My friends and family members (35 in total) went into fudge and stuff during our Montauk vacation. The ice cream is good, however, the customer service is among the worst I've ever seen. Here are some examples: my daughter asked one of the woman for a sample and she stated, "come back tomorrow when you know what you want and when we don't have a long line." A rude response? Of course. Especially when the 30 people behind her were from our family! My nephew a short time later came up to counter and asked about the ice cream and his peanut allergy. The lady responded with the regular flavors are no problem. He received his ice cream but, asked for a clean spoon. She stated, "a clean spoon won't help you with your allergies." I believe that comment is even more obnoxious than the previous and it came from two different employees. Besides the extremely small serving in a cup for $5.50, how do you treat kids and kids with allergies and special needs like this. This is unacceptable treatment and we will not be back to Fudge and Stuff on our next visit.
Shannon King
Very good chocolate. not the friendliest but then again if I had to deal with obnoxious pre-teens all summer I probably wouldnt have a lot of smiles either. It was still worth the 3 hour drive out here to surprise someone with fudge from their favorite shop for their birthday.
Evan D.
We got a SMALL cone with soft serve vanilla. Waffle cone with two scoops. Both had some sprinkles. It came out to nearly $20 lol!!! That gets you 4 gallons of ice cream at IGA.
Diane H.
Fudge this year was terrible. Not creamy and tasted like chemicals.? What did they do to make it this bad after all these years? Also - the chocolate jelly rings were stale and inedible. What a disappointment! I hope they can figure it out. Geeezzz
Jen G
So much candy and ice cream
Loretta H.
Interesting little store off the beaten path. Thankfully GPS is great for finding fun stores. There is a sign on the door regarding service dogs, but I opted to leave said dog with SO in the car with the air running.There are so many choices for fudge. Prices are a bit high, but that happens in tourist areas. After a few days of tasting this fudge, I am happy I did get some. Purchased 4 different flavors. Also purchased some salt water taffy and found that to be tasty as well. There are many "penny" candy options along the wall if you don't want taffy or fudge. Go visit, bring lots of cash, enjoy the sweets.It's a tourist area, parking during high season may be an issue.
Ant R.
Gonna go with 4 stars. Ice cream sundae is as real good - cherry vanilla with hot fudge and gummy bears. Little awkward when I asked for gummy bears as a topping and the woman started weighing them on a scale? She runs a tight ship! Convenient location and reasonable (for Montauk) prices.
Anna I.
I really liked this place. Had my best ice cream cone in the hamptons here - peanut butter cup. Also got yummy chocolate almond bark for my husband and my son loved the popcorn. The shop has an old-school charm which is missing from many of the new spots in town.
Harvey Beringer
Tried first of four flavor we got today. If you are in Montauk be sure to stop in. Can’t wait to try second flavor tomorrow.
mary w.
This place always kills my diet.And it's worth it!!!Rainbow cookie pistachio and peanut butter fudge are the best flavors in my opinion. No trip to the Hamptons complete without a stop at this institution. If you know you know
I stopped by today before leaving Montauk to pick up some candies and I am so glad I did. The shop is immaculately clean and the lady that waited on me (who I assumed is the owner) was warm and friendly. The chocolate caramels are absolutely delicious and worth every penny. Be forewarned that it is cash only. I will definitely stop by again the next time I am in the area. Highly recommend!
May Babraitis
Unfortunately I had a very discriminatory experience at Fudge n Stuff. I was told by the owner that my trained service animal was not allowed to enter the store. She did not ask me:* Is this animal required because of a disability?* What work or task has this animal been trained to perform?Instead, she proceeded to yell at me in a hostile voice that my dog (a trained service animal) could bite someone and made me feelextremely uncomfortable. As a person with a disability this is not the way myself or anyone in my situation should be treated. This establishment should be seriouslyinvestigated for this form of misconduct.
My friends and family members (35 in total) went into fudge and stuff during our Montauk vacation. The ice cream is good, however, the customer service is among the worst I've ever seen. Here are some examples: my daughter asked one of the woman for a sample and she stated, "come back tomorrow when you know what you want and when we don't have a long line." A rude response? Of course. Especially when the 30 people behind her were from our family! My nephew a short time later came up to counter and asked about the ice cream and his peanut allergy. The lady responded with the regular flavors are no problem. He received his ice cream but, asked for a clean spoon. She stated, "a clean spoon won't help you with your allergies." I believe that comment is even more obnoxious than the previous and it came from two different employees. Besides the extremely small serving in a cup for $5.50, how do you treat kids and kids with allergies and special needs like this. This is unacceptable treatment and we will not be back to Fudge and Stuff on our next visit.
Very good chocolate. not the friendliest but then again if I had to deal with obnoxious pre-teens all summer I probably wouldnt have a lot of smiles either. It was still worth the 3 hour drive out here to surprise someone with fudge from their favorite shop for their birthday.
We got a SMALL cone with soft serve vanilla. Waffle cone with two scoops. Both had some sprinkles. It came out to nearly $20 lol!!! That gets you 4 gallons of ice cream at IGA.
Fudge this year was terrible. Not creamy and tasted like chemicals.? What did they do to make it this bad after all these years? Also - the chocolate jelly rings were stale and inedible. What a disappointment! I hope they can figure it out. Geeezzz
So much candy and ice cream
Interesting little store off the beaten path. Thankfully GPS is great for finding fun stores. There is a sign on the door regarding service dogs, but I opted to leave said dog with SO in the car with the air running.There are so many choices for fudge. Prices are a bit high, but that happens in tourist areas. After a few days of tasting this fudge, I am happy I did get some. Purchased 4 different flavors. Also purchased some salt water taffy and found that to be tasty as well. There are many "penny" candy options along the wall if you don't want taffy or fudge. Go visit, bring lots of cash, enjoy the sweets.It's a tourist area, parking during high season may be an issue.
Gonna go with 4 stars. Ice cream sundae is as real good - cherry vanilla with hot fudge and gummy bears. Little awkward when I asked for gummy bears as a topping and the woman started weighing them on a scale? She runs a tight ship! Convenient location and reasonable (for Montauk) prices.
I really liked this place. Had my best ice cream cone in the hamptons here - peanut butter cup. Also got yummy chocolate almond bark for my husband and my son loved the popcorn. The shop has an old-school charm which is missing from many of the new spots in town.
Tried first of four flavor we got today. If you are in Montauk be sure to stop in. Can’t wait to try second flavor tomorrow.
This place always kills my diet.And it's worth it!!!Rainbow cookie pistachio and peanut butter fudge are the best flavors in my opinion. No trip to the Hamptons complete without a stop at this institution. If you know you know
Restaurantji Recommends
I stopped by today before leaving Montauk to pick up some candies and I am so glad I did. The shop is immaculately clean and the lady that waited on me (who I assumed is the owner) was warm and friendly. The chocolate caramels are absolutely delicious and worth every penny. Be forewarned that it is cash only. I will definitely stop by again the next time I am in the area. Highly recommend!
Unfortunately I had a very discriminatory experience at Fudge n Stuff. I was told by the owner that my trained service animal was not allowed to enter the store. She did not ask me:* Is this animal required because of a disability?* What work or task has this animal been trained to perform?Instead, she proceeded to yell at me in a hostile voice that my dog (a trained service animal) could bite someone and made me feelextremely uncomfortable. As a person with a disability this is not the way myself or anyone in my situation should be treated. This establishment should be seriouslyinvestigated for this form of misconduct.
Best homemade candy on the East End
My kids grew up here!!! We love them!!
Omg?#sugarcoma