Service was exceptional!! Highly recommend the branzino the linguine. Marlin was a wonderful waiter.. we will be back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Branzino
EvanL
Food was great. Had the porchetta appetizer. Delicious. Had the Bolognese for dinner. Also terrific. My wife had the tuna tartar and salmon. She loved them both. A great night, as always.
Jessica22
We never leave disappointed! We had the mushroom rice balls, tuna tartar, the lamb special and the linguine with crab special. All were FANTASTIC. I even requested to make the linguine a little spicy and the chef delivered. We finished our dinner with the dog cheesecake (also a special) and an espresso martini. Jonathans is a hidden gem with amazing food and service!
CliffordS
Every dish was perfectly cooked. The pork chop and tuna appetizer were particularly remarkable. The pork chop was cooked to a precise medium—juicy and flavorful, avoiding the common pitfall of dryness found in other establishments. The service was impeccable; attentive and helpful, reminiscent of the high standards seen in New York's finest restaurants. Having visited multiple times, it's clear they've elevated their game across the board.
Dan
My wife and I had dinner here last week; they asked us to leave the minute we finished our dinner. Still had our last ordered drinks unfinished. They said they needed the table for the next party. Our dinner was of normal length, no aps, ordered as soon as we sat down. Over 200 bill with tip for just the two of us.
Livagirl
Always a friendly environment. Upbeat but never too loud or harried. Servers always pleasant. Food reliably well prepared and tasty. Nice ambience combined with good dining. A favorite place.
Jane Monti
Manager Alex was a pro from start to finish when we held a family milestone party at Jonathan's! The food, wine selection, atmosphere and overall event was exactly what we had hoped for. We'd highly recommend Jonathan's for a private event or just a night out for a delicious meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Keith Friedlander
It is one of the very best restaurants on Long Island if not the entire region.An extensive wine list accompanied by innovative, consistent, delicious, and beautifully prepared foods makes this restaurant unique. Prices are consistent with the quality but not unreasonable.Servers are professional but not stiff, and the ambiance is joyous and can be loud if seated in the bar area.A surprising and delicious entree is the perfectly prepared prime NY Strip, which is served with a side of shoestring potatoes and is as good as any served in a steak house.
30+ years enjoying this fine establishment. Blessed by many good local restaurants which have stayed the course in Huntington, and this is one. Distinction here are fresh pasta, made on site, and we sampled two last night (chitarra + linguini), plus 'chokes, steak (perfectly prepared with inventive condiments + pounds of spinach). Excellent wine-by-serving selections. Joy to be here!
JohnC
They have ineffective management running restaurant. Had to leave restaurant for failure to serve dinner. Waited over an hour from appetizer being removed. Need better kitchen management, ticket control and more experience in providing customer service.
Jonathan's is easily the best restaurant in the village. The food is always fresh, the staff is kind, professional and happy to be working. It is truly a gem and our village is so lucky to have it.
My husband and recently moved to Huntington and this was our first dinner out; it did not disappoint. Everything was delicious and the service was wonderful. We will definitely be coming back again soon!
Duck Breast was probably the best I have ever had (and I have ordered duck all over the world at least 30 times). Ample portion and simply prepared with crisp outside and medium rare throughout. No heavy sauce just perfect duck flavor complimented with poached pear and pistachios. Top 5 entree I've had in Huntington in the past few years. Needs to always be on the menu!
Eloise
We and our two guests had a great meal, excellent service, a good wine, and a good time. I had the most delicious eggplant parm I have ever eaten in a restaurant - and that is saying a lot!
JaneG
We've been dining here x 25 yrs and they have never disappointed. Service, quality of food and wine has consistently been top notch. Just had another winner last nite w friends. Fabulous bread (always!), bolognese, Caesar salad, scallops - all perfect.
Service was exceptional!! Highly recommend the branzino the linguine. Marlin was a wonderful waiter.. we will be back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Branzino
Food was great. Had the porchetta appetizer. Delicious. Had the Bolognese for dinner. Also terrific. My wife had the tuna tartar and salmon. She loved them both. A great night, as always.
We never leave disappointed! We had the mushroom rice balls, tuna tartar, the lamb special and the linguine with crab special. All were FANTASTIC. I even requested to make the linguine a little spicy and the chef delivered. We finished our dinner with the dog cheesecake (also a special) and an espresso martini. Jonathans is a hidden gem with amazing food and service!
Every dish was perfectly cooked. The pork chop and tuna appetizer were particularly remarkable. The pork chop was cooked to a precise medium—juicy and flavorful, avoiding the common pitfall of dryness found in other establishments. The service was impeccable; attentive and helpful, reminiscent of the high standards seen in New York's finest restaurants. Having visited multiple times, it's clear they've elevated their game across the board.
My wife and I had dinner here last week; they asked us to leave the minute we finished our dinner. Still had our last ordered drinks unfinished. They said they needed the table for the next party. Our dinner was of normal length, no aps, ordered as soon as we sat down. Over 200 bill with tip for just the two of us.
Always a friendly environment. Upbeat but never too loud or harried. Servers always pleasant. Food reliably well prepared and tasty. Nice ambience combined with good dining. A favorite place.
Manager Alex was a pro from start to finish when we held a family milestone party at Jonathan's! The food, wine selection, atmosphere and overall event was exactly what we had hoped for. We'd highly recommend Jonathan's for a private event or just a night out for a delicious meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
It is one of the very best restaurants on Long Island if not the entire region.An extensive wine list accompanied by innovative, consistent, delicious, and beautifully prepared foods makes this restaurant unique. Prices are consistent with the quality but not unreasonable.Servers are professional but not stiff, and the ambiance is joyous and can be loud if seated in the bar area.A surprising and delicious entree is the perfectly prepared prime NY Strip, which is served with a side of shoestring potatoes and is as good as any served in a steak house.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Flourless Chocolate Cake with Coffee Gelato & Caramel Sauce
30+ years enjoying this fine establishment. Blessed by many good local restaurants which have stayed the course in Huntington, and this is one. Distinction here are fresh pasta, made on site, and we sampled two last night (chitarra + linguini), plus 'chokes, steak (perfectly prepared with inventive condiments + pounds of spinach). Excellent wine-by-serving selections. Joy to be here!
They have ineffective management running restaurant. Had to leave restaurant for failure to serve dinner. Waited over an hour from appetizer being removed. Need better kitchen management, ticket control and more experience in providing customer service.
Restaurantji Recommends
Jonathan's is easily the best restaurant in the village. The food is always fresh, the staff is kind, professional and happy to be working. It is truly a gem and our village is so lucky to have it.
My husband and recently moved to Huntington and this was our first dinner out; it did not disappoint. Everything was delicious and the service was wonderful. We will definitely be coming back again soon!
Duck Breast was probably the best I have ever had (and I have ordered duck all over the world at least 30 times). Ample portion and simply prepared with crisp outside and medium rare throughout. No heavy sauce just perfect duck flavor complimented with poached pear and pistachios. Top 5 entree I've had in Huntington in the past few years. Needs to always be on the menu!
We and our two guests had a great meal, excellent service, a good wine, and a good time. I had the most delicious eggplant parm I have ever eaten in a restaurant - and that is saying a lot!
We've been dining here x 25 yrs and they have never disappointed. Service, quality of food and wine has consistently been top notch. Just had another winner last nite w friends. Fabulous bread (always!), bolognese, Caesar salad, scallops - all perfect.