Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown

110 Main St, Cooperstown
(607) 547-5721

Recent Reviews

Kathy M

Four of us stopped in for dinner. We ordered two large pizzas. Really didn't pay attention to the size description -- they were 18 inches and the largest pizzas we had ever seen. Also, among the most delicious pizzas. The setting is informal -- you order at the counter, but then they bring the food to the table. We took most of the pizza home and enjoyed it for another two meals. Highly recommend.

Bryan Stascavage

If you are looking for the best pizza in Cooperstown, this place is it. Pizza is delicious, service is great, prices are reasonable. Can't ask for more from a pizza joint.

Lizzie Hendrickson

Above average service and the nicest counter guy you will ever meet! The pizza was fantastic, great prices and I would recommend this pizza place to anybody.

Meaghan Stascavage

Excellent, flavorful pizza. One of the best crusts I've had in a long while.


Fast service, delicious pizzas, and as a pizza connoisseur, this is the ONLY place worth it. Hot, perfect temperature, juicy and overall tasty.

Cheryl Vanvlack

I do not recommend this place, sorry. We ordered soup, it was definitely cheap canned. Also had slices of pizza...?.never again!

Pamela Wart

We ordered a large extra cheese and pepperoni pizza with a side of Meatballs. Food was excellent. Service was also good.

Wendy L.

We stop here every year and it has become kind of a family joke that the staff is always rude. Who really cares, though--the food is good and your interaction with them is limited, since it's counter service. They've never screwed up an order and we've never been disappointed with our meal. Informal, comfortable setting--nothing fancy. Always plenty of seating. Go and enjoy but don't expect the royal treatment.

Denise G.

I live in NYC and know good pizza.  My friend and I went to the Baseball Hall of Fame and stopped for slices afterwards.  Let me just say that I have been dreaming of those slices now for weeks.  The crusts were so perfectly crispy and the sauce:cheese was perfect.  I am now trying every pizza place in my neighborhood for something that might even come close (there are about a dozen in walking distance!)  Let me know if you ever deliver to NYC! ;)

Laura Allen

I had never been in Sal's pizzeria before but I have to say I am glad we stopped in!!! The pple are very friendly and the service was wonderful!!! The food was absolutely perfect...everything was well prepared and full of flavor!!! I should know because I'm Italian and I'm picky about what Italian food I'll eat out somewhere!!! Keep up the good work guys!!! Be well and stay safe!!!???

sheri tucker

Good pizza and working to protect customers from Covid.

Heather Zirbel

Great selection of slices, friendly service. Indoor and outdoor seating!

michael panas

Great place to have your pizza while visiting the baseball world of Fame

Mark D.

Having left the area over a decade ago, the one thing I missed about this area was the pizza. This being the case, I decided to stop at this pizzeria which I had first eaten at in the early 2000s. The pizza crust is just perfect, the place was clean, and the prices were reasonable. There are other pizzerias in the area which are cheaper and staff at some of these establishments are friendlier, but for this restaurants location right next to the Baseball HOF and main street, this place is highly recommended!

KS Weachter

Wow, super thin crust, crunchy. Worth the stop fro a quick bite.

Load More

Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown

110 Main St, Cooperstown, NY 13326
(607) 547-5721