Tolleson's Pizzeria

419 N Main St, Newark
(315) 332-8008

Recent Reviews

Greg Blocker Sr.

Quite open washers

Earthgirl Tarot

First time eating the garbage plate...SLAMMIN! They were right on the delivery timing too. Good job guys ?

Epsteins Necktie

If I want a loaf of bread id go to the store and buy one. Im originally from Brooklyn ive ordered from every pizzeria in this small town. This is the ONLY one who seems to know how to make a proper thin NY crust!

Krystin I

Always good food and good people!

Erinn -

Employees Rude and act dumb

Gabriel LeTennier

Cheesy bread with bacon was great specialty pizza was great as well ?

Amy McKinney

Awesome food, awesome service

Irene Velez

I ordered originally a few months back while looking for a local pizza place and wanting to try somewhere new. Ironically I havent ordered pizza because their menu has such diverse items that I always try something new! My favorite by far is the chicken cordon blue hot sub. I love that by the time its delivered to me the bread is still toasted and not soggy!By far, my favorite new go to place to order whenever I'm feeling lazy and don't want to cook!

Craig Seely

Best in town. Great people.

Jeff Tyler

Never been disappointed I’ve been ordering there since they opened best pizza joint in town by far

Jina Foster



Great tasting pizza! A good price!

Rainbow Mushroom Cloud

Great tasting pizza! A good price!

Cheryl Shields

Usually the pizza is good. Tonight both pizza and wings were absolutely horrible. Both wend in the garbage. I won't be back

Kimmy Dee

Only place for the yummy godfather pizza and so much to choose from!!!

Load More