was raised on this place’s food since birth, & my daughter loves it & she’s 6. Kinda heartbroken from going months without it. & Now Huntington pizza is just trash without it. Sigh.
Food: 5
Anthony Degroff
This was by far the best pizza on long island and in New York that I have ever been to in my life. It's very upsetting that they're closed, I hope they open back up.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel Delgado
This pizzera has been the staple pizza for my family since before I was born! My mother would eat this pizza when she was pregnant with me (1993) and when I tell you no pizza comes close then that means NO PIZZA COMES CLOSE!!! My sisters are crazy for this pizza too, when one of them comes around from PA she knows the first place she needs to stop by is Guiseppe’s Pizza. In fact, I’m current doing a 40 day fast and I know just what I’m going to eat to break my fast. You guessed it, GUISEPPE’S PIZZA!! This place better not go anywhere because let me tell you it’s not only the food that’s great but the whole experience makes you feel like you just left a family reunion. Guiseppe’s when are you going to start making some commercials? The people have to know!! Ask for the original sauce, (the sweet sauce) and get hooked like my family and I.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael T
These guys need to come back, grew up on this pizza and absolutely miss
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sweet Pizza
Michael
Unfortunate that they went out of business but as someone living in the area, I could’ve seen this coming. It was a kind of a hot mess in there. Always chaos even when the owner was around. He could not find good help. The teenage girls that worked there just didn’t care what was happening. I would show up 30 minutes after ordering $50 of food and it was never even started. When I worked for Grubhub it was even worse. Would arrive on time and they would say “oh we didn’t see the order! That will be a few more minutes. Only for it to be about 25 minutes. That will always be the decline of a business, customer service is key.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Omar Rosales
Drove past the other day, realizing it was actually closed for good.. grew up on it Anytime I'd be back in town n was in the mood for pizza, this was the spot.Sesame crust was great, n their sweet sauce ??.. crazy, not a lot of pizzeria do sweet sauce
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Jordan
Really great pizza. I usually get a pepperoni pie with traditional sauce and no sesame seeds. They are very accommodating and have the old-school classic flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Gorman
Greatest pizza in the world. Best in NY. The sweet sauce and the sesame seed crust absolutely amazing. Please come back we need you I have been a fan for years
Mr. Shlock
Joe's shop and people WERE a great neighborhood cornerstone -- now out of business. First Joe was on the decline personally, poor guy, then he couldn't buy soda, then he couldn't accept credit cards, now no-one will answer the phone for pickups or deliveries again. Shame...
Melissa DiGirolamo
Pizza is great but placed a Superbowl food order online. They took the money from my account. They were closed when I got there. No food for the game. I called today with no answer. I don't know how they have good reviews 2 days ago when they're not even open.
I like their pizza with the sweet sauce and sesame seed crust. They will add extras of your choice. Nice service!
Freckled Mom
My grandma and I took a girls trip to Mill Falls at the Lake and decided to get dinner after our long drive. My grandma told me a story about a waiter who she met a few years earlier, she told me how excited he was about his unborn child and how great he was! Our waiter came to our table and was very attentive- my grandmother asked him if he had a baby a few years earlier, and he lit up and ran for his phone. It was an added bonus meeting Brian; the food was amazing! Everything was delicious: salads, pizza, entrees, and dessert! I would recommend this restaurant… lunch, dinner, music; an evening with friends!
Temperance Sagittarius
So the pizza was fresh today. But The child working behind the counter tried to charge me a $1.00 extra to put the pizza in a box. Management needs better staff.
Rafia A.
A trip back home to NY is never complete without pizza from Guiseppe's. Absolutely to die for. The sweet sauce is the best twist I have ever tasted in pizza. Their pies are always made to perfection and the service is always friendly. I have been going here for over 20 years, nothing else compares!
Toni Romano
pizza was delicious my boyfriend had a reg slice and a sweet slice ... I had a Caesar salad slice crust was amazing on all ... mine had so much chicken .... Definitely will be going back again
was raised on this place’s food since birth, & my daughter loves it & she’s 6. Kinda heartbroken from going months without it. & Now Huntington pizza is just trash without it. Sigh.
Food: 5
This was by far the best pizza on long island and in New York that I have ever been to in my life. It's very upsetting that they're closed, I hope they open back up.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizzera has been the staple pizza for my family since before I was born! My mother would eat this pizza when she was pregnant with me (1993) and when I tell you no pizza comes close then that means NO PIZZA COMES CLOSE!!! My sisters are crazy for this pizza too, when one of them comes around from PA she knows the first place she needs to stop by is Guiseppe’s Pizza. In fact, I’m current doing a 40 day fast and I know just what I’m going to eat to break my fast. You guessed it, GUISEPPE’S PIZZA!! This place better not go anywhere because let me tell you it’s not only the food that’s great but the whole experience makes you feel like you just left a family reunion. Guiseppe’s when are you going to start making some commercials? The people have to know!! Ask for the original sauce, (the sweet sauce) and get hooked like my family and I.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
These guys need to come back, grew up on this pizza and absolutely miss
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sweet Pizza
Unfortunate that they went out of business but as someone living in the area, I could’ve seen this coming. It was a kind of a hot mess in there. Always chaos even when the owner was around. He could not find good help. The teenage girls that worked there just didn’t care what was happening. I would show up 30 minutes after ordering $50 of food and it was never even started. When I worked for Grubhub it was even worse. Would arrive on time and they would say “oh we didn’t see the order! That will be a few more minutes. Only for it to be about 25 minutes. That will always be the decline of a business, customer service is key.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Drove past the other day, realizing it was actually closed for good.. grew up on it Anytime I'd be back in town n was in the mood for pizza, this was the spot.Sesame crust was great, n their sweet sauce ??.. crazy, not a lot of pizzeria do sweet sauce
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really great pizza. I usually get a pepperoni pie with traditional sauce and no sesame seeds. They are very accommodating and have the old-school classic flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greatest pizza in the world. Best in NY. The sweet sauce and the sesame seed crust absolutely amazing. Please come back we need you I have been a fan for years
Joe's shop and people WERE a great neighborhood cornerstone -- now out of business. First Joe was on the decline personally, poor guy, then he couldn't buy soda, then he couldn't accept credit cards, now no-one will answer the phone for pickups or deliveries again. Shame...
Pizza is great but placed a Superbowl food order online. They took the money from my account. They were closed when I got there. No food for the game. I called today with no answer. I don't know how they have good reviews 2 days ago when they're not even open.
Restaurantji Recommends
I like their pizza with the sweet sauce and sesame seed crust. They will add extras of your choice. Nice service!
My grandma and I took a girls trip to Mill Falls at the Lake and decided to get dinner after our long drive. My grandma told me a story about a waiter who she met a few years earlier, she told me how excited he was about his unborn child and how great he was! Our waiter came to our table and was very attentive- my grandmother asked him if he had a baby a few years earlier, and he lit up and ran for his phone. It was an added bonus meeting Brian; the food was amazing! Everything was delicious: salads, pizza, entrees, and dessert! I would recommend this restaurant… lunch, dinner, music; an evening with friends!
So the pizza was fresh today. But The child working behind the counter tried to charge me a $1.00 extra to put the pizza in a box. Management needs better staff.
A trip back home to NY is never complete without pizza from Guiseppe's. Absolutely to die for. The sweet sauce is the best twist I have ever tasted in pizza. Their pies are always made to perfection and the service is always friendly. I have been going here for over 20 years, nothing else compares!
pizza was delicious my boyfriend had a reg slice and a sweet slice ... I had a Caesar salad slice crust was amazing on all ... mine had so much chicken .... Definitely will be going back again