Pizza was not bad. I could do without the F-bomb rap music playing while I was trying to eat.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ian McGillivray
Pretty much never open during their hours and always take twice as long as they tell you. Even totally forgot to make my pie once. I’m done
Lindsay L.
Went in there today after visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. The guy behind the counter was very nice and the slices were great. The bottom crust was crunchy and the rest of the crust was soft with that slight crunch on the top. The chicken bacon ranch slice I had was amazing. I'm so glad I tried it. It was a little greasy, but not overly so, and besides pizzas supposed to be a little greasy. Absolutely recommend this place.
Brian R.
My wife and I was visiting Cooperstown for the Baseball Hall of Fame. We were going to spend the night and then got to the hall of fame the next day. We went to a pizza place downtown area around seven and the place was closing up for the night. Then we found Sal's opened and got a pizza to go. They were friendly and had great customer service. The pizza was really good. Fresh ingredients and the sauce was very tasty. I would highly recommend Sal's.
A
Food was good. Pizza was missing cheese in certain areas. Service was okay. I can see what everyone was talking about as far as the cashier handling money and then handling food, although it only seemed like they handled food when you ordered slices vs a whole pie or something else.Parking: Free parking during the baseball off season
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Cheese Pizza
I was hungry and about to go into the Hall of Fame across the street. I think I ordered, paid, and ate two slices of pretty good pizza and a garlic knot in the space of about 10 minutes. Nice work.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Garlic
Victor Almeida
Well , this review is certainly one that will probably rock people. It’s nothing like I had ever experienced in my life time. My wife and I had visited the hall of fame a few weeks ago. Once we were done at the hall d fame , we decided that we would grab lunch O mention to my wife that maybe we should support a local place. So , we walked across to sals pizza. Entering the restaurant, we noticed that there was a 3-4 year old cute little boy wandering in the restaurant. Became quickly apparent , that he belonged to the store owner and his wife. We ordered at the counter. I ordered a slice of pizza and a bottle of coke. My wife ordered a calzone. My bottle of coke was brought and placed onto the counter at the cash register. Where little junior , grabbed my bottle of coke and tried to open it, several times. I was taken back. I looked at the owners to see their response. Neither one of them even noticed what he was up to. I just let it go , seeing that he wasn’t able to open the bottle. We paid and found ourself a booth at the front of the restaurant. Received our food. All of it was sub par. Not even close to being good. We made it a point to get this over as quick as possible. As we were eating lunch, little junior was busy using the unoccupied booth as a jungle gym. Causing disruption and carrying on as if he was in a park. Moving onto the best part of this horrible experience. We finished our lunch, got up headed towards the door. As we got up to the cash counter we noticed little junior was sitting up in the prep table behind the counter by the front window. Not only was he sitting up on the counter , he was sitting in a tray of shredded mozzarella cheese , and playing with it as if it were sand. Kneeling in this Tupperware of cheese , on his knees as if it was a sand box ! There were customers ordering food and clearly everyone saw this , but nobody said a word. Are there no health regulations in NY ? How on earth can the store owner think it’s okay to let a 3 year old sit in a Tupperware tray of mozzarella cheese and soft his dirty fingers through. Lets hope whoever is reading this post has not had any contact with that particular container of cheese. Never again will we go back there.Peace out.
Jose Angel Tollens
Pizza was pretty good, unfortunately not like NYC. Service is excellent and the atmosphere is alright. The eat in tables are not big people friendly at all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Eric Haddenham
Delicious and affordable slices and garlic knots. Perfect after 4 hours at the
My experience was a quick dinner with a meatball & ricotta slice, accompanied by a local amber (beer). Both very enjoyable quality. Staffer kindly offered a taste test of the amber before I ordered it.Quick, easy. Appropriate condiments and napkins on table. Order at counter; food brought to table. Clean (incl. the restroom). Simple booths with fun little baseball sayings and plaques on the wall.$15 for a slice, a beer, and a tip. Good dinner for the cost.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Scott Jermstad
Coming from Minnesota to check out b.ball hall of fame, I really wanted some real NY pizza.My wife and daughter also was with me and all agreed authentic Sals NY pizza was damn good. Garlic knots you also to try out. The American lager was quality beer also made in Cooperstown.Thanks for the memories!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandy Teegarden
Not handicapped accessible so I can't speak to the food or service. If you can get your wheelchair over the 6 to 8 inch curb, then I think you can get in. Or if you carry around a ramp or have a bodyguard to lift your chair over the curb. Too bad.Wheelchair accessibility: See above comment
Janet D
Very good experience. We had dinner our first night in Cooperstown. My husband had the grilled chicken Caesar salad and I got the chicken parm with spaghetti. The chicken was a little over cooked but it was still good. Our waitress MILLIE was so friendly and helpful and just very cheery. I would definitely eat here agsin. It was cute with all baseball themed things on the wall!
Jennifer Lauck
Great food. The workers were friendly and the beer was delicious. Definitely stop by when your visiting.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Style Pizza, Slice of Pizza, Sausage Pizza, Pepperoni Slice, Garlic
Pizza was not bad. I could do without the F-bomb rap music playing while I was trying to eat.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Pretty much never open during their hours and always take twice as long as they tell you. Even totally forgot to make my pie once. I’m done
Went in there today after visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. The guy behind the counter was very nice and the slices were great. The bottom crust was crunchy and the rest of the crust was soft with that slight crunch on the top. The chicken bacon ranch slice I had was amazing. I'm so glad I tried it. It was a little greasy, but not overly so, and besides pizzas supposed to be a little greasy. Absolutely recommend this place.
My wife and I was visiting Cooperstown for the Baseball Hall of Fame. We were going to spend the night and then got to the hall of fame the next day. We went to a pizza place downtown area around seven and the place was closing up for the night. Then we found Sal's opened and got a pizza to go. They were friendly and had great customer service. The pizza was really good. Fresh ingredients and the sauce was very tasty. I would highly recommend Sal's.
Food was good. Pizza was missing cheese in certain areas. Service was okay. I can see what everyone was talking about as far as the cashier handling money and then handling food, although it only seemed like they handled food when you ordered slices vs a whole pie or something else.Parking: Free parking during the baseball off season
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Cheese Pizza
Superior pizza place in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Broccoli Pizza, Antipasto Salad, Slice of Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Buffalo Chicken
I was hungry and about to go into the Hall of Fame across the street. I think I ordered, paid, and ate two slices of pretty good pizza and a garlic knot in the space of about 10 minutes. Nice work.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Garlic
Well , this review is certainly one that will probably rock people. It’s nothing like I had ever experienced in my life time. My wife and I had visited the hall of fame a few weeks ago. Once we were done at the hall d fame , we decided that we would grab lunch O mention to my wife that maybe we should support a local place. So , we walked across to sals pizza. Entering the restaurant, we noticed that there was a 3-4 year old cute little boy wandering in the restaurant. Became quickly apparent , that he belonged to the store owner and his wife. We ordered at the counter. I ordered a slice of pizza and a bottle of coke. My wife ordered a calzone. My bottle of coke was brought and placed onto the counter at the cash register. Where little junior , grabbed my bottle of coke and tried to open it, several times. I was taken back. I looked at the owners to see their response. Neither one of them even noticed what he was up to. I just let it go , seeing that he wasn’t able to open the bottle. We paid and found ourself a booth at the front of the restaurant. Received our food. All of it was sub par. Not even close to being good. We made it a point to get this over as quick as possible. As we were eating lunch, little junior was busy using the unoccupied booth as a jungle gym. Causing disruption and carrying on as if he was in a park. Moving onto the best part of this horrible experience. We finished our lunch, got up headed towards the door. As we got up to the cash counter we noticed little junior was sitting up in the prep table behind the counter by the front window. Not only was he sitting up on the counter , he was sitting in a tray of shredded mozzarella cheese , and playing with it as if it were sand. Kneeling in this Tupperware of cheese , on his knees as if it was a sand box ! There were customers ordering food and clearly everyone saw this , but nobody said a word. Are there no health regulations in NY ? How on earth can the store owner think it’s okay to let a 3 year old sit in a Tupperware tray of mozzarella cheese and soft his dirty fingers through. Lets hope whoever is reading this post has not had any contact with that particular container of cheese. Never again will we go back there.Peace out.
Pizza was pretty good, unfortunately not like NYC. Service is excellent and the atmosphere is alright. The eat in tables are not big people friendly at all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Delicious and affordable slices and garlic knots. Perfect after 4 hours at the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
My experience was a quick dinner with a meatball & ricotta slice, accompanied by a local amber (beer). Both very enjoyable quality. Staffer kindly offered a taste test of the amber before I ordered it.Quick, easy. Appropriate condiments and napkins on table. Order at counter; food brought to table. Clean (incl. the restroom). Simple booths with fun little baseball sayings and plaques on the wall.$15 for a slice, a beer, and a tip. Good dinner for the cost.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Coming from Minnesota to check out b.ball hall of fame, I really wanted some real NY pizza.My wife and daughter also was with me and all agreed authentic Sals NY pizza was damn good. Garlic knots you also to try out. The American lager was quality beer also made in Cooperstown.Thanks for the memories!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not handicapped accessible so I can't speak to the food or service. If you can get your wheelchair over the 6 to 8 inch curb, then I think you can get in. Or if you carry around a ramp or have a bodyguard to lift your chair over the curb. Too bad.Wheelchair accessibility: See above comment
Very good experience. We had dinner our first night in Cooperstown. My husband had the grilled chicken Caesar salad and I got the chicken parm with spaghetti. The chicken was a little over cooked but it was still good. Our waitress MILLIE was so friendly and helpful and just very cheery. I would definitely eat here agsin. It was cute with all baseball themed things on the wall!
Great food. The workers were friendly and the beer was delicious. Definitely stop by when your visiting.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Style Pizza, Slice of Pizza, Sausage Pizza, Pepperoni Slice, Garlic