Bagels Your Way
331 NY-25A #10, Mt Sinai
(631) 828-5278
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I don't write reviews really but, the bagels were very large light and fluffy. They were great and Anna the girl that helped me was such a nice person. It was a great experience
VERY grateful to Brian for waiting after closing for me to pick up my order. Not a good week for a multitude of reasons and I forgot I placed my order for pick up. I called, he said no worries, if not today another time I can pick up a replacement order. THIS is why I travel there. So kind, accommodating and always a kind word. And let's not forget the yummy bagels. ALWAYS a hit in my household. Oodles of thanks Bagels Your Way, we will be back.
Used to love this place, was my go to for an egg sandwich with turkey sausage. Today I received a pathetic sandwich that didn’t taste good at all. They went from a great, full-sized, flavorful sausage patty to these dry, tiny little sausage discs. For the price, not worth it. The saving grace here is the crispy potatoes, still good. Unsure if I will return.
You May Also Like
Lotus East II - 331 Rte 25A
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
Finnbar's Pub - 340 NY-25A
![]()
Bar, Irish Pub, Sports Bar, Chicken Wings