Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

1700 Culver Rd, Rochester
(585) 288-5555

Recent Reviews

Casanova Burgos

Great place to get food. Pizza is always hot and fresh, staff is amazing and professional. Atmosphere is great for family and friends.In the summer there’s nice area to sit outside.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Boneless Wings, Buffalo Wing

Erica Michelle

I love this place the donuts and pizza are very good. I have had a breakfast pizza. Also they have pizza sitting out but if you don’t like the way it looks they will make you fresh pizza if you have a little time. They also have a really nice sitting area inside and out.Parking: Plenty of free parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Donut

D Johnson

Between here and Two Ton Tony's I don't know which has a more terrible slice. Nothing is redeeming the sauce the cheese the pepperoni all bland and stale.Imagine leaving a decent pizza out all night you wake up around noon the next day and reheated it. It's somehow worse than that.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Peggy Gilmartin

Love going into this retro building. Best pizza and best donuts!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Donut, Pasta & Meatballs, Grilled Chicken Parm, Breakfast Meat Pizza Special

Astreha M.

Service was horrible. They Got my order wrong after going over it with them many times. Wish I could get a refund. Garlic knots nasty. Desserts tasted old. Save your time and don't go!

Jacob C

Pizza for dinner with doughnuts for dessert,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bobby Watson

I usually go to the one on Main St location but decided to stop here on my way home . I order a typical Italian assorted with provolone, L-O-T, mayonnaise & oil. Got home and cut off just the heel and the bread was so hard I scraped the roof of my mouth. The whole loaf was like that... you could knock on it like a door. I normally don't do this but I took it back and asked for the manager . She looked at the receipt and said no problem. I even told her they could even keep the same toppings, just give me a fresh loaf. They made a new one for me anyway which I appreciated...! So I get home and the bread was great. But this time there was no oil, it had pickles...which I didn't ask for, and the onions weren't sliced like normal. They were big chunks of onions like they put on a Pizza. Who does that? Never going there again.... Maybe for doughnuts.....but that's it.

Food: 2

Service: 1

Cass Jackson

I literally live across the street. This the 3rd time they have messed my order up. I call and try to fix things and they stay oh well another 30 minutes. How are y’all constantly getting orders wrong

Ryan B.

I have never written a review before but the awful time that I experienced prompted me need to warn everybody. I ordered a large and a gluten free breakfast pizza for pickup at 9am on a Sunday. I prepaid. I arrived at 8:55 and found long lines outside into the parking lot. I tried to call to see if I could just go in and get my pizza since I had already paid. They said they were behind and that they haven't made it yet, but it would be going in soon.I waited in line for an hour with many other people, talking about when they ordered and how long they had waited. They had no prepaid like I had, but it wasn't a big deal. After an hour I finally made it inside and again gave my information. I was told that the pizzas were just going in the oven.After 30 minutes I again asked about my pizzas. They said they were just going in the oven now. I told them to cancel and told them I wanted a refund. They said they would give me the order for free so I said fine, angry that I had already invested 1 hour and 30 minutes. I was then told that they didn't have any gluten free pizzas. Despite the fact that they already told me TWICE that it was already going in the oven.I told them to cancel it and give me my money. I will never go to another Salvatore's even if it is a franchise. You should but either. Be smart, boycott this shoddy establishment and their terrible service and business practices.

Lisa Bella

Horrible food. Cold and hard pizza. Greasy chicken. Old stale mozzarella sticks. Worse Caesar salad in my life. Mushrooms onions and bacon?!! Huge waste of money.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sarah Bion

Big portions, but other than that it was nothing special. Now I know to just stick to their pizzas.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

psudino

If you are on a diet, stay away! The host of our business trip brough us breakfast from here and it is dangerously tasty! First of all, the donuts are huge and filled with so many flavors. Then, from the pizzeria side they have breakfast pizzas and calzones. Everything we tried was delicious! Excellent way to start the day.

alex long

Ordered fried calamari with cocktail sauce and fried mushrooms with blue cheese. Received both food items but no blue cheese and marinara sauce. Called and was told credit will be put onto my account.The sauces makes both of these dishes, one without the other is pointless.

Dorene Mari

Apple spice donuts were stale and messed up on the garlic bites so crunchy and extra salty. The one in Irondequiot is amazing so I ordered from here cus of the donuts I don’t think I’ll be making this my number one stop I’ll try the other donuts Delites might be better

Anitra Spencer

The order was wrong. I asked for bakef beans and Mac salad and they came in the mini sauce containers. I ordered pepperoni pizza and it came just cheese and was cold. The last few orders I got from here has been horrible. Culver Road Salvatores quality of food has seriously declined. You will not keep customers like this.

Load More

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

1700 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY 14609
(585) 288-5555