Papa Johns Pizza

2102 E Hwy 66, Gallup
(505) 722-2323

Recent Reviews

Don Hatfield

I know this is the best pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

B. Barnes

I ordered pizza for the hotel room and OH MY GOSH they made it with LOVE! Extra sauce and fluffy crust. Man it hit the spot. That “za” was amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Timothy Martinez

Daniel did an incredible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marisa H

I don't eat this that often but when I have the craving for a papadia man this store hits the spot. The staff is always friendly and the store is clean.Vegetarian options: They do that for you.Kid-friendliness: I found that the staff was friendly to everyone.Parking: Parking is in front of the building.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, they have that also.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Wonders of Nika

The worker Vanessa was rude and unprofessional. Maybe address someone with some kindness and understanding before making them feel like they’re the problem. Don’t need that kind of negativity.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Michael P.

Great pizza, delivery guy was awesome. Didn't even ask for plates and condiments, this guy hooked us up. Thank you!

Amy C.

they delivered right to our hotel room! Nice !!! hot and tasty. wish we had Papa Johns at home!

Becca P

Traveling through ! Orders pizza from papa John’s tonight ! The best pizza I ever ordered period! Was topped right and hot!! And delivered early! Honestly wish i would have tipped the driver more !! This place is awesome!! Thank you guys!!! Best pizza I’ve had across US.

Dennis Cosens

I'm sorry to do this but if you advertise you close at 1130 or 11 that what it should mean ....not 1030 turn the 0h9nes and computer off

Artimus Protensor

They tried hard, but I think they were a bit overwhelmed, possibly short-staffed. They mixed me up partially with someone else, giving me the right pizza but also handing me some other dishes I hadn't ordered, one being chicken and the other being inside a closed box, so I can only speculate that it was bread. This was minor and easily corrected.They had also forgotten one of the two drinks I had ordered. Of course, it's always chancy to order drinks with your pizza; best to go to a gas station and buy your own, but at least I got one of them on time, and they did come back later to bring me the other.Perhaps the most unpleasant thing was that they had not adjusted the cooking of the pizza to account for the double extra cheese I had ordered, and it felt a bit soggy and undercooked. I'm not sure how much that can really be held against them though, as deviating from a restaurant's standard recipe model always does have consequences. I'll put this as an 'improvement possible' rather than a true bad thing. After all, they did as I asked and put the pepperoni on top, so that part was cooked well. The rest isn't meat, so it should be safe enough.Then of course there was the price. I used to be able to get this order for under twenty bucks, now it's nearly thirty. Other restaurants have done a far better job of resisting the absolutely stupid burst of inflation our government's poor policies dumped on us as a result of its 'wound shock' shutdown response to Covid.Bottom line, this wasn't a true disaster, and they were polite, apologetic and determined to fix their mistakes, but it was certainly not an inspiring performance from one of my favorite pizza chains.

Shawn Gomez

I love the food and reason I'm rating so low was cause I called the store multiple times before it closed, and they never answered my calls.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Dave Halls

Fast and better than most Papa Johns I’ve been too. Huge crowd made no difference.

Kerry Gashweseoma

Amazing pizza got the special and it fed the family perfectly

Cookie Etheridge

Went for the ny style got a regular pie. Was good, but a bit undercooked I guess. Whatever pizza is pizza I guess.

Cari Seoma

Amazing pizza got the special and it fed the family perfectly

Load More