Four & Twenty Blackbirds

439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 499-2917

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Oliver Hayward

The pie was super good. Very expensive but super good.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie

Ackhilleus truva

Not welcoming place definitely they lowered quality of pumpkin pie ingredients it is also too sugary I get ıt every season i never forget good taste stuff I went there 4 times two times got rejected for only slice of pumpkin pie they said you have to buy whole pie next day they let me get slice of pumpkins it was just all so stpid to me

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tina Mua

My bf and I got two slices of pie and one coffee. Upon ordering I noticed they have a sign, “buy any two slices of pie and get one free slice of salty honey pie.”
They did not offer it to us, so I let go..
a few mins later a customer ordered a couple slices of pie and a worker automatically offer them the free slice of pie…. Makes me wonder if they forgot (I doubt it tho) or we were being discriminated…

My bf was planning to buy a few pies for the holidays, but after today we won’t be coming back.

Btw, the pies are not that great and it is not memorable.
I prefer Petee’s Pie Company in the LES.

Christina Kam

This has been on my bucket list for a while. I stopped in this morning to get a pecan pie and a few slices of other pies. They were out of whole pies but they sold me a whole sliced pie at a per/slice price. With how expensive the pie is to begin with, to be literally nickel and dimed over whether the pie was sliced was really tacky to me. The matcha pie and apple pie slices I got were okay but didn't blow me away. Petee's is so much better and so is the customer service. I won't be returning.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Sylvia Rupani-Smith

feels like a farmhouse kitchen, to someone who has clearly never entered one. I love the quiet darkness of the space: ambience is an important part of enjoying that bespoke pie. they do it all very well -love the lemon pie, and the apple, and a good cup of coffee or perhaps the mint tea which is loose leaf so it imparts more flavor. sit by the large windows and let the traffic of Gowanus roll by.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M brodesky

Tasty pies, always something different and so close to the subway at 4th and 9. Place is great anytime to hang and read a newspaper. The custard pies are all different and the coffee is bottomless.

I'm happy to see that the pies sell out each day, I just wish they had more pumpkin pie in the fall, and a half pie purchase option/mini pie

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly. Like that they strongly discourage laptop use on weekends

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Abel Girma

LEMON CHESS PIE 😱
LEMON CHESS PIE 🎉
LEMON CHESS PIE 🤩
LEMON CHESS PIE 🥳
LEMON CHESS PIE 😍
LEMON CHESS PIE 😋
LEMON CHESS PIE 🍋
LEMON CHESS PIE 💥
LEMON CHESS PIE 🔥
LEMON CHESS PIE 🤯

Vegetarian options: Pie is all vegetarian!

Kid-friendliness: Kids like pie!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Matcha Pie

Javier Kohen

The pie is good! The cortado was too bitter.

Jose Sosa Rueda

I visited this pie spot 6 YEARS ago, when I was living in Manhattan - took a trip down there over winter after seeing on social media (I think). Did not disappoint; and to this day, I still rememver the tasty pies and coffee I had that winter day. I am glad to see it is still open! I look forward to go back some day (good memories).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salted Caramel Apple Whole Pie

Jonathan Muller

This is a nice spot overall. The staff were friendly. I had a good latte and a yummy chocolate scone. The price was good too. I'd go back here again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Yasmeen El Gerbi

The pies and coffee were delicious. The woman at the front desk was welcoming. However, I have one suggestion. I visited this place on a Sunday. I was asked to leave just one hour into my visit because I was using my laptop (which disrupted my workflow). The person who did that assumed I understood the wifi password to indicate their no-laptop use policy on the weekend. This was very much not the case. I thought it was just another password (it's not intuitive). I suggest that a clearer password is set that indicates no "laptop" use policy on the weekends, or simply having this policy displayed on the wall or near the front desk for visitors to see. Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Katherine Hsu

First tried pie here back in 2014 and still can’t get enough! I am obsessed with the chocolate chess pie and stone fruit granola (the latter of which is seasonal unfortunately but an absolute must try!!). The matcha is also really yummy.

My only suggestion would be to make it possible to select the flavor for same day delivery orders (at least for whole pies if not the slice boxes) or post the daily flavors somewhere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D R-K

We stumbled across this gem of a bakery cafe while we were walking to Whole Foods. Being in NYC for business and pleasure means looking forward to seeing and trying great things, so this was a highlight of our trip. The nursery rhyme name of this establishment caught our attention, but it was the very first bite of our slices of pie that sealed the deal. If you are able to visit or haven't thought to go in and live in the neighborhood, let this be your sign to GO!

You can order whole pies as well as cookies, bars and savory pies. The coffee served is excellent and strong.

The atmosphere is welcoming, chill and
friendly. It's a comfortable place to eat in alone or with friends. If you want to bring someone something out of the ordinary order a pie and know it will be a hit!

We will remember our visits for a very long time after we return home.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A P

Refused to warm up my apple pie slice! I was so excited to try this place, but the experience fell flat. A cold slice just doesn’t cut it, and their unwillingness to accommodate such a simple request was disappointing. Will not be coming back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Jinnie

Thanks!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Loading...