Winners Circle Ice Cream

2400 NY-414, Watkins Glen
(607) 535-2409

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael Sheehan

Great ice cream with very generous portions. Cost was a bit steep - but worth it. They also do pup cups, so bring Fido :-)

Marcus Smith

They have good ice cream & other foods too like burgers, fries & hot dogs 🌭 & such.

C B

The winners circle ice cream shop is hands down one of the best around. They have really fair prices and a huge selection. The staff is always friendly, and it looks like they employ local kids during the summer, giving them a good job! There is nothing on the menu that you can go wrong with. They even have a $25 mega Sunday that if you eat it within an hour it's free!! Good luck though, that thing is alot of ice cream! Don't pass this place by.

Braulio Martinez

Slow service

Al Ben

Would’ve been a great experience if the girl who just clocked in didn’t have a horrible attitude. Very rude, slamming the window, made an entirely liquid milkshake, gave a dirty look when asking for a dish to put melting ice cream in in 90 degree weather. No professionalism and disrespectful. Older man was super nice and fixed the milkshake.

Solomon Rosenthal

Get ready for a long line and wait. But that is just because people love this place. And for good reason. You'll have plenty of time to examine the super large menu and change your mind at least 100 times before finally getting to order. But whatever you do decide on, be sure it'll be tasty.

Tiffany Doan

Such wonderful people! 💕

Kim Landis

So many choices! So many flavors! Amazing!

Nancy Shumway

Very friendly staff, tons of options and they appear to have a fair amount of food options (non-ice cream). No indoor seating, though there is a small gazebo and plenty of outdoor seating.

Amy Flint

This place has the best frozen custard I’ve ever had. So many menu choices! Very reasonably priced too!

Haley Lynn

A favorite spot for my brother and I. We drove by after 9 tonight and the owner turned the lights back on and made sure we got our ice cream fix. 10/10 recommend. Good ice cream and even better people. And a fraction of the cost compared to other places.

Brittany Williams

It's nice to have an ice cream shop up the road, and it's a plus to avoid downtown traffic sometimes. What makes this place great is that the owner is super friendly and kind!

Eli

Waited by the window for over 5 minutes without even being acknowledged by the person inside. Waste of time. Got our ice cream somewhere else.

Service: 1

Holly Westcott

Awesome ice cream. Super friendly. We go a few times a year whenever we’re in the area! Love it!

Brian Smith

The menu is MIND BOGGLING! It is like 10 pages?!? I could thankfully narrow it down to the shake column but then... What flavor to pick? I saw "Boston shake". I asked the cute-as-a-bug about 12 year old cashier, "What is a 'Boston shake?'" She relayed the question back. I said "Perfect!". I paid, she made my change. I asked "is there a tip jar?" "You mean for me personally?" "Yes" "You can just give it to me" She so reminded me of my granddaughter. She brightened my day :) And the shake was AWESOME!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...