The Better Bagel

45 Merrick Rd, Amityville
(631) 608-4831

Recent Reviews

Annie Bastien

Best bagels, lunch wraps, and salads.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels with Butter, Garden Salad, Bagels by Dozen, Bagels with Flavored Cream Cheese

Linda Edwards

Everything is Amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels with Butter, Everything Seeds & Sriracha Avocado Toast, Grilled Cheese, Asiago, Nutty Chicken Salad, Box of Joe, Garden Salad, Kitchen Sink Hero, French Toast Bites, Spinach Wrap w Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Roll, Bagels by Dozen, Egg Salad, Gatorade, Plan Bagel Butter Sausage and Bacon, Bagels with Flavored Cream Cheese, Bacon & Egg Sandwich, Fat Kitchen Sink Hero, Chicken Salad

DC L.

I think these are the best bagels in this area! So fresh and delicious! I'm surprised their rating isn't higher I really love them!! They have great nova (which they slice nice and thin) and their cream cheese with chives is very creamy!

Mary M.

I should have known better when I saw how filthy this place was but how could a plain bagel with butter ever be gross? I found out! A bagel with a big nasty bug in it. This store is so concerned with patrons of other businesses using their parking lot when they should be worried about their own filth! And they should be really worried about the board of health. The workers also looked miserable.

Katherine K

Place is

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Heather D.

Amazing food and great service! Whenever I go in there it's quick to get served and they have the online ordering system if you are in a hurry!

K W

Owner didn’t like military men and women. Thinks the local town works have a harder job and sacrifice more than military men and women. The place isn’t that clean either. Cooks don’t have gloves or hair nets. Generating the bagels have sweet dropping off their face, where do you think it’s landing?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Christine Dunn

For the price these people charge they should be able to afford a TOASTER. Every single time I order from this place I ask them to dark toast my bagel in hopes that maybe it will be even the slightest bit toasted, no matter what it never is and it’s usually soggy. On Friday I asked them to just burn my bagel and it still came out gross and soggy. They used to be so good but the quality has just completely plummeted downhill. I’m done giving this place any money. Got a strawberry iced tea 2 days ago that could have easily passed as nail polish remover. Tasted like literal poison. Never again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

ANN-MARGARET BARNEWOLD

Great bagels but they are not on Uber eats. This is a clean place, with d great tasting bagels. I'm originally from Brooklyn and I am a huge bagel snob. My go to bagel is a salted bagel. Shockingly, they're weren't rock hard as most places destroy salt bagels. If your kids like a sweet bagel, the French toast bagel is a must. I love their salads, and they have an array of goodies that you don't need but may buy.Please join Uber eats!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel

Sarah Francke

Great food, wish they offered Asiago on week days and more coffee drink variety.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jodi Mark

Great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Sarah S.

the egg cheese with hash brown and hot sauce on ciabatta bread was amazing. This is going to be my new local place I go to for a very excellent egg cheese sandwich. They have earned my patronage. I think the other bad reviewers didn't focus on the quality of the food. The food is as good as it gets.

Maria P.

Fantastic! Bagel of my dreams. Soft inside, crunchy outside. Perfect amount of cream cheese and toasted to perfection. Very friendly staff, clean space. Checked all my Boxes. Now our to go place for morning bagels.

Matt Ashe

Food is good quality, But literally 8-10 times the order is somehow wrong. Maybe they are just playing a sick joke on me..

Luke P.

terrible service. definitely favors wt folks never again. i call a head for the order they said 10 mins in the phone ended up waiting 30min in the store after taking my money

Load More