Chicken wings were burnt. Peperonchini peppers were dehydrated. Pizzas were just average. Disappointed
Carolyn Cruz-Hannah
Went to New Hyde Park Papa John's because my mom wanted to try the Shaqaroni. Interestingly, the cost advertised on TV is $13.99. However, this location charged $15.99 plus tax then proceded not to give me all of my change.The gentleman was surprised when I asked for a receipt. Only then did he give me the rest of my change. After, I had to ask for a receipt a second time. Will not go to this location again.
Talina Ellington
This place is nasty, I end up giving away the Hawaiana pizza..
Kanwaljit Pannu
Very neat and clean restaurant. Amicable staff and great ambiance.
Jesse Y.
Gets the job done when you're hungry. Don't compare to coal fired or brick oven pizza but what do you expect for $13.99 large pie with 5 toppings. Friendly store with ample parking. I usually order on the app and pick ip on way home.
Josh Anderson
This was my favorite pizza place until they tried to scam me for 5 extra bucks. I usually go to this place around once or twice a week. I ordered a small pizza and 10 pc chicken poppers. They tried to charge me 32 bucks when it costed 25. I thought it wasn’t correct so I asked for the recipes. It took them a good 5 minutes to get me the receipt. They still charged the small pizza for the price of the medium pizza, but I just paid the extra two bucks. Never going back again
Ray Lin
Very bad hygiene. The worker touched the pizza dough with bare hands and didn’t even bother to wash them and just before that he was using his cellphone and cash register. I even saw him picking his nose. When I asked for a refund they refused so I just threw the entire pizza away.
Jesse Yuan
Well it’s fast food pizza and I’ve never had any bad experience with this location. Don’t expect this to be brick oven or coal fired quality but gets the job done when you’re hungry with limited pizza options.I simply just order from app and pick up.
Musical Opyfee
This was my favorite pizza place until they tried to scam me for 5 extra bucks. I usually go to this place around once or twice a week. I ordered a small pizza and 10 pc chicken poppers. They tried to charge me 32 bucks when it costed 25. I thought it wasn’t correct so I asked for the recipes. It took them a good 5 minutes to get me the receipt. They still charged the small pizza for the price of the medium pizza, but I just paid the extra two bucks. Never going back again
Raybbon Archives
Very bad hygiene. The worker touched the pizza dough with bare hands and didn’t even bother to wash them and just before that he was using his cellphone and cash register. I even saw him picking his nose. When I asked for a refund they refused so I just threw the entire pizza away.
Very bad hygiene. The worker touched the pizza dough with bare hands and didn’t even bother to wash them and just before that he was using his cellphone and cash register. I even saw him picking his nose. When I asked for a refund they refused so I just threw the entire pizza away.
Mr. K
This pizza was supposed to be a whole Black olives, green peppers, onions, Jalapeño peppers and pineapple. All you see here is pineapple and jalapeño. This time it was a lady making the pizza. The crust side is such a waste. They did not cover the whole dough with toppings and cheese.
Vin D
Operated cashier then went straights to touching the dough with his hands. No way this place is following corporate standards.
JOYTI SINGH
The worst pizza I ever had at papa John it was disgusting,She doesn’t even know how to take order over the phone . It was my favorite place in new Hyde park but no anymore .
Chicken wings were burnt. Peperonchini peppers were dehydrated. Pizzas were just average. Disappointed
Went to New Hyde Park Papa John's because my mom wanted to try the Shaqaroni. Interestingly, the cost advertised on TV is $13.99. However, this location charged $15.99 plus tax then proceded not to give me all of my change.The gentleman was surprised when I asked for a receipt. Only then did he give me the rest of my change. After, I had to ask for a receipt a second time. Will not go to this location again.
This place is nasty, I end up giving away the Hawaiana pizza..
Very neat and clean restaurant. Amicable staff and great ambiance.
Gets the job done when you're hungry. Don't compare to coal fired or brick oven pizza but what do you expect for $13.99 large pie with 5 toppings. Friendly store with ample parking. I usually order on the app and pick ip on way home.
This was my favorite pizza place until they tried to scam me for 5 extra bucks. I usually go to this place around once or twice a week. I ordered a small pizza and 10 pc chicken poppers. They tried to charge me 32 bucks when it costed 25. I thought it wasn’t correct so I asked for the recipes. It took them a good 5 minutes to get me the receipt. They still charged the small pizza for the price of the medium pizza, but I just paid the extra two bucks. Never going back again
Very bad hygiene. The worker touched the pizza dough with bare hands and didn’t even bother to wash them and just before that he was using his cellphone and cash register. I even saw him picking his nose. When I asked for a refund they refused so I just threw the entire pizza away.
Well it’s fast food pizza and I’ve never had any bad experience with this location. Don’t expect this to be brick oven or coal fired quality but gets the job done when you’re hungry with limited pizza options.I simply just order from app and pick up.
This was my favorite pizza place until they tried to scam me for 5 extra bucks. I usually go to this place around once or twice a week. I ordered a small pizza and 10 pc chicken poppers. They tried to charge me 32 bucks when it costed 25. I thought it wasn’t correct so I asked for the recipes. It took them a good 5 minutes to get me the receipt. They still charged the small pizza for the price of the medium pizza, but I just paid the extra two bucks. Never going back again
Very bad hygiene. The worker touched the pizza dough with bare hands and didn’t even bother to wash them and just before that he was using his cellphone and cash register. I even saw him picking his nose. When I asked for a refund they refused so I just threw the entire pizza away.
Restaurantji Recommends
Could be cleaner ,fast service
Very bad hygiene. The worker touched the pizza dough with bare hands and didn’t even bother to wash them and just before that he was using his cellphone and cash register. I even saw him picking his nose. When I asked for a refund they refused so I just threw the entire pizza away.
This pizza was supposed to be a whole Black olives, green peppers, onions, Jalapeño peppers and pineapple. All you see here is pineapple and jalapeño. This time it was a lady making the pizza. The crust side is such a waste. They did not cover the whole dough with toppings and cheese.
Operated cashier then went straights to touching the dough with his hands. No way this place is following corporate standards.
The worst pizza I ever had at papa John it was disgusting,She doesn’t even know how to take order over the phone . It was my favorite place in new Hyde park but no anymore .