Papa Johns Pizza

1709 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 281-7272

Recent Reviews

Nicholas Burnett

I’m so happy this Papa Jhon’s is in my neighborhood. They get it done and quickly I might add. Faster than you think for sure.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza

Mandy

Staff didn’t deliver my pizza and decided to mark as delivered. Still winded up charging me but never delivered my pizza. Will be reporting to corporate.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Whitley Coke

Especially tasty pizza as y’all can see I tore into it ??? Cheese was perfect, service was 10/10 they were very friendly + kind, and quick service. They

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

REaikee

This is my SECOND TIME GETTING FOOD POISONING FROM THIS PARTICULAR LOCATION. I have no idea what their food handling practices are but something is not

Food: 1

Service: 3

Médaille Guy

Top quality/price ratio.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Cemil Inal

Someone who knows about the restaurant industry should know how to treat people. But behind the counter there is an arrogant and absolutely unfriendly guy. As a franchise company, Papa John's should select and hire its people more carefully! I was self-employed in the catering industry for many years. Everyone can have a bad day, but that doesn't give anyone the right to yell at other people... It was my first and last time in this store.

Service: 1

Andie Y.

Insanely rude customer service, poor management, and overall incompetence. We placed an order at 9 pm only for the order to be missing an hour later. We then placed a second order only for the wrong order to be delivered. We called this location both times and were met very rudely with no apologies or explanation. It took over 2.5 hours for no solution and only rude responses.

amar King

Great pizza neighborhood can be a little Shakey especially at night. Be aware of surroundings at all times!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Reymundo Marquez

Poor you oder something as simple as extra cheese and they put pepperoni on the bottom and the regular cheese that goes on the bottom the worst pizza stain hard cold delivery late from the time they offered it terrible oder from P and M pizza alot better.

Svet Tebe

TERRIBLE QUALITY. They did not add all toppings. Pizza was burned out(((((((

Sveta

TERRIBLE QUALITY. They did not add all toppings. Pizza was burned out(((((((

Jazmin T.

Really great customer service!

Katy Pena

Order pizza for my grandkids the status stated delivered never received my pizza. I reported to manager and requested a refund he said ok and still was charged.

Dallas A.

While Papa John's and other national chains probably wouldn't be my first choice with how many pizza options there are in NYC, Papa John's stays open late and I can rely on them to deliver solid pizza consistently. This location is only a couple of blocks from two different subway stations, the service was fast (I ordered online and it was ready within 20 minutes on a Saturday night), and the employees were friendly. I'd definitely come back--it's a solid late-night or pizza party kind of place.

Denis Demarco

The pizza is disgusting! the sauce was like someone was eating it. There was only one slice of pepperoni on the whole pizza!The order was through Seamless (Regarding order 68252046-9272770).

Load More