Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

91 W Main St, Macedon
(315) 538-0220

Recent Reviews

Joseph Vetter

They're fast and provide good service. The food is really good. One of the better Salvatore's.

Dave Miles

An hour and a half late,g a call that they're in the wrong town, then had to reorder $70 worth of food for our family gathering. Last time trusting this place. Good food but it's not worth the inconsistency

Colleen Clark

Great food and good prices

Angel L Lopez jr

Great place to eat, also great prices, I'm glad its here in town

Chris Savage

The pizza here is more consistent then at Mark's. I like the sauce better here and some of the daily specials can't be beating anywhere, especially the Wednesday calzone special! They always have good deals and good service!

Chris S.

The pizza here is more consistent then at Mark's. I like the sauce better here and some of the daily specials can't be beating anywhere, especially the Wednesday calzone special! They always have good deals and good service!

Deb S.

Generally I really like Salvatore's pizza and was very happy when the Macedon location reopened. But, I will never again waste my money on a Manhattan New York pizza. We ordered it with pepperoni, green peppers and onions. What a disappointment! The pizza took over an hour to be delivered, assume that Sunday football can be blamed for that. But, it was almost cold when it arrived and the crust was over cooked in places. I was shocked to find the green peppers were a dried up joke; completely tasteless and not enough of them to notice. The onions were equally disappointing. At $2.55 for each extra topping, I expected them to be somewhat tasty. They weren't. I'll stick to the Monday large regular pizza with pepperoni from now on. I've never been unhappy with that. But we do pick that up rather than wait for delivery.

Rebecca Turkmen

Fresh, hot, delicious pizza... Love the variety of wing sauces available!!

William MacWhorter

Great food and service

Brandy McDonald-Voughters

There pizza is amazing great place to eat

Zach F.

Great pizza. Excellent wings and sauce. Great to have decent pizza in macedon. The new ownership of this location is finally pulling though. They never disappoint. Friendly and inviting atmosphere.

Karen Baglin

Salvatore’s on Main Street in Macedon is open again! From the pizza and wings, to the subs, and the fish fry (available daily), the food is delicious and convenient. Eat in or take out, it’s a welcome addition to downtown Macedon!

Kingo Jewell

5 Star. 2 Thumbs Up. Great Service, Great atmosphere. Great workers. First class establishment. Great Food. The owner is a class act. I RÄ“ccomend it to all. Keep up the good work Salvatore’s Pizzeria

Lester Voughters

Very good pizza!! Its a Must Try!!!

Albert Valentin

One of the best around, just not that great.

Matthew Menz

Great service and great food. So nice to have them back in Macedon.

Michael & Cindy Kaehler

So glad to see Salvatore's Pizza back in Macedon. Definitely the best Macedon Pizzeria! Love their steak subs and pizza with old fashioned pepperoni! Went there for lunch and dinner yesterday... yum!

Michael Kaehler

So glad to see Salvatore's Pizza back in Macedon. Definitely the best Macedon Pizzeria! Love their steak subs and pizza with old fashioned pepperoni! Went there for lunch and dinner yesterday... yum!

Cindy Kaehler

So glad to see Salvatore's Pizza back in Macedon. Definitely the best Macedon Pizzeria! Love their steak subs and pizza with old fashioned pepperoni! Went there for lunch and dinner yesterday... yum!

Kayla Kent - Moreira

The reopening of Salvatore's in Macedon is so exciting! Salvatore's has the best pizza, wings and subs around! Welcome back to Macedon!

Q P

This review is for the Salvatores that just opened in the past month. I generally go to Marks in Palmyra. However due to my recent experience at Salvatores...I will likely never go back to Marks again. Salvatores has wings that are bigger and have far better taste. The pizza sauce is not as bland and the regular pepperonis have a bit more zing. And...they got my order perfectly correct 3 times in a row...which is rare at Marks. Please continue to do well!

Marci Freida

Great food and friendly service

Zachary Ruhlen

The epitome of New York style pizza. Hot, melted, good. Try the buffalo chicken pizza.

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

91 W Main St, Macedon, NY 14502
(315) 538-0220