Try the caramel pretzel cookie, you will not be disappointed!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tommy Propane
Mario and Salvo's Pizza carries Cathy's cookies, and I will say they are amazing. I look forward to visiting Cathy's Cookie Kitchen in the future to check out their full menu.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Robert Jutton
Made a very good special order of a gluten free almond cookie
J Lanni
The greatest cookies we have tasted!Heath bar crunch cookie was outstanding.The chocolate chip cookie is worth the drive from Canandaigua!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hercules Candy
My son special ordered vegan snickerdoodles with MAPLE frosting! Wow, what a party for my mouth! Best birthday ever!
Teganmary Freberg
Staff was very friendly and the gluten free cookies were AMAZING, the best I’ve had!
Tahj Blackiston
Best cookies in upstate! Friendly service, great place to stop.
charnley abbott
The cookies are DELICIOUS! And the owner and staff are great!
kyle metz
Friendly staff and great cookies! Kids always ask to go all the way from Marcellus. Worth the trip!
Laura M.
Delicious cookies, tastes like home! Variety, good coffee and friendly staff. A Syracuse staple!
These are the BEST gluten free cookies I have ever eaten in my LIFE. I’ve had them several times, and tried all the flavors. Not only are the cookies amazing, but customer service is amazing. All of my questions were answered quickly, and she was so friendly, kind, and helpful!!!
Jamie Olden
These cookies are BOMB! A colleague of mine introduced me and then we’d have date days to grab some at least twice a month. I moved out of the state but every time I’m in Cuse I make it to stop by and load up. The owner is always super friendly and kind. She also did a birthday (I think cookie) cake and delivered it for a friends kids birthday!!
Georgia Wicker
The absolute best cookies, hands down! I have some EVERY TIME I’m in Cuse! Can’t get enough of the Snickerdoodle and Peanut Butter cookies w/Reese cups on top!??. I live in Texas and make huge orders for my family and coworkers every once in awhile and they’re still delicious when they arrive! Think I’m going to make another delivery order right now, now that I’m thinking about them!!
Ellie Gonzales
Cathy’s cookies are so delicious and made to perfection. Their employees are so professional and always smiling. I definitely enjoyed this place and will make a stop every time I’m passing by. Thanks for a great experience.
Harry “Hairball”
Went about a week ago, got a half dozen cookies for like 25 bucks. Cookies were stale and kinda depressing. Honestly would rather go to peace love and cupcakes, they can atleast make a decent chocolate chip. Oh, also try to stay away from the milky way ones. I created this account to voice my distaste of those baked concoctions the owner calls cookies.EDITUnsure of the mean natured friend you're talking about, I had a bad experience, the employee that cashed me out was rude and I was very unsatisfied with the product I received. After checking my order, I got half a dozen for 14.75, a buttercream for 3.50 and 4 brownie bites for 8.
Try the caramel pretzel cookie, you will not be disappointed!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mario and Salvo's Pizza carries Cathy's cookies, and I will say they are amazing. I look forward to visiting Cathy's Cookie Kitchen in the future to check out their full menu.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Made a very good special order of a gluten free almond cookie
The greatest cookies we have tasted!Heath bar crunch cookie was outstanding.The chocolate chip cookie is worth the drive from Canandaigua!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My son special ordered vegan snickerdoodles with MAPLE frosting! Wow, what a party for my mouth! Best birthday ever!
Staff was very friendly and the gluten free cookies were AMAZING, the best I’ve had!
Best cookies in upstate! Friendly service, great place to stop.
The cookies are DELICIOUS! And the owner and staff are great!
Friendly staff and great cookies! Kids always ask to go all the way from Marcellus. Worth the trip!
Delicious cookies, tastes like home! Variety, good coffee and friendly staff. A Syracuse staple!
Restaurantji Recommends
These are the BEST gluten free cookies I have ever eaten in my LIFE. I’ve had them several times, and tried all the flavors. Not only are the cookies amazing, but customer service is amazing. All of my questions were answered quickly, and she was so friendly, kind, and helpful!!!
These cookies are BOMB! A colleague of mine introduced me and then we’d have date days to grab some at least twice a month. I moved out of the state but every time I’m in Cuse I make it to stop by and load up. The owner is always super friendly and kind. She also did a birthday (I think cookie) cake and delivered it for a friends kids birthday!!
The absolute best cookies, hands down! I have some EVERY TIME I’m in Cuse! Can’t get enough of the Snickerdoodle and Peanut Butter cookies w/Reese cups on top!??. I live in Texas and make huge orders for my family and coworkers every once in awhile and they’re still delicious when they arrive! Think I’m going to make another delivery order right now, now that I’m thinking about them!!
Cathy’s cookies are so delicious and made to perfection. Their employees are so professional and always smiling. I definitely enjoyed this place and will make a stop every time I’m passing by. Thanks for a great experience.
Went about a week ago, got a half dozen cookies for like 25 bucks. Cookies were stale and kinda depressing. Honestly would rather go to peace love and cupcakes, they can atleast make a decent chocolate chip. Oh, also try to stay away from the milky way ones. I created this account to voice my distaste of those baked concoctions the owner calls cookies.EDITUnsure of the mean natured friend you're talking about, I had a bad experience, the employee that cashed me out was rude and I was very unsatisfied with the product I received. After checking my order, I got half a dozen for 14.75, a buttercream for 3.50 and 4 brownie bites for 8.