Gibeye's Pizza & The Ashley Watering Hole

We finally tried Gibeye’s and so pleased with the food and the service! We ordered online for pickup because we’re outside the delivery area…worth the drive! The online ordering was easy to use and I was able to select my pick up time. Order was ready early but kept hot until I arrived. Greeted by super friendly staff who also gave me a frequent buyer card…we’ll for sure be back to fill it up! I ordered my go to pizza- pepperoni, black olives and jalapeños - it was perfect! Just the right amount of sauce and cheese and perfect amount of toppings - no skimping! The crust was perfect too..not tough! Husband ordered the fish sandwich and he was very satisfied. Kept talking about how big and good it was. I didn’t realize they had a dining area, we’ll definitely take advantage of that in the future!

A true local joint, but the regulars are super friendly and the food is worth your time. Very welcoming.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

The service was wonderful. The staff was very accommodating to my order. Friendly when I picked it up. The pizza was awesome too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Read to end...So we have lived across the street from Gibeyes for about 15 years. We loved it and ordered it several times a month. then it was sold and after about 5 orders of burned pizzas and subs we gave up ordering. Not a fan of the other place which shall not be mentioned. so for 2 years we were just eating frozen pizza. Sad right? The salads even tasted and smelled old. Then it was sold again. We decided to try it again and it was like an old friend returned. Not a single order wrong or disappointing. Your delivery people know us and our porch parrot very well once again 🤣❤️ Thanks Votaw & Gibeyes family!

Gibeye’s delivers!!! So excited.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food, great service and entertainment with that down home atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love our hometown restaurant. The owner is so very nice and kind. And the staff is always friendly. My go to place for wings. Thanks so much for delicious local food!

Busy on a Friday night. Means it's good.

Terrible 8 pickle chips for 8 dollars..... owner says he wouldn't pay that much for them and says no one complains about his business. This is disgusting a dollar a chip

Best restaurant in ashley oh

I just got chicken wings and they were cold and way over cooked

Good pizza and atmosphere! 2nd time here and I expect to visit many more times even though we're not close by.

Been here a few times and the food is always good, great service, and went for karaoke Tuesday night and was a wonderful experience. Will definitely be back *gonna make Tuesday nights a regular thing 👍👍

Was there tonight. A very laid-back atmosphere. They had karaoke and it was awesome.

Great food and they now have karaoke on Tuesday nights (5pm to 9pm)! The staff is super friendly. They also deliver (food, not karaoke).