I love this place. I ate here almost every week for more than thirty years. I don't live on the island anymore and this place is one of the things I really miss. In fact whenever I come back to Huntington I make a point of stopping in to see the crew and have a slice and some garlic knots or something else. I love the heroes and calzone. The salads are good too. Give it a try! They offer great service and delivery and over fifty years serving the community.
Lynn l.
Been going to this pizza place since I was a kid and junior high school and I love it. Still taste as delicious. Very happy that they are still in business. Good food, good people.
Carrie Schmermund
We ordered the family meal which we haven’t had in a few years. In the past the meal was delicious and well priced. This time we were not as pleased with it as we had been in the past. The meatballs were underwhelming, pizza and baked ziti tasted old and the garlic knots were stale. I’ll try it again because any place can have an off night. It used to be the best place around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Steven
After recently moving to Huntington and trying every pizza place in town, Southdown Pizza is the best and the only place we’ll order from! They’re not overpriced like every other pizza place in town and the food is delicious every time! Fast service, delicious food, and wonderful staff!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frederick Schneider
Best thin crust pizza in Huntington, great heros tooParking: Park right in front of restaurant
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Minub Ronge
Pretty sure they dumped sugar all over my pasta when I asked for it to be spicy everyone on the table that tasted the pasta said it was super sweet and they just said that’s how they make it,
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
matt C
I went in there because I was in the area I got a buffalo chicken slice. This is the worst slice of pizza I’ve had in my entire life. What a disgrace I’ll never go there again.
Andres Zambrano
The worst pizza EVER ...EVER NO taste No flavor the price is so cheap....maybe that's why the pizza is so bad.
o k
Fresh but too much oil sometimes, whew... easy on the oil please. Pizza doesn't need that much oil.
It’s absolutely the worst Pizza I’ve ever had. I ordered the Margherita pizza, and it was not. The sauce tasted like unseasoned tomato paste, and the “fresh mozzarella” had the texture of rubber. So disappointed. What a waste of money.
Diane G.
THANK YOU to Southdown Pizza! Yesterday, my very confused, 90 year old mother called and placed an order with them and the owner and staff were so kind to deliver her a meal "on the house". When she told me that I called them to find out what had happened. They said that she was very confused and the owner was worried about her so he told them to go over and check up on her. That was so kind of them. It's nice to know that there are still, thoughtful and kind people out there that do the right thing. I hope that anybody reading this will support this little business in our neighborhood. They are the best!
Bill Albert
Great food! Excellent specials.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Solow Sports
Nice staff making you feel like family in this long time pizza place with tons of Italian classics and specialty slices.
Worst pizza I have ever had in NY
I love this place. I ate here almost every week for more than thirty years. I don't live on the island anymore and this place is one of the things I really miss. In fact whenever I come back to Huntington I make a point of stopping in to see the crew and have a slice and some garlic knots or something else. I love the heroes and calzone. The salads are good too. Give it a try! They offer great service and delivery and over fifty years serving the community.
Been going to this pizza place since I was a kid and junior high school and I love it. Still taste as delicious. Very happy that they are still in business. Good food, good people.
We ordered the family meal which we haven’t had in a few years. In the past the meal was delicious and well priced. This time we were not as pleased with it as we had been in the past. The meatballs were underwhelming, pizza and baked ziti tasted old and the garlic knots were stale. I’ll try it again because any place can have an off night. It used to be the best place around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
After recently moving to Huntington and trying every pizza place in town, Southdown Pizza is the best and the only place we’ll order from! They’re not overpriced like every other pizza place in town and the food is delicious every time! Fast service, delicious food, and wonderful staff!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best thin crust pizza in Huntington, great heros tooParking: Park right in front of restaurant
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Pretty sure they dumped sugar all over my pasta when I asked for it to be spicy everyone on the table that tasted the pasta said it was super sweet and they just said that’s how they make it,
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I went in there because I was in the area I got a buffalo chicken slice. This is the worst slice of pizza I’ve had in my entire life. What a disgrace I’ll never go there again.
The worst pizza EVER ...EVER NO taste No flavor the price is so cheap....maybe that's why the pizza is so bad.
Fresh but too much oil sometimes, whew... easy on the oil please. Pizza doesn't need that much oil.
Restaurantji Recommends
Buffalo Chicken slice was really bad lol
It’s absolutely the worst Pizza I’ve ever had. I ordered the Margherita pizza, and it was not. The sauce tasted like unseasoned tomato paste, and the “fresh mozzarella” had the texture of rubber. So disappointed. What a waste of money.
THANK YOU to Southdown Pizza! Yesterday, my very confused, 90 year old mother called and placed an order with them and the owner and staff were so kind to deliver her a meal "on the house". When she told me that I called them to find out what had happened. They said that she was very confused and the owner was worried about her so he told them to go over and check up on her. That was so kind of them. It's nice to know that there are still, thoughtful and kind people out there that do the right thing. I hope that anybody reading this will support this little business in our neighborhood. They are the best!
Great food! Excellent specials.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice staff making you feel like family in this long time pizza place with tons of Italian classics and specialty slices.