Peppy & Eddy's

1 Cacchioli Ct, Highland Mills
(845) 928-9876

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kayden Vaughn

I always stop by getting some food in this place. I love the quick service and well prepared food. 5 stars.

Paige Rubach

It has amazing food and great service!! Sadly, right now, it is closed due to Covid. Hoping they reopen because their crab cakes are to die for!!!

Elizabeth Johnson

Nice cozy place, I like the ambiance. The food was great and the service was really good.

Claire Ventura-Wolf

The best white pizza ever !!!!! And fantastic salad with homemade dressing .

Adalberto Rodelo

It’s a cute atmosphere n the food is really good !

Colby Maxwell

This place is worth trying. They have big portions for reasonable rates. Constantly neat and with awesome ambience. Would recommend to others.

Hamza Callahan

This place is worth giving a shot. They have big portions for reasonable prices. Consistently well organized and with good mood. Highly recommended.

Loraine Abrams

Always the best Service and they're food is delicious! Celeste your amazing!

Erin O'Connor Forrester

We celebrated our son’s 1st communion at Peppy & Eddy’s. 40 people for an afternoon - Celeste, Dan and the staff were awesome - food was fantastic (lemon chicken!!!) and we felt at home. We love the food, the charm and we’re taken care of every minute. THANK YOU!! It made our day that much better. Look forward to seeing you soon!

Erin O'Connor Forrester

We celebrated our son's 1st communion at Peppy & Eddy's. 40 people for an afternoon - Celeste, Dan and the staff were awesome - food was fantastic (lemon chicken!!!) and we felt at home. We love the food, the charm and we're taken care of every minute. THANK YOU!! It made our day that much better. Look forward to seeing you soon!

Jim Bixler

Been passing this place for years, finally stopped in and loved it. Comfortable bar and dinning room with all the family as your servers. Food is fresh and made from old world recipes.

Mike Elliott

Staff was excellent, bar was very aesthetic, food was good.

Kev Swing

Great atmosphere, terrific food (highly recommend the crab cakes) and generous portions.. Love it here, hidden gem in Highland Mills! Recently through my wife a surprise 50th Birthday Party, and it couldn't have been better! The food was amazing, the service impeccable and the ambience incredible.

anthony picarelli

Very good meal. Staff was very helpful. Overall a nice experience

Tara Ward Adamos

Delicious food, wonderful people.

Loading...