Recommended dishes: Fresh Tomato Pie and Sausage Pizza, Grilled Eggplant Pizza
Eric Gauthier
Best 4 cheese pizza, cooked in a wood oven, that I have eaten in my life!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nina Marinova
I'm a traditional girl when it comes to pizza and the way to win me over is with a great cheese slice. Whenever I move to a new area my pizza system is to check out all the joints' cheese slices and go from there. This place has great crust and sauce (not sweet), and excellent proportions of dough, sauce and cheese.They also make a really good grilled chicken Caesar, lots of chicken and tasty, all Romain, no iceberg cheating.I've had their specialty slices as well and so far everything has been tasty. The inside got a little facelift recently too.
Aneliya Georgieva
Pleasantly surprised by this local pizzaria along our drive up to Canada. We stopped for a quick bite and I can easily say their pizza was one of the best I ever tried. We also had the calamari and my husband had a sandwich. Everything was made fresh and perfectly seasoned. Very happy with our choice for dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathleen Mazzetti
Consistently the best pizza in the Hudson Valley for a long time. I’d drive far for their eggplant pizza and I’ve been enjoying that since they had Napoli Pizza in New Paltz many years ago. If you can’t get to Italy get yourself to Picnic Pizza in Kingston!Wheelchair accessibility: A good cement ramp from the parking lot
The pizza is nothing to write home about. The owner is also very arrogant and has zero manners. Definitely wouldn't go to this dump again. Too much cheese on the pizza (low quality mozzeralla mind you) , hardly any sauce and the crust is too thick for a slice and is burnt and leathery. It's the kind of pizza I can't stand. The "real italian" owner somehow doesn't know how to make good pizza.
Myles Omeara
Picnic is out first choice when getting pizza! Sicilian is awesome. Wings are great. They always have a pretty good selection of slices.
Use to be ok pizza there, our often "no-time no budget spot". Got 2 pizzas and 2 bruschettas yesterday, paid $75 and couldn't eat it. Family of 5, not just me. It's hard to explain: crust was there and cheese was there, but it doesn't taste good anymore. Hope I just got unlucky, was a great spot!
Saoirse Moloney
Love this place and have loved it for years. Glad to see it is still delicious. Amazing crust and amazing flavors all around. You will not regret getting pizza here.
Excellent Pizza. Good, friendly and accommodating service. Their mushroom pizza is delicious.
Nick Valiante
Great
Food: 5
Service: 5
Takiya M.
Me and my mother have been ordering from here for a while now with no major issues. Tonight I can honestly say we will no longer be returning. We ordered 3 large pies one being a pepperoni pie. That is what I have an issue with. The amount of pepperoni on the pie is ridiculous. I called them to ask them if they can put more on and the man said that's how they come now and hung up on me. So I called back and asked him why he hung up and he said we have more calls I just spent $62 here and this is how I was treated. He further began to say if I wanted more pepperoni I should've asked. And I told him he should let people know only 1.5 pepperoni came on each slice. I will not be returning not only because of the pepperoni but because they have no respect for customers at all.
michael
I feel bad even writing this review.. there was a time where I would drive across town to get pizza here instead of 440. Stopped by for the first time in a while the other day and won’t be back anytime soon. Seems they’ve done away with wood fire. For my pie at least. Very little and low quality cheese. The sauce used to be a staple now it taste like cheap marinara out of a can. Disappointing from one of the last genuine Italian pizza spots.
Always great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Tomato Pie and Sausage Pizza, Grilled Eggplant Pizza
Best 4 cheese pizza, cooked in a wood oven, that I have eaten in my life!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm a traditional girl when it comes to pizza and the way to win me over is with a great cheese slice. Whenever I move to a new area my pizza system is to check out all the joints' cheese slices and go from there. This place has great crust and sauce (not sweet), and excellent proportions of dough, sauce and cheese.They also make a really good grilled chicken Caesar, lots of chicken and tasty, all Romain, no iceberg cheating.I've had their specialty slices as well and so far everything has been tasty. The inside got a little facelift recently too.
Pleasantly surprised by this local pizzaria along our drive up to Canada. We stopped for a quick bite and I can easily say their pizza was one of the best I ever tried. We also had the calamari and my husband had a sandwich. Everything was made fresh and perfectly seasoned. Very happy with our choice for dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Consistently the best pizza in the Hudson Valley for a long time. I’d drive far for their eggplant pizza and I’ve been enjoying that since they had Napoli Pizza in New Paltz many years ago. If you can’t get to Italy get yourself to Picnic Pizza in Kingston!Wheelchair accessibility: A good cement ramp from the parking lot
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Chicken Parm Pizza, Grandma Pizza, Grilled Eggplant Pizza
The pizza is nothing to write home about. The owner is also very arrogant and has zero manners. Definitely wouldn't go to this dump again. Too much cheese on the pizza (low quality mozzeralla mind you) , hardly any sauce and the crust is too thick for a slice and is burnt and leathery. It's the kind of pizza I can't stand. The "real italian" owner somehow doesn't know how to make good pizza.
Picnic is out first choice when getting pizza! Sicilian is awesome. Wings are great. They always have a pretty good selection of slices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Grandma Pizza
Use to be ok pizza there, our often "no-time no budget spot". Got 2 pizzas and 2 bruschettas yesterday, paid $75 and couldn't eat it. Family of 5, not just me. It's hard to explain: crust was there and cheese was there, but it doesn't taste good anymore. Hope I just got unlucky, was a great spot!
Love this place and have loved it for years. Glad to see it is still delicious. Amazing crust and amazing flavors all around. You will not regret getting pizza here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Great pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best mushroom pizza I have ever had ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Excellent Pizza. Good, friendly and accommodating service. Their mushroom pizza is delicious.
Great
Food: 5
Service: 5
Me and my mother have been ordering from here for a while now with no major issues. Tonight I can honestly say we will no longer be returning. We ordered 3 large pies one being a pepperoni pie. That is what I have an issue with. The amount of pepperoni on the pie is ridiculous. I called them to ask them if they can put more on and the man said that's how they come now and hung up on me. So I called back and asked him why he hung up and he said we have more calls I just spent $62 here and this is how I was treated. He further began to say if I wanted more pepperoni I should've asked. And I told him he should let people know only 1.5 pepperoni came on each slice. I will not be returning not only because of the pepperoni but because they have no respect for customers at all.
I feel bad even writing this review.. there was a time where I would drive across town to get pizza here instead of 440. Stopped by for the first time in a while the other day and won’t be back anytime soon. Seems they’ve done away with wood fire. For my pie at least. Very little and low quality cheese. The sauce used to be a staple now it taste like cheap marinara out of a can. Disappointing from one of the last genuine Italian pizza spots.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3