bring out my order after ordering. Inside which I tipped good. fast, clean and polite workers plus I love their pizzia ♥️

Madeline Begay

Cheese filled crust, was good.

Pearl Sloan

It was Very Poor..I waited for my Order for one hour and half!

Load More