Gourmet Bake Shop

775 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park
(516) 354-3930

Recent Reviews

A

Must be new owners prices went up , cookies thinner and less filling Joe you will be missed, Not the same anymore

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Austin Budhram

Don't let the simplistic atmosphere of Gourmet Bake Shop fool you. The cakes and cookies taste amazing and the workers are very friendly and accomodating. They are easily one of the best bakeries in the area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Andy

Always like this place go there once a week staff is great .everything is yummy. Plenty of parking. I heard there is a new owner I hope they keep everything and staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angie G.

I have been to Gourmet Bake Shop many times. I have always been happy with my purchases and even recommended them. Unfortunately I probably won't go back after my experience today. I was bringing dessert to a friend's house. Everything I ordered was old and stale. The pastry were hard and dry and you could tell the cream was old. I was so embarrased. Everything went in the garbage. They lost a customer today.

Victoria Romano

Great pastries and cakes. Fiona was very helpful and was able to answer my questions. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

E Lyons

As far as my husband and I are concerned one of the best, if not the best bakery. Been stopping by for years and never had a complaint. We had apple pie, chocolate babkah, various Danish, cookies. I love the chocolate cigars. Staff is always pleasant and helpful, no matter how busy they are. If it is a holiday, go early or reserve ahead of time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt P.

Good baked goods, reasonable prices. Closed on Monday and takes vacations from time to time, so call ahead if you aren't in the neighborhood. There's another bakery about a mile down the road, but that one is out of bread before 7 am.

Christina Rubino

I am addicted to their napoleons. They are the best in town.

Kathy Kothesakis

Great local bakery. Come in here at least once a week. Have ordered many special occasions cakes here and they were phenomenal. Joe and his staff are very friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Evrana Khatun

Amazing bakery, cake came out beautiful and tasted great! The staff was so kind and helpful, will be ordering again!

Paul Cianciaruso

I wouldn't recommend this bakery. We came one morning, and a nice associate asked if we needed help. We said we would look around and she said to let us know when we were ready.After a couple of minutes, we were ready. A different associate asked what we wanted, and I began to tell her. In the middle of me saying what I wanted, she turned to the next person in line and asked what they wanted, and then began boxing up their items.I found this very rude and we walked out. It really left a sour taste in our mouths. We had been there already long before anybody else was even in the store. I can appreciate that working in retail is difficult, but common decency and communication goes a very long way in running a successful business. We went to another local bakery and won't be returning here.

Mary Kaplan

Some of the best pastries around here not to mention the freshest bread around here.

Richard Feit

They make a wonderful 7-Layer cake I am addicted to them

L C.

One of my favorite bakeries. I usually get their fruit tarts, mini pastries and fresh filled cannolis but never tried their cakes or custom ordered one before. But for my sons first birthday, I decided to take a chance and order the cake. Wow! I'm so impressed! The cake was beautiful and delicious! Joe is so talented and was able to bring my vision to life. I gave him a few pictures of what elements I liked and he did the rest. The cake was moist and delicious. I got a vanilla cake with buttercream frosting and a fresh fruit and custard filling. So delicious! Highly recommend. Joe was so easy to work with and the price was very reasonable too. Thank you for making an amazing cake!

Heena D

Ordered an amazing Oreo cake from gourmet bake shop. Joe did amazing and everyone raved about the cake all night. They will be my go to bakery for cake!

Load More