Great family seafood restaurant with a very friendly capable staff.The prices and portions are more than adequate, however the surroundings and vibe are straight out of 1982.The locals are kind of the loud unappreciative and demanding customers that are detracting from this well managed restaurants potential.Change is a good thing Anthony! Your staff deserves better than low tipping loudmouths and entitled " locals". Elevate and evolve.Great staff!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
David Turkiew
Quick-serve restaurant and retail fish counterParking: Busy lot
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Crab Cake Sandwich, Fish & Chips
Timothy Perri (Osprex)
If im preparing a seafood meal at home, I shop at Catfish Annie's.Always Freash.Excellent eat in dinning also available.
Jose che
Love the menu and the staff food is
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam S.
the service was great and the workers were really nice definitely a must visit if you want amazing food
Elizabeth HD
Amazing food. Great staff. Love the owner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Delia
Amazing food. Great staff. Love the owner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela P.
Tonight we tried Catfish Annie s restaurant in Commack, it was all around great! our dinner was delicious the waitress and the rest of the staff were friendly and quick. we are already planning our next visit and are bringing family with us.
Eric Ackerman
The fish counter hasTHE BEST quality seafood around. Everything is so fresh and the cooked shrimp are like little steaks. Haven't tasted a better one around. The cocktail souce is the best also.We also love the calamari salad and the lobster salad, which I bring home and make lobster rolls for my wife and myself on a skillet toasted potato bun. ?
Nothing short of amazing family friends for a very long time family business for almost 50 yrs crab cakes out of this world seafood bisque to die for I love the stuffed shrimp.. but whatever you order is top notch food.. staff is excellent and Anthony and his wife are the driving force behind it all!! Best on long island
Catfish Annie's is a wonderful place to go dine in or takeout. The owner is a sweetheart as well as the workers there very friendly always smiling and helpful the Food is omg so good especially Shrimp Fried dinner, fried claims, and so many other excellent dishes oh and the soup is delicious you got to try it!!
Laura “TSSC” Palker
Just ended a long weekend with dinner at Catfish Annie's...the lobster and crab legs were amazing. Mitey our server was professional, efficient and attentive, I apologize for mispeling her name..and Jake her assistant was great. He is quiet but make no mistake on top of his job. Our table was well maintained. Jake removed dirty dishes quickly and always asked if we needed anything. It's nice to have a meal where people care. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Whole Lobster
S A.
This place is a complete joke. Takeout lobster salad at $80 per pound is bad enough but apparently Catfish Annies believes that a pound is comprised of 13 ounces. Consistently. The place does not look particularly clean either.
Christopher C.
Diner food - this place is seriously for old people who have no taste buds. The fish itself seemed fresh enough but don't expect anything to be cooked well. Fisherman's platter a complete disaster, shrimp boiled down to rubber. Extremely simple 1 ingredient dishes - the baked potato literally was just a potato from the oven - dried out because it wasn't even poked with holes to let the air through. Children employed as servers, atmosphere is a sad husk of something that might have been lively in 1980. Reasonable prices and I am evaluating as a restaurant, not as a fish market. My wife took one look at the food and decided she would pass. I tried everything and crossed my fingers I would not get sick. I will not be returning.
Paul Keryc
Great place to have simple seafood and for a decent price ?
Great family seafood restaurant with a very friendly capable staff.The prices and portions are more than adequate, however the surroundings and vibe are straight out of 1982.The locals are kind of the loud unappreciative and demanding customers that are detracting from this well managed restaurants potential.Change is a good thing Anthony! Your staff deserves better than low tipping loudmouths and entitled " locals". Elevate and evolve.Great staff!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Quick-serve restaurant and retail fish counterParking: Busy lot
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Crab Cake Sandwich, Fish & Chips
If im preparing a seafood meal at home, I shop at Catfish Annie's.Always Freash.Excellent eat in dinning also available.
Love the menu and the staff food is
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
the service was great and the workers were really nice definitely a must visit if you want amazing food
Amazing food. Great staff. Love the owner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food. Great staff. Love the owner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tonight we tried Catfish Annie s restaurant in Commack, it was all around great! our dinner was delicious the waitress and the rest of the staff were friendly and quick. we are already planning our next visit and are bringing family with us.
The fish counter hasTHE BEST quality seafood around. Everything is so fresh and the cooked shrimp are like little steaks. Haven't tasted a better one around. The cocktail souce is the best also.We also love the calamari salad and the lobster salad, which I bring home and make lobster rolls for my wife and myself on a skillet toasted potato bun. ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Whole Lobster, Fried Calamari, Seafood Bisque Soup, Baked Clams
Nothing short of amazing family friends for a very long time family business for almost 50 yrs crab cakes out of this world seafood bisque to die for I love the stuffed shrimp.. but whatever you order is top notch food.. staff is excellent and Anthony and his wife are the driving force behind it all!! Best on long island
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood Bisque Soup, Crab Cake Sandwich, Salad Lettuce
Restaurantji Recommends
Catfish Annie's is a wonderful place to go dine in or takeout. The owner is a sweetheart as well as the workers there very friendly always smiling and helpful the Food is omg so good especially Shrimp Fried dinner, fried claims, and so many other excellent dishes oh and the soup is delicious you got to try it!!
Just ended a long weekend with dinner at Catfish Annie's...the lobster and crab legs were amazing. Mitey our server was professional, efficient and attentive, I apologize for mispeling her name..and Jake her assistant was great. He is quiet but make no mistake on top of his job. Our table was well maintained. Jake removed dirty dishes quickly and always asked if we needed anything. It's nice to have a meal where people care. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Whole Lobster
This place is a complete joke. Takeout lobster salad at $80 per pound is bad enough but apparently Catfish Annies believes that a pound is comprised of 13 ounces. Consistently. The place does not look particularly clean either.
Diner food - this place is seriously for old people who have no taste buds. The fish itself seemed fresh enough but don't expect anything to be cooked well. Fisherman's platter a complete disaster, shrimp boiled down to rubber. Extremely simple 1 ingredient dishes - the baked potato literally was just a potato from the oven - dried out because it wasn't even poked with holes to let the air through. Children employed as servers, atmosphere is a sad husk of something that might have been lively in 1980. Reasonable prices and I am evaluating as a restaurant, not as a fish market. My wife took one look at the food and decided she would pass. I tried everything and crossed my fingers I would not get sick. I will not be returning.
Great place to have simple seafood and for a decent price ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5