Bexley Pizza Plus

2651 E Main St, Columbus
(614) 237-3305

Recent Reviews

Colton Perdue

Great little shop. Good lunch deals.Parking: Small lot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Ultimate, Italian Sub, Ultimate Pizza, Pepperoni and Mushrooms Pizza

Geocaching gal C

Food was great. Waited inside for it to be made and was cringing at only one employee wearing a hat. No one had a hair net or hat. Touching food with bare hands. One employee texting on cellphone (which is fine) but then to go back and handle food. Ahh! After handling money and touching the register hands must be washed. Can't wait for robots to make food. No mouth droplets, hair or uncaring individuals handling food. Of all my sub was the best ever just wish employees would do the bare minimum and at least put a hat on to hold hair back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Geissman

Great pizza! Peperoni, bacon and jalapeño for the win!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hopeless Romantic (No romance)

The food was good, the people were nice, and it overall gives off good vibes. The workers were so helpful and nice, and even waited patiently when it came to ordering. 10 out of 10 I would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Elon Nichols

We went here for a lunch date. The pizza was delicious. The staff and the service was great! The restaurant is very clean and relaxing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Faith Baldwin

i worked here for 3 years, my first job. i love this place and the people. i will miss working here!! <3 (also the food is really good of course.)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emma Whitaker

Ordered a white pizza 28.00 no sauce very dry. Called and they said they couldn't put much sauce because the toppings would fly off that makes no sense. Never apologized or offered a refund.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nicole Ratliff

Pizza was excellent. The Italian subs had way too much dressing on them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Mushrooms Pizza

Destiny Ma'at Hotep Daniels (Mama Ma'at)

The staff is very friendly and helpful. The store is very clean. Service is quick. Food is excellent. We got a pizza and 2 subs.Vegetarian options: There are a few veggie optionsKid-friendliness: Very kid friendlyParking: Parking lot is in the front and side with plenty of spaces

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Melissa Alexander

I just came in to buy a pizza for my sister and when i ordered it and gave my $ to the young male cashier he took it with no problem but when I held out my hand that was plain as day to hand me my $ back he clearly looked at me and said it on the counterI was completely surprised by what he just did so i left my hand reaching out for him to give me my $ the same way that I gave it to him and all he dis was leave my $ where it was told me how long my wait was for my pizza and walked away. It's a shame that a establishment that has a variety of people that I have seen patronage this business would still be treating people in this manner!! I have came here multiple times here for her and this is the first time that I have encountered this type of service!! Hopefully the management can address this problem so no other customer can feel the way that I feel right now again!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Ro Go

DO NOT BE FOOLED!! They show one price online, and when you order, they say "oh, those online prices are out dated"...WHAT??!!!...REALLY?? and you haven't fixed them?? (and you are expected to pay the higher price)....NOPE...Joe''s Pizza is 2 blocks away on E. Broad (with accurate prices displayed on their website) or Momma Nancy's next to the BMV on E. Broad as well.

Aimee Re

This is our is our favorite go-to Pizzeria! We’ve likely eaten more than a hundred pies from here at this point. Pizzas are usually pretty consistently in quality/ how they are made. Have enjoyed eat-in, carry out and delivery options. Place is clean and staff is friendly.

Yo DogLover

Pretty poor all around. I got a meatball sub and a pizza sub. Meatball sub was poor. Not flavorful at all. Pizza sub was a little better but not enough to buy again. They used to be good, but they've fell to the bottom. They was putting the chairs up at 7:30 already like they didn't want any business. I won't go there again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tim Kazee

This is my #2 when it comes to pizza in Columbus, Ohio. I live, LITERALLY, 5 mins from them. I’ve gotten multiple deliveries in the past. I call tonight, and Mike (manager) isn’t able to see my delivery history, and tells me they don’t deliver to me. Even though, I’ve had this establishment deliver to me MULTIPLE times.I’m 5 mins from you!! 8 mins with traffic. Do better. Either deliver to my home, or don’t. But don’t deliver to me many times, and then say, “nawwww, we don’t deliver that far out (5min drive). Craziness.

Mike McKeegan

Nice pizza. Had better. They don’t appear to be interested in their dining room.

Load More