The Old Stone Tavern

758 South Ave, Rochester
(585) 448-1148

Recent Reviews


Ordered from this spot via Grubhub while staying at a local hotel. My food was delivered in record time! It was plentiful and delish, definitely enough for leftovers.

Mary Maier Pinkerton

Friendly staff and great food!!

Christine C

We went at lunch time and it was not too crowded. The food was amazing, and the options were plentiful. We will definitely be back to try more menu items.

Robert Zecca

Stopped in last minute glad we did friendly place great food and Trivia nite

Roger Jackson

A great little bar.Warm friendly employees.And one of the best garbage plates in Rochester.

Priscilla Jackson

The food, atmosphere, and staff are GREAT! Make your way to The Old Stone Tavern if you haven't already gone. ?

Andrew Gookin

Awesome menu. Cool vibe. Great food. Superior service

Molly Kolb

It was decent enough for bar food. It can get loud on trivia night. There was no warning that trivia was coming when we entered. At first our waitress had a mask, but as the night went on she wasn't wearing it. Pretty small dining area. But they have their own parking lot and plenty of TVs.

Shannon Barg

A great place for some good quality bar food. They also have a few vegetarian options including cauliflower wings and a beyond burger, both of which are great.

Jasmine J

The burger and dog big plate was so good, didn’t make sense nor sound good to put all that together but man it was so good !! The staff was very pleasant and made great recommendations, can’t wait to come back!

Holly Greaves

Fairly small interior but very friendly environment. Didn't feel out of place at all, waiting staff were SO friendly! Fish tacos were absolutely brilliant and my cocktail was delicious if not maybe a little on the sweet ion side for me. 100% going back soon and will be a regular

Ken Porter-Hutton

Food was great - simple but delicious yet tots and a very good chili. Caught it at a quiet time. Server/bartender (whose name I totally forgot to get) was fantastic. If I lived in the neighborhood, I’d be there every week.

Vincent Costantino

They mixed up my gluten free and regular buns, when I called to confirm the woman who answered told me she entered the order right and if the kitchen mixed it up it wasn't her fault.Great, when asked to help find the difference, she offered little reassurance for someone who is gluten free and hung up on me.

Ann C

We went with a larger group (about 12), and I suppose that might have been too much for them. They didn't get 3 of our orders right and they mixed up a couple other things too. The food tasted good, but wasn't anything too unique.


I wish we took pictures, the food smelled and looked so good we didn’t have time for pictures lol excellent service and great people. I can’t wait to make it back for the tacos

Load More