Tried ordering delivery as our son was home sick with the flu and we just needed a night off from cooking....food never arrived, upon calling they insisted it was delivered, and refused to refund our order despite it never arriving!
Vivian R.
Stopped in for a Chicken Caesar Slice. It was a little different than the normal. Love the fact that it is loaded with chicken. The bottom part usually is a pizza crust. This one is more like a focaccia dough. The dressing is on the sweet side. Everything looked delicious. Definitely will come back & try other pizzas
John Atkinson
I ordered to specialty slices. The girl put them in the oven went to help someone else. Comes back to help my wife. Puts two slices of specialty pizza in the oven for her. Seemed to forget about my slices. Takes mine out at the same time as my wife's. They were burnt! She wrapped them up and gave them to me anyway.
Food: 1
Service: 1
anthony cardone
One of the best pizza places on Long Island! The dough is delicious, and ingredients fresh and high quality. Service was attentive and wonderful. I’m a new customer and will be back many many times. Thank you to La Nonna’s!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
T Black
Basic pizzeria to grab and go..not necessarily to dine in.Staff are great!!Owner is pleasant and actually has a restaurant as well in Roslyn. Great food (brass swan...check it out)!Grandma slices are yummyPenne a la vodka slices are yummyGreat saladsCaesar slice is yummyGreat parm sandwiches...Tri colored pizza with pesto...phenomenal!!!About the wings though...they're fried way toooooo hard. Sometimes very dry....if they can fix that, they'll be top notch!Robert the delivery guy is awesome ??Ana at the counter is awesome ??Been going there 10 years!!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Garlic Knots, Grandma Pie, Vodka Meatball Square Pizza, Meatball Vodka Pizza, Meatball Vodka Square Pie, Large Pizzas, Grandma, Meatball Hero with Marinara Sauce and Meatballs, Pie
Matthew T, CPA
Went here for a few slices. It was $11 for a Sicilian and a chicken ranch slice, should be $4.50 for a speciality $3.50 for a regular. They’re way over priced. And food is okay to sub bar at best. Go somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Wolf O.
Still the best pizza in the area, having sampled them all. La Nonna's classic slice is a perfect balance of thin cheese, sweet sauce, and light, crispy crust. It's lighter than La Scala's, sweeter than Mario's, and less cheesy than the others on Jericho. It ranks with Little Vincent's, which is further away, and belongs in any Long Island top pizza list. Their grandma's slice is great too, though it gets strangely watery sometimes. Lots of other great plate selections too!
Terrible service. I ordered delivery through the slice app. After hour and half, I contacted the store and was told they had left it outside. Lies, nothing was outside. Credit card was charged and got nothing after waiting 2 hours.Shady place, don’t eat here.
Service: 1
John Palminteri
Been going here for years. Food is always good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pie
.Larry Monegro
Joe, the owner, is great. The food is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Large Pizzas
Leah G.
3 stars for the food in the past I've had which was great. I'm taking away two stars based on service today. Otherwise it would have been 4/5 star review. Called to place a takeout order - answer was a young lady who said hold please. Waited several minutes. Then I hung up. Figured just a long takeout call. Called back 20 mins later while driving, again put right on hold by a girl answering the phone. Never answered it again, wasted several minutes so I hung up. I gave up and went down to rosas in the village. Phone service was fast, and pizza was ready when I got there.
Elizabeth B (Beth)
I can not say enough about how good this place is. Not only was the food amazing but the staff is very friendly and they have always been kind to my partner when he goes in to pick up deliveries. He even feels comfortable enough to talk to them when he is in there. We will most definitely be going back to eat there, including late lunch today. It smelled so great that we decided to try it one night and the food was amazing and the staff was still just as nice.
My go to pizzeria in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Specialty slices are great. Always
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent pizza spot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tried ordering delivery as our son was home sick with the flu and we just needed a night off from cooking....food never arrived, upon calling they insisted it was delivered, and refused to refund our order despite it never arriving!
Stopped in for a Chicken Caesar Slice. It was a little different than the normal. Love the fact that it is loaded with chicken. The bottom part usually is a pizza crust. This one is more like a focaccia dough. The dressing is on the sweet side. Everything looked delicious. Definitely will come back & try other pizzas
I ordered to specialty slices. The girl put them in the oven went to help someone else. Comes back to help my wife. Puts two slices of specialty pizza in the oven for her. Seemed to forget about my slices. Takes mine out at the same time as my wife's. They were burnt! She wrapped them up and gave them to me anyway.
Food: 1
Service: 1
One of the best pizza places on Long Island! The dough is delicious, and ingredients fresh and high quality. Service was attentive and wonderful. I’m a new customer and will be back many many times. Thank you to La Nonna’s!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Basic pizzeria to grab and go..not necessarily to dine in.Staff are great!!Owner is pleasant and actually has a restaurant as well in Roslyn. Great food (brass swan...check it out)!Grandma slices are yummyPenne a la vodka slices are yummyGreat saladsCaesar slice is yummyGreat parm sandwiches...Tri colored pizza with pesto...phenomenal!!!About the wings though...they're fried way toooooo hard. Sometimes very dry....if they can fix that, they'll be top notch!Robert the delivery guy is awesome ??Ana at the counter is awesome ??Been going there 10 years!!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Garlic Knots, Grandma Pie, Vodka Meatball Square Pizza, Meatball Vodka Pizza, Meatball Vodka Square Pie, Large Pizzas, Grandma, Meatball Hero with Marinara Sauce and Meatballs, Pie
Went here for a few slices. It was $11 for a Sicilian and a chicken ranch slice, should be $4.50 for a speciality $3.50 for a regular. They’re way over priced. And food is okay to sub bar at best. Go somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Still the best pizza in the area, having sampled them all. La Nonna's classic slice is a perfect balance of thin cheese, sweet sauce, and light, crispy crust. It's lighter than La Scala's, sweeter than Mario's, and less cheesy than the others on Jericho. It ranks with Little Vincent's, which is further away, and belongs in any Long Island top pizza list. Their grandma's slice is great too, though it gets strangely watery sometimes. Lots of other great plate selections too!
Restaurantji Recommends
Terrible service. I ordered delivery through the slice app. After hour and half, I contacted the store and was told they had left it outside. Lies, nothing was outside. Credit card was charged and got nothing after waiting 2 hours.Shady place, don’t eat here.
Service: 1
Been going here for years. Food is always good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pie
Joe, the owner, is great. The food is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Large Pizzas
3 stars for the food in the past I've had which was great. I'm taking away two stars based on service today. Otherwise it would have been 4/5 star review. Called to place a takeout order - answer was a young lady who said hold please. Waited several minutes. Then I hung up. Figured just a long takeout call. Called back 20 mins later while driving, again put right on hold by a girl answering the phone. Never answered it again, wasted several minutes so I hung up. I gave up and went down to rosas in the village. Phone service was fast, and pizza was ready when I got there.
I can not say enough about how good this place is. Not only was the food amazing but the staff is very friendly and they have always been kind to my partner when he goes in to pick up deliveries. He even feels comfortable enough to talk to them when he is in there. We will most definitely be going back to eat there, including late lunch today. It smelled so great that we decided to try it one night and the food was amazing and the staff was still just as nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5