This place is pure gold. Excellent food, staff, feel, everything. Arthur Ave. is a treasure, thanks to joints like this. Visiting from DC (and always gotta pop by Arthur Ave.), otherwise I'd be here weekly. High-quality food/service/congeniality and very reasonably priced. Highly recommend.
Mark
We arrived early for our reservation in a monsoon like rain during closing hours. The wait staff was kind enough to let us sit inside until the kitchen opened. Everything was great from the meatballs in cheese, gnocchi and my veal dish. Can't wait for my next trip down from upstate NY M
Phoebe S
Arthur's is the definition of what a perfect restaurant should be like. Amazing and friendly staff, always filling up water without asking, prompt timing with food, and above all, delicious food. The food was seriously out of this world. The drinks were amazing too. I got a white sangria and it was to die for. I dont live close by but I am very seriously contemplating making the long drive back here just so that I can return.
Food was fantastic. Only beer and wine. A cocktail is always warranted at such a fine dining establishment. The short rib lasagna was delicious. But the Risotto Pescatore was the best dish.
Bruce B.
What an incredible find on Mother's Day 2022. They were gracious enough to shoehorn in our party of three without a reservation. A couple of incredible chicken franchaise with handmade penne and a scrumptious eggplant parmigiana with a side of handmade spaghetti awash in a delightful red sauce. Simple dishes but far from simple fare - Extraordinarily Delicious! Plus the tiramisu was to die for... How in the world could this fantastic restaurant be called Fiasco? It should be called Magnificent
Kathy K.
Probably the best past I've had in my life (and I've been to Italy). First place that I've ordered gnocchi and got more than 10 pieces. The gnocchi had really good truffle flavor, but may be too much for some. The vodka penne is DELICIOUS. really creamy and has a distinct bacon/pancetta flavor. Clam linguini is also delicious, make sure you get an extra basket of bread to sop up the leftover broth!
NYCDinerJ
Food is outstanding. Clams and eggplant apps are some of the best I have ever had. Penne Vodka has a unique smoky flavor that I could eat every day. Chicken Francese is another standout. Service is always top notch.
hungrypapa
This is a really nice restaurant with excellent food, excellent service for a fair price. You will leave this restaurant feeling satisfied. I can't think of a higher complement.
Dina
Highly recommend! I was in town for the orchid show at the NY Botanical Gardens on Easter Monday, and planned a post event visit on Arthur Avenue to walk down memory lane! Initially I was disappointed because Roberto‘s is not open on Mondays, but, Chef Roberto‘s newest restaurant certainly did not disappoint! As always, the food is phenomenal, and the staff very professional and attentive!
Rachel Ellis
Really cute restaurant with nice outdoor seating in the middle of little Italy. Next store to an authentic butcher shop. Meals were reasonably priced at under $30. The sangria was great - not too sweet. I had the gluten free penne vodka and it was delicious! All of their pasta dishes can be made gluten free minus those with meatballs. Would definitely recommend.
Sunday Italian supper was memorable and delicious. Attentive and friendly staff, very delicious food and generous portions - we enjoyed the artichoke appetizer to start, great flavors. And for dinner we enjoyed fresh gnocchi, very rich and also the bolognese pasta with ricotta. Yum! We were stuffed and didn't save room for dessert, another time! Highly recommend.
Jani M.
Love ordering from Arthur Ave Fiasco. They have great noodles and taste fresh/homemade. Definitely visit if you're in the neighborhood.
felicia
Arthur Avenue Fiasco was quite good in terms- of service, ambience, noise level and food. The eggplant parmigiana appetizer was really delicious. The gnocchi were good - large portion - the sauce wasn't to my liking, but that was just me- other people thought it was very good. I would definitely go back, as the whole experience was really nice.
Jennifer H.
I was there on Friday, March 18, 2022. Ordered the Grilled shrimp scampi over risotto. The shrimp was spoiled and I did complain but was not taken off the check. This my first and last time eating there. I was very disappointed that a manager or someone did not come out to ask me why I did not eat my food although I mentioned it to the waiter. Never again.
Vincent D.
First time explorer of Arthur Ave, The Bronx. Decided to try Fiasco and it was a great choice. Indoor and outdoor dining areas available. Interior has two sections and both are roomy and cozy. Attentive staff. Fresh, delicious food. Definitely a good choice for our first time on Arthur Avenue and a strong recommend to anyone looking for great food in that area.
This place is pure gold. Excellent food, staff, feel, everything. Arthur Ave. is a treasure, thanks to joints like this. Visiting from DC (and always gotta pop by Arthur Ave.), otherwise I'd be here weekly. High-quality food/service/congeniality and very reasonably priced. Highly recommend.
We arrived early for our reservation in a monsoon like rain during closing hours. The wait staff was kind enough to let us sit inside until the kitchen opened. Everything was great from the meatballs in cheese, gnocchi and my veal dish. Can't wait for my next trip down from upstate NY M
Arthur's is the definition of what a perfect restaurant should be like. Amazing and friendly staff, always filling up water without asking, prompt timing with food, and above all, delicious food. The food was seriously out of this world. The drinks were amazing too. I got a white sangria and it was to die for. I dont live close by but I am very seriously contemplating making the long drive back here just so that I can return.
Food was fantastic. Only beer and wine. A cocktail is always warranted at such a fine dining establishment. The short rib lasagna was delicious. But the Risotto Pescatore was the best dish.
What an incredible find on Mother's Day 2022. They were gracious enough to shoehorn in our party of three without a reservation. A couple of incredible chicken franchaise with handmade penne and a scrumptious eggplant parmigiana with a side of handmade spaghetti awash in a delightful red sauce. Simple dishes but far from simple fare - Extraordinarily Delicious! Plus the tiramisu was to die for... How in the world could this fantastic restaurant be called Fiasco? It should be called Magnificent
Probably the best past I've had in my life (and I've been to Italy). First place that I've ordered gnocchi and got more than 10 pieces. The gnocchi had really good truffle flavor, but may be too much for some. The vodka penne is DELICIOUS. really creamy and has a distinct bacon/pancetta flavor. Clam linguini is also delicious, make sure you get an extra basket of bread to sop up the leftover broth!
Food is outstanding. Clams and eggplant apps are some of the best I have ever had. Penne Vodka has a unique smoky flavor that I could eat every day. Chicken Francese is another standout. Service is always top notch.
This is a really nice restaurant with excellent food, excellent service for a fair price. You will leave this restaurant feeling satisfied. I can't think of a higher complement.
Highly recommend! I was in town for the orchid show at the NY Botanical Gardens on Easter Monday, and planned a post event visit on Arthur Avenue to walk down memory lane! Initially I was disappointed because Roberto‘s is not open on Mondays, but, Chef Roberto‘s newest restaurant certainly did not disappoint! As always, the food is phenomenal, and the staff very professional and attentive!
Really cute restaurant with nice outdoor seating in the middle of little Italy. Next store to an authentic butcher shop. Meals were reasonably priced at under $30. The sangria was great - not too sweet. I had the gluten free penne vodka and it was delicious! All of their pasta dishes can be made gluten free minus those with meatballs. Would definitely recommend.
Restaurantji Recommends
Sunday Italian supper was memorable and delicious. Attentive and friendly staff, very delicious food and generous portions - we enjoyed the artichoke appetizer to start, great flavors. And for dinner we enjoyed fresh gnocchi, very rich and also the bolognese pasta with ricotta. Yum! We were stuffed and didn't save room for dessert, another time! Highly recommend.
Love ordering from Arthur Ave Fiasco. They have great noodles and taste fresh/homemade. Definitely visit if you're in the neighborhood.
Arthur Avenue Fiasco was quite good in terms- of service, ambience, noise level and food. The eggplant parmigiana appetizer was really delicious. The gnocchi were good - large portion - the sauce wasn't to my liking, but that was just me- other people thought it was very good. I would definitely go back, as the whole experience was really nice.
I was there on Friday, March 18, 2022. Ordered the Grilled shrimp scampi over risotto. The shrimp was spoiled and I did complain but was not taken off the check. This my first and last time eating there. I was very disappointed that a manager or someone did not come out to ask me why I did not eat my food although I mentioned it to the waiter. Never again.
First time explorer of Arthur Ave, The Bronx. Decided to try Fiasco and it was a great choice. Indoor and outdoor dining areas available. Interior has two sections and both are roomy and cozy. Attentive staff. Fresh, delicious food. Definitely a good choice for our first time on Arthur Avenue and a strong recommend to anyone looking for great food in that area.