The pizza is very good. I would go back for a pizza any day of the week. Thin crust, perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni.
Josh Bush
Went to Ithaca Beer co but prices and service were bad. Stopped at Sammy's and the food was absolutely delicious.
Jack Morgan
Soda fountain had no syrup, guy behind the counter just shrugged and walked away. Pizza was ok, not really worth the price. Place was filthy, looked like it hadn't been cleaned in a week. Only went here because it was the only pizza place open that wasn't Dominos. Kinda wish i'd gone there instead.
Desh Cooper
Convenient location in the commons. Everything seemed relatively clean when I went. The bomber sandwich and fries I got were nice and fresh. Good service and friendly staff.
Debi Davis
Really love their pizza and atmosphere. Always very happy ? and friendly. Reasonable prices.
Joseph Cole
Great pizza, and even better kabab!!
Sam Vit
Great pizza place and the best garlic knots. The owner was very friendly and made us feel very welcome.
Brandi Pompey
Can’t beat the prices. Delicious crispy pizza. Great little spot
Alex H.
Amazing pizza. Can't wait to come back! Very fresh. Great staff. Will always stop every time in town!
OMG, we ordered a tuna sandwich and a meat ball sandwich. No one else in the place, we waited 25 minutes, no food in sight. Not sure what the 6 people in the kitchen were doing, but we left. WTH?
Pushpendra Yadav
It has good pizza value for money.
sanaz sadeghi
Staff are friendly and super nice. Meals are tasty and affordable with good portions. I especially love their pizzas.
Ontario Shores
The best pizza we have tasted in quite a while. Definitely recommend stopping by for slice.
lauriej2015
Sadly, Sammy’s is closed. The website shows open but the doors were locked. We tried calling and the message said to order online. When we tried to order online, there was a message saying Sammy’s is for sale. We stop every time we travel from Virginia to Syracuse because the pizza is the best we’ve had since Naples, Italy. Completely bummed!
The pizza is very good. I would go back for a pizza any day of the week. Thin crust, perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni.
Went to Ithaca Beer co but prices and service were bad. Stopped at Sammy's and the food was absolutely delicious.
Soda fountain had no syrup, guy behind the counter just shrugged and walked away. Pizza was ok, not really worth the price. Place was filthy, looked like it hadn't been cleaned in a week. Only went here because it was the only pizza place open that wasn't Dominos. Kinda wish i'd gone there instead.
Convenient location in the commons. Everything seemed relatively clean when I went. The bomber sandwich and fries I got were nice and fresh. Good service and friendly staff.
Really love their pizza and atmosphere. Always very happy ? and friendly. Reasonable prices.
Great pizza, and even better kabab!!
Great pizza place and the best garlic knots. The owner was very friendly and made us feel very welcome.
Can’t beat the prices. Delicious crispy pizza. Great little spot
Amazing pizza. Can't wait to come back! Very fresh. Great staff. Will always stop every time in town!
gourmet pizzas, best pizza in Ithaca
Restaurantji Recommends
OMG, we ordered a tuna sandwich and a meat ball sandwich. No one else in the place, we waited 25 minutes, no food in sight. Not sure what the 6 people in the kitchen were doing, but we left. WTH?
It has good pizza value for money.
Staff are friendly and super nice. Meals are tasty and affordable with good portions. I especially love their pizzas.
The best pizza we have tasted in quite a while. Definitely recommend stopping by for slice.
Sadly, Sammy’s is closed. The website shows open but the doors were locked. We tried calling and the message said to order online. When we tried to order online, there was a message saying Sammy’s is for sale. We stop every time we travel from Virginia to Syracuse because the pizza is the best we’ve had since Naples, Italy. Completely bummed!