Tarallo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

CLOSED
$ •

Recent Reviews

Write a review

December 2021

I am definitely going to rate this 4 stars...Margherita pizza Absolutely delicious With the Sesame seed crust....A+++++BUT: It arrived very cold (brrrrr)We had to air fry it...for $25 it should arrive hot n ready to eat.I hope The owners can take some constructive criticism because I have to admit The Taste was absolutely delicious! Happy Healthy New Year!!!-

August 2021

I'm from Brooklyn, and since living on LI, we have searched for similar pizza... Tarallo"s is awesome, and not just the pizza. Have NEVER been disappointed with anything we've ordered.

August 2021

Came here for the first time yesterday to grab a slice with a friend, it was so good that I came back today with my dad and we split a pie. There wasn't a slice left between the both of us....might be the best regular slice in the area. They put sesame seed in the crust which is go good. This will be my new go to for a regular slice. Also all the workers behind the counter are awesome down to earth people!

More Reviews(86)