Jonathan's Restaurant | New Hyde Park

3000 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 742-7300

Recent Reviews

DebraG

Service was great, food was good but did not receive requested table

RobertF

Delicious ! I had the day scallops and my husband had the Lobster paella. Both excellent meals and cooked perfectly. We loved the desert sampler - it was perfect for the two of us. Service was excellent! We had a lovely dinner for a last minute decision to eat out “ just because “

Bonnie

It was a 4 generation dinner. Food for all, good service, not so loud that we couldn’t hear our conversations. A welcoming family environment

JimF

Superb center cut filet mignon with mashed potatoes and asparagus, delicious orange creme brulee and cappuccino.

Donnagrilli

Wonderful service and food

kenF

Their lunch salads are spectacular! Love the corn shaped rolls. Wait staff very attentive! I'll come back and back again.

EileenB

First time & loved it all !!! Food -atmosphere& waitress Victoria & help was great !!! Definitely recommend

OpenTable Diner

Overall a great experience for a nice family gathering!

NYC515

It was the perfect restaurant to enjoy a leisurely meal with former work friends. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, and the noise level enabled us to carry on a conversation without a problem. Our server was very knowledgeable and accommodating. I had the bourbon pork chops which were juicy and delicious. We shared appetizers. Pear and Gorgonzola salad was a big hit with all of us. My friend could not stop raving about the Bronzino. It was perfectly cooked. The crème brí»lée, and the rice pudding were the perfect end to our meal. We did not feel at all rushed and will certainly return as soon as possible.

OpenTable Diner

As it was New Years Eve, I need to cut the restaurant some slack as that day is never perfect to eat out. Considering this, the restaurant was not packed although the reservations were full. I was with one person and although I asked for one of the larger tables (for 4 and usually are accommodated), they seated us at a table for 2 which was in the corner of the restaurant. My filet mignon (usually wonderful) was overdone on the inside. Also, my view was of my friend, the wall behind him, the fire extinguisher and the exit sign. As I am a very frequent customer, I should not have been shoved in a corner and had to deal with that. Only 4 stars because it was NYE. Had it been another night, it would have been 2 stars.

OpenTable Diner

Isabella was an exceptional waitress. Attentive and understanding. Enjoyed her service.

Bonnie

The service was personal, the food made to our different dietary needs, we just had a wind evening

Harlemite

Always an enjoyable experience!

MonaLisaM

Popped in for dinner with an old friend and had a wonderful time and enjoyed a delicious well prepared meal. We'll definitely be back to try something new!

LizB

staff was very pleasant and accomodating Will definately go back

Load More