The seafood is always fresh and stuff is always warm and friendly. Great place
Chris Oliveira
This place is clean and all the food is great. Addition of Roots makes it even better!!
Janet Byler
Great food, great people! Community minded, they support great organizations like Tri Village Baseball for example, the Oyster Reef Project...highly recommend.
Stephen A.
I will say the shrimp mac and cheese was good. The lobster bisque is a little bit marginal. I got a couple of pieces of steamed lobster from the fresh seafood section, and was shocked to pay $75 a pound. This isn't East hampton. That is ridiculous. But I live and learn. Not rushing back. There was so much hype about this place, it's a glorified little market with ridiculous prices.
Joe Savino
Freshest seafood. Friendly and knowledgeable service. This is a new location for Jeff's and is much roomier and nicer than the previous location. Also there is a market where you can get other fresh items...meats , veggies etc. Highly recommend Jeff's. This is my go to fish guy.
Maura Holstein
Went there for lunch special and the place smelled like sewage. Bought a sandwich anyway but got really sick afterwards
Heather MacCaffrie
Came for there great daily lunch specials and grabbed a bunch of other things as well. If you haven’t been to there new location don’t walk but run!! fresh sushi, smoothies, açaí bowls, bakery, fresh produce and butcher and a ton more. If you haven’t tried there baked clams….. There The Best!!!!! Best baked clams I’ve ever had!!!
Jake Lee
The sushi here tastes great!
Joseph Govoni
Check it out....fresh seafood, great meats....didn't try the prepared foods but they look awesome!!! A must when you are in the area!!
This place blew it. Was once the only decent fish monger in the area when it was the old location. They sold it, moved down the road, combined it with a pointless market and doubled their prices. Add to it the quality and selection of fish is downgraded and they staffed with a bunch of kids who don't know halibut from tilapia. So sad to see a good place die. I retried it multiple times but now avoid it and go to Whole Foods. Miss the old Jeff's :(
Bruce Dulberg
Nice selection and quality. A bit pricey though.And as a store they shouldn't lcharge 3% for credit card use. It is not a restaurant.
Alexandra C.
I just left Jeff's and I'm so unbelievably disappointed by the service of this place. For the price you'd assume there would be no mistakes and everyone behind the counter would know how to make a sandwich. It took about 35 minutes to make 5 sandwiches. Nobody knew what they were doing... I heard them ask what goes into a Cesar salad wrap.... $15 for a sandwich that forgot to add the simple lettuce, tomato, mayo. I went to to check out and the young boy behind the counter was confused when we asked him to put our stuff in plastic baggies to leave. I had high hopes and heard great things but I don't think I'll be going back.
Jonathan Kirchner
I had the lunch special today. The food was great and so was the price! High quality!
Casey Allen
Great place! Went for the juice bar, but will return for the seafood & sushi.
Chowder are plus
The seafood is always fresh and stuff is always warm and friendly. Great place
This place is clean and all the food is great. Addition of Roots makes it even better!!
Great food, great people! Community minded, they support great organizations like Tri Village Baseball for example, the Oyster Reef Project...highly recommend.
I will say the shrimp mac and cheese was good. The lobster bisque is a little bit marginal. I got a couple of pieces of steamed lobster from the fresh seafood section, and was shocked to pay $75 a pound. This isn't East hampton. That is ridiculous. But I live and learn. Not rushing back. There was so much hype about this place, it's a glorified little market with ridiculous prices.
Freshest seafood. Friendly and knowledgeable service. This is a new location for Jeff's and is much roomier and nicer than the previous location. Also there is a market where you can get other fresh items...meats , veggies etc. Highly recommend Jeff's. This is my go to fish guy.
Went there for lunch special and the place smelled like sewage. Bought a sandwich anyway but got really sick afterwards
Came for there great daily lunch specials and grabbed a bunch of other things as well. If you haven’t been to there new location don’t walk but run!! fresh sushi, smoothies, açaí bowls, bakery, fresh produce and butcher and a ton more. If you haven’t tried there baked clams….. There The Best!!!!! Best baked clams I’ve ever had!!!
The sushi here tastes great!
Check it out....fresh seafood, great meats....didn't try the prepared foods but they look awesome!!! A must when you are in the area!!
Restaurantji Recommends
This place blew it. Was once the only decent fish monger in the area when it was the old location. They sold it, moved down the road, combined it with a pointless market and doubled their prices. Add to it the quality and selection of fish is downgraded and they staffed with a bunch of kids who don't know halibut from tilapia. So sad to see a good place die. I retried it multiple times but now avoid it and go to Whole Foods. Miss the old Jeff's :(
Nice selection and quality. A bit pricey though.And as a store they shouldn't lcharge 3% for credit card use. It is not a restaurant.
I just left Jeff's and I'm so unbelievably disappointed by the service of this place. For the price you'd assume there would be no mistakes and everyone behind the counter would know how to make a sandwich. It took about 35 minutes to make 5 sandwiches. Nobody knew what they were doing... I heard them ask what goes into a Cesar salad wrap.... $15 for a sandwich that forgot to add the simple lettuce, tomato, mayo. I went to to check out and the young boy behind the counter was confused when we asked him to put our stuff in plastic baggies to leave. I had high hopes and heard great things but I don't think I'll be going back.
I had the lunch special today. The food was great and so was the price! High quality!
Great place! Went for the juice bar, but will return for the seafood & sushi.