Delicious seafood! And lots of fresh catching the day local fish here. One of my top seafood shops on the whole Long Island. Smoker trout was amazing. Cod sandwich superb. Service is great. No wonder this pace is packed for lunch in the middle of the day. We highly recommend this place!
Radu Matei
The best seafood I’ve had in my life!!!
My first time in America and this place was exactly what I was looking for.
I had a variety of oysters, cold and warm lobster roll, fried calamari, steamers, mayo mahi tacos and their New England clam chowder. Everything blew my mind. I had to get a hat so I can reminisce about this place when I’m back home. Hope I will get to visit again!
Coach Dani
SLAMMIN!! The Bloody Mary was the best meal I’ve ever had and the oysters were RIGHT !!
Gianna Riso
this place has great food, bad service. i came here with my aunt and cousin twice in the same week. once the kitchen was closed, which we understood. the second time, we timed it perfectly on my cousin's 25th birthday so we could get there at a reasonable hour before the kitchen closed. my other cousin, her twin, is overseas in the navy and was unable to be here. we live an hour and a half away and all she wanted was to go to this place. we were disappointed to find out that they closed two hours early before the kitchen was supposed to close. it would have been nice to have some notice.
andrea flannery
Twice in one week I came to eat, once the kitchen was closed and we understood the second in the Same weekthey closed for a private party… come on guys.. We live 1.5 hours away.. A little notice would have been nice.. My daughters 25 Th bday and all she wanted was your food.. I'm so disappointed in you
Rob
Hands down one of the best seafood markets and seafood takeout places I have ever been to the staff went out of their way to accommodate me and answer all the questions that I had and provide excellent customer service I've been in the customer service industry for 32 years now definitely will be back the steam clams were absolutely delicious and looking forward to trying other stuff on the menu items and giving them my business in the future
Que En
Waste of money. Food had no flavor at all. Over priced, prices did not match the menu price. Will not return.
Undercover Astrology
05/31/25
Freshest seafood and the best people ever! Oysters were incredible. Thank you!
Jack Kratoville
Place looked amazing and the staff went above and beyond. However, after we brought home fresh fluke, it was full of tiny bones everywhere. I expected better.
We were absolutely stunned by how good the food was at Southold Fish Market! Every bite was fresh and flavorful—true coastal perfection. The place is full of character, with that authentic seaside charm that makes you feel like you’ve discovered a local treasure. The staff were super friendly and welcoming, adding to the warm, laid-back vibe. If you’re anywhere near Southold, do yourself a favor and stop by—this spot is a gem!
Delicious seafood! And lots of fresh catching the day local fish here. One of my top seafood shops on the whole Long Island.
Smoker trout was amazing.
Cod sandwich superb.
Service is great.
No wonder this pace is packed for lunch in the middle of the day.
We highly recommend this place!
The best seafood I’ve had in my life!!!
My first time in America and this place was exactly what I was looking for.
I had a variety of oysters, cold and warm lobster roll, fried calamari, steamers, mayo mahi tacos and their New England clam chowder. Everything blew my mind. I had to get a hat so I can reminisce about this place when I’m back home.
Hope I will get to visit again!
SLAMMIN!! The Bloody Mary was the best meal I’ve ever had and the oysters were RIGHT !!
this place has great food, bad service. i came here with my aunt and cousin twice in the same week. once the kitchen was closed, which we understood. the second time, we timed it perfectly on my cousin's 25th birthday so we could get there at a reasonable hour before the kitchen closed. my other cousin, her twin, is overseas in the navy and was unable to be here. we live an hour and a half away and all she wanted was to go to this place. we were disappointed to find out that they closed two hours early before the kitchen was supposed to close. it would have been nice to have some notice.
Twice in one week I came to eat, once the kitchen was closed and we understood the second in the Same weekthey closed for a private party… come on guys.. We live 1.5 hours away.. A little notice would have been nice.. My daughters 25 Th bday and all she wanted was your food.. I'm so disappointed in you
Hands down one of the best seafood markets and seafood takeout places I have ever been to the staff went out of their way to accommodate me and answer all the questions that I had and provide excellent customer service I've been in the customer service industry for 32 years now definitely will be back the steam clams were absolutely delicious and looking forward to trying other stuff on the menu items and giving them my business in the future
Waste of money. Food had no flavor at all. Over priced, prices did not match the menu price. Will not return.
05/31/25
Freshest seafood and the best people ever!
Oysters were incredible. Thank you!
Place looked amazing and the staff went above and beyond. However, after we brought home fresh fluke, it was full of tiny bones everywhere. I expected better.
No comment for this place. They fry all seafood.
Restaurantji Recommends
We were absolutely stunned by how good the food was at Southold Fish Market! Every bite was fresh and flavorful—true coastal perfection. The place is full of character, with that authentic seaside charm that makes you feel like you’ve discovered a local treasure. The staff were super friendly and welcoming, adding to the warm, laid-back vibe. If you’re anywhere near Southold, do yourself a favor and stop by—this spot is a gem!
Incredible seafood; lobster rolls, shrimps, crab, fish, scallops. Everything is really tasty!
Fresh and plenty of selection. Locals and out of town visitors like the seafood platters.
Tuna club sandwich, blackened swordfish sandwich, lobster salad were all as good as it gets.
Will never return to the area without eating here!
Amazing selection of fresh fish and seafood, as well as prepared foods. You can also eat there.
Loading...