Eddie's Pizza

2048 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park
(516) 354-9780

Recent Reviews

Parth Kochhar

Solid pizza pie. It's super thin. The prosciutto was a delicious addition, and the staff are super friendly.Definitely coming back.

jasmine barry

Horrible pizza. I got a pie to go about 3 weeks ago. I orded grilled chicken on a large. The chicken was uncooked the bottom of the pizza was still uncooked there was barley any cheeses. These cheapos put the cheeses in there pockets instead of the pizza. They did not give back my money or make me a new one they disrespected me and I did not even finish a slice and I brang the pizza back to them. Do not ever go eat over there. The lady at the front is disgusting. Old lady. Do not know how to cook.

Cindy B.

Everything was delicious. Our waiter Jose was very nice! Pizzas are always top notch and the thin crust is my absolute fav!!

Steven DeLaurentis

Step back in history and enjoy legendary bar pie . A paper thin cracker crust and delicious toppings. A must visit

Gurvinder S.

I paid $22 dollars for a whole pie of pizza and it was uncooked raw disgusting looks like cardboard wouldn't give a new pizza or refund of my money horrible customer service. RACIST People discriminating against us.

Jessica S.

Ate here the other day. Old lady didn't stop yelling at the workers while I was there. It was embarrassing to witness

Remag123

Cracker type crust. Wholesale food suppliers sell this or similar crusts. Okay for a change or low carb diets. Real pizza lovers should not eat this.

Anthony Lakatos

Our server wasn't very friendly. The appetizers were good but my main meal was disappointing I got a chicken cutlet parm sub I don't think they could have made the chicken any thinner

Korey London

Eddie's Pizza for many many years waiters and staff owners have always been the best the food the pizza the specialties can always rely on it nothing on the menu is bad

Leah M.

Pizza was good, salad was great, chicken Francese was lacking flavor and a small portion for the price.

Sarah P.

Ate there today around 12PM just after opening. We were one of two families in there. Food was great- bar pies were delicious. However, the restaurant had a terrible smell, the waiter was miserable and bathrooms had water in the soap dispenser. Really sad to see it in such disrepair after going for the last 30 years.

Elaine Vaccaro

My fiancé & I booked one of their pizza trucks for our backyard engagement party and they were a big hit!! Everyone RAVED about the pizza and the staff was so amazing! So glad we booked with them!

Betty

We went to pickup lunch. My coworkers said the bar pie pizza was delish. The grill chicken sandwich was meeeh. I would try other sandwiches instead. The bread was good tho. I would come back again to try other food but their pizza crust is super thin if you like that. They dont sell by the slice. Only by small or large pie. Have to eat it quick if picking up or it'll get cold fast

Aaron Clow (AMC4x4)

Used to spend a night or two every week hanging out here and getting a few beers and bar pies with my friends in the early '90s. Took my family tonight and it was just as awesome as it was 30 years ago. There's only one Eddie's, and in a time where everything changes so fast, it's good to know some good things stay the same.

Peter Vogl

Been going here for many years but had not been in a while. Still the same awesome place and staff and the best bar pies ever.

Load More