Jonathan's Restaurant

3000 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 742-7300

Recent Reviews

Priscilla Hinson

my favorite place to eat. The cornbread is to die for.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup

kasie Elsner

Very nice place, comfortable seating. Ordered the schnitzel which was good but different than I expected so I'd get something else next time. Definitely would go backVegetarian options: Some vegetarian choices, gluten free choicesDietary restrictions: Gluten free optionsKid-friendliness: High chairs and made us comfortable with little one even though it was high end, not catered to kids

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Debra Oette

I've eaten here a few times and the food and service are great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rocco R.

I ate here over ten years ago and I wanted to return again because my memory was that it was good. I returned recently and the food was very bad. The fried appetizers tasted like they came from the frozen food section of the supermarket. The salad was very bad too. Just poor quality, the dressing, chicken and lettuce. The service was good. The main room feels like a cafeteria and is over crowded and very noisy.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

bigjoe68

The food was excellent as always. The service was excellent. The Waiter was very attentive. The noise level was moderate and the table selection was a great location. It is always a wonderful experience to dine here whether it be personal , or business.

Lisa Armband

I recently had a private party at Jonathan’s . Everyone commented on how good the food was . The waiters were attentive to the guests and the party was a great success

Diane

Very nice affordable breakfast. Gets very crowded and they need to turn the tables over. That's the only downside but otherwise the food was good and there were a lot of choices for brunch. 

Jacob Brown

Very nice waiter and very nice food! Barely any waits! Would go again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gunther

We enjoy going to Jonathan's and never are disappointed. The food always is very good and the service the same. The menu has something for everyone. We often order their cheeseburger, but other menu options are just as good. One really can't go wrong going to this restaurant..

Danielle A.

Food is excellent with a nice variety to choose from. The wine list is impressive and the service is on point. Ample parking.

Jonathan B.

I had never been to this place before but had been to Jonathan's in Huntington which is excellent. This place not so much. Service was very good so really should be 2 1/2 stars but food was borderline institutional/bad catering hall. We had grilled octopus/calamari appetizer which was bland and had little flavor. The fig and goat cheese special appetizer was mushy. Chicken Milanese was good but the Paella Valencia was salty and fish tasted like frozen fish. Clams were rubbery. Place felt like a diner or small catering hall. I had read reviews before going there which were very mixed but someone had bought me a gift card for the restaurant so we went anyway. I can honestly say I don't think I would ever go there again. Staff was nice and attentive.

DeLo

It was our 19th Anniversary. It was a Saturday night and the place was crowded. The food was good. I ordered a martini "very dry". Had to send it back. It had more vermouth than vodka. The second attempt wasn't any better. It was mostly lemon water and very little vodka. Returned the $17 martini with no attempt to try for a 3rd time. Service was Ok, but, he never took the $17 martini off the check. He compensated with a Latte and soda.

Christopher Lemelle

This place was overall pretty great. Came here for a wedding dinner, large group of around 20-30 people. They were very organized, food was delicious. The reason I did not give this restaurant five stars was unfortunate. One of the appetizers were these tiny fried spring rolls. We asked if there was any fish in there and they told us no. One of our friends is extremely allergic to salmon, and these fried spring rolls were filled with salmon. Our friend took one bite and was extremely sick for the reminder of the night. Very unfortunate, but aside from this everything else was pretty great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dennis Funez

I’m recommending everyone to visit this

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JoeP

Excellent restaurant. Everyone enjoyed their meal. Service was great. They even seated us at a table convenient for my elderly mom. Have dined at Jonathan's on numerous occasions when I visit my mom and the experience is always amazing.

Load More