Guys Pizza Co.

538 East Superior Ave, Cleveland
(216) 298-5100

Recent Reviews

Autumn Boehle

For how late they're open, and the fact they deliver up to your hotel room even on floor 15, I'd consider this good pizza and service. Ordered at 11:55 it got here just after 12:30. Hot, full of toppings, can't complain. Order it every time we're in the city. I'd share a pic but it's been 10 minutes and the 2 of us already smashed the whole medium pizza lmfao

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vimarie

I won't go back because tasteless and sauce on pizza taste weird and I got the runs 10 after eating two bites that I took before I threw it to the garbage.

Natalie Spencer

I was told it would be 12 minutes but an hour later still nothing...they tried to make me pay for it again but I refused...never offered a discount and accused me of trying to get a free pizza ..0/10 would not

Food: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slices

Sophie M

Def not the same as Kent’s. Ordered delivery and it took FOREVER, and it tasted/looked nothing like the one in Kent. Don’t waste your $$, order dominos.

Big Al (Cleveland Van Man)

Righteous zaaa brrraaahhhhh!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Ess

Asked to place an order to go. And a girl in the background said “NO”. Then hung up.

Frank Kidd

Joe showed amazing customer service! On top of that Ana allowed me to use her phone charger

Ben B

3 dollars for a fresh hot pep slice, can't beat that. Tasty

Raven Gurley

They are

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Pepperoni Pizza, Guyzone, Pizza by the Slice

simpletechstuffcom

Some of the best pizza in Cleveland. The price is great and the pizza is even better. You can't really get a better slice for the price.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Pepperoni Pizza, Slice of Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Pizza by the Slice

Brad Nixon

Ordered a quasadillaWaited on it for a half hr asked how much longer and was told its getting boxed up right now after waiting 45 minutes on it l asked for my money back and the girl just got out of her seat and walked off the pizza I had during my wait was actually pretty good wish I could say the same about the service in my experience Anything other than pizza by the slice you had probably better be prepared to spend 2 hrs in this place

Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice

Stephen McCormick

Great late night place for a quick, decent, filling meal for it's price. I stop in here often for the buffalo chicken quesadillas. Mhmm!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Subs, Guyzone

Patrick Dary

I don’t even know where to start. I don’t even know if this place owns a fryer.. I ordered chicken tenders and fries (well done extra crispy please.) when my food came about ten mins later something told me not to leave and to just try my food before I left (I like my food fresh and crispy) the chicken tenders were soft & rubbery and the fries were as soft as mashed potatoes and broken and flimsy and pale as Casper the ghost (there is no way they have a fryer back there ) as I’m thinking to myself “thank god I tried this before I left “ I bring it back to the cashier and let her know (politely ) that I can’t eat the food if I could just get something else she than calls her manager over and I tell him same and he kindly agrees to change my order so I ask are the boneless wings actually crispy (on their menu it says fried to perfection ) (there is no way there is a fryer back there ) he continues yes we bread them and it fry’s a couple times till it’s our desired crispiness . NO PROBLEM ! That’s exactly what I want and wanna hear right … WRONG. I wait 15 more mins for my boneless wings I receive them and say thank you than walk outside to try the food cause at this point I’m not gonna be a pain again.. the boneless chicken “wings” tasted like the cut the chicken tenders into smaller pieces and tossed them in sauce. There was nothing remotely crispy about them it didn’t even taste air fried or over baked. It tasted like they breaded chicken and popped it in the microwave and tossed them in sauce. I’ve had Dino nuggets that have tasted better than this food has and the only good this I can say is the staff was genuinely nice. But other than that I can promise I will never step foot in that place again .. you expect things like this for delivery but to order fresh at restaurant and eat there so you avoid thing like that and for it to be worse is horrendous.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Jessica N

Pizza was delivered cold and rock hard. The second time in a row the dipping sauce I paid for was NOT included. The extra topping I paid for was NOT included. Received thin crust which I did NOT order. Ridiculous really.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

John McPhail

Great late night spot. It's not a 5 star restaurant but I don't think they'd claim that either.Pizza and salad were both quite delicious!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Load More