Carlo's Pizza

74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village
(718) 894-7915

Recent Reviews

Susan Poon Chung

This place is never crowded, which is great when you want to stop by for a quick bite. The pizza is really good. My husband loves their chicken slices and I don't eat an upside down from anywhere else.Food: 5/5

eduardo solis

This is a very friendly neighborhood pizza shop. The guy in there are sarcastic and hilarious, the food is really good. The pizza was deliciousFood: 5/5

Andrew Catalano

I went to Carlo's Pizza for the first time and had a awesome experience. I ordered a cheese pizza and a spinach calzone. They normally don't offer spinach calzone but they made it special on a busy Saturday night. The cook with the glasses [sorry I didn't get his name], extremely customer focused, stop.to tell me he made it special. It was one of the best I ever had, and the pie was perfect.Carlo's pizza has a new regular customer.Thank you, to the staff at this fine establishment.

David Fuller

My wife is from Middle Village and we visit this place every time we come to NYC. The Veal Parm Hero is one of my favorite things on earth. I'm from Oregon and we have nothing like this. It's a must stop every time.

Jillian Zemel

My favorite pizza establishment hands down. This is the real deal. I wish they had a Carlo's in Vegas because all the pizza places that I have been to are junk. I miss you guys!

Amanda M.

They deliver to Forest Hills through Yelp which is very convenient. They also delivered when they said they would. We got a Sicilian pie that was generously sized. The sauce and crust were just ok, and could have used more seasoning (maybe basil or rosemary or both, something). The cheese was great.

Jeff G.

I've never loved the pizza scene close to my place. I found Carlo's purely by accident. We were moving and needed a place that could deliver by noon to feed the movers. Literally everyone said they couldn't get multiple pies out that early. I kept expanding my search area until Carlo's said it wouldn't be an issue. Turns out the pizza was great. The movers asked for the number because they loved it so much. We have since ordered multiple times and everyone has been happy. Carlo took my first call and I promised him I'd be back. Well we have been back multiple times and we now have our go to pizza delivery.

PRC

Average Pizza not a 4.6. They only had fresh regular pizza, all the other varieties were stale looking. They advertised coal oven, the pizza I had was not.

DB

Awesome delicious food, their chicken parm heros and steak salad were so good. Also the service is excellent!

Justice T.

Dollar slice quality for a premium price.

David Van Aken

Can't speak higher of Carlo's. I've been eating here since I could start eating solid food and I have nothing but love for the staff and food. 11/10, why aren't you ordering from Carlo's right now?

Maria N.

Ordered catering from Carlos through their website. They a very good number of options for separate dishes. They also offer packages to help you decide the combination. I chose package 3: shrimp scampi, baked clams, chicken parm, eggplant parm, penne vodka, sausage & peppers, and cold antipasto. For the chicken, shrimp, and pasta you can tell them how you want it cooked i.e. pasta with meat sauce or chicken francese, etc. I also ordered a pizza pie on the side. They delivered right on time. The food was delicious. Certainly helped me with hosting. No stress. I also think they're decently priced :) I will definitely order from here again. Highly recommend!

Veronica D.

I ordered the chicken & shrimp Alfredo and it was so disgusting and burnt. It literally had no taste smh in my head I thought who can possibly mess up Alfredo, that is the EASIEST THING TO MAKE !!!!!! Do not buy from here their chef obviously doesn't believe in seasoning, salt or pepper !!!!! And I paid $30 for this DISGUSTING MEAL !!!! My food literally taste like boiled Ramon nudles without seasoning and the grilled chicken tastes like tuna fish fresh out the can without THE F****KING SEASONINGGGGGGG !!!!!!

Staci Baker-Navas

wrong pizza order. gave driver wrong address. pizza cold after all that. person who took order did not care about fixing the situation instead of blaming his customers because he dont knownwhat he's doing nor can he take an order correctly. I guess that falls on us. we are no longer a customer and am deleting this number from the phones.

Mike Y.

Exactly what my husband And I were craving off of the plane from Hawaii! Mahalo! Did not disappoint, we enjoyed every last bite Mahalo!

Load More