Valentinos Pizza

1597 Manatuck Blvd #2420, Bay Shore
(631) 666-5172

Recent Reviews

Veronica C.

Volví a este lugar después de unos 5 años porque me gustó la jalea, pero esta vez toda la comida estuvo fatal, la jalea no tenía sabor, el caldo de gallina parecía agua de gallina definitivamente jamás regresaré a este lugar

Liz C.

I was really disappointed the pizza arrived cold and without the garlic knots I ordered, they brought the garlic knots later and they were just as cold. That tells me how much they care. The sad thing is I like to buy from local shops and same exact thing happened 2 weeks ago I gave them another shot and they blew it. If I wanted to cook I wouldn't have ordered pizza I had to heat up the food before we could eat it.

East Coast Adventure ..

Got a grandma pizza and a antipasto salad. Grandma pie was sub-par....literally just bad crust and marinara sauce that tasted like the puree you get in cans almost no cheese. Antipasto was a salad in a tray with a layer of provolone, salami, and pepperoni ontop cut into little pizza slices. Literally one slice of each ingredient and by salad I mean lettuce. No tomato no onion no peppers, and the edges of the provolone were moldy. Ended up being skeeved out and threw out the salad and have had horrible heart burn from the sauce on the pie all night. Used to go to this pizzaria when I was a kid and had the munchies. Would get a slice of hamburger pie when hanging out with some friends over that way...let's just say it was a lot better looking when I was 15 and had the munchies. These stores including valentinos caters to the low income/ low class affordable housing boarderline hemlock "projects" surrounding the strip and the cheap prices and food quality reflect it. Dont be tempted by saving a few bucks like I was giving it a shot. Bill was still $30 with tip. What did I save? Probably $5 when I could've gotten a stacked salad with more ingredients and a better pie else where. I'm not mad at you I'm mad at myself for being cheap at the time I ordered tonight. Crack heads and drug dealers hanging outside constantly. Area hasn't changed in 15 years when I used to hang around here, I'm not speculating, either. Crack heads and drug dealers hang around here with the occasional prostitute soliciting a blowjob. Outside smells like stale beer and rancid urine. Delivery took over a hour and I live 6 minutes away by gps I'd reccomend trying any other pizzaria.... Give victorios 1&2 a try, or mulberry street, bonos, busetos, amores, dominos, salvatores, or even exit 42 who also got a negative review from me before these guys. Any of those places would be a better bet. I dont mean that in an offensive way, it's just a little more than opinion that those places will give you a better quality more genuine pizza/italian food experience than these guys.

Ant G.

Pizza pizza. Plus dine in restaurant can't go wrong with that rite!!!

Michelle Sara

Peruvian food is good but service is just okay since they have the tip included in the price the waitresses don't seem to be as attentive or nice. And would've been nice to know that they charge extra for using a credit card before just charging my card.

jim giarraputo

Best pizzeria on Long Island , fast delivery , nice eat in spot ...Great food at great prices

Miriam Aguilar

Right now with the best team and friends having a good time @mitierrita

Joan cortez

Really good food!

kamau osageyfo

Pizza ok the restaurant food was great Peruvian food

Phylicia J.

Best pizza and beer patties (with coco bread and cheese) around!

11DanTheMan111

Ceviche is AMAZING!!! Get a bottle of wine, relax and enjoy

Jocelyn Bleiwas

Delivery always takes sooooo long

Walter Avelar

I love the food. Chicha morada the best. Since i had it the first time. I always. Ask. For. Salmon a lo macho. Amazing. I love peruvian food and im salvadorian

Kevin Parker

don't waste your time or money and customer service is horrible

Douglas Friely

Good food , clean and good service

Load More