Bexley Pizza Plus

2651 E Main St, Columbus
(614) 237-3305

Recent Reviews

Victor Rodriguez

We had good pizza in the past from Bexley Pizza Plus. We just picked up our request of a vegetarian pizza large. Terrible! We asked for crispy and not even that. The vegetables were not even cooked...raw. Paid $26 cold cash and is not the money. They must be new employees....It will be a long time before we go back!!!!!.

Evan G

Excellent and unique variety of pizzas. Can't go wrong!

N B.

Yep, this is your "go to place" for your pizza appetite !!! THIER pepperoni pizza and cheese pizza are what a good pizza should be in my honest opinion; Fresh, non-greasy, Flavorful, chewy center with a crisp crust, YUM and just the right amount of sauce, I can't count how many times I have order pizza here in C-bus that you can barely tell it is even on it.., and it's a regular pizza, no specialty pizza. I am new to the area and so happy to have found this place:))

Nicole Toles

Discovered Bexley Pizza Plus almost a year ago, and now we order from there at least twice a month. (We order from other pizza spots when we don’t order from BPP)

Chris Badenhop

The ultimate is what pepperoni and mushroom pizza dreams are made of!! Very good pizza that is clearly made with high-quality ingredients. Made in the style of many traditional Columbus area pizza shops with a thin and crispy crust. However, the crust is much more fluffy and lighter on the inside than others. Very good and I can't wait to come back

Adrian Scott

And the winner is...Bexely Pizza Plus. As a teenager, young adult is drop in here to have a bite after a jog thru the neighborhood where I'd pretend I owned one of the mini mansions and was waiting for friends to join me. I eventually purchased a home, in the Historic Bryden area, foryears after graduating high school, got married, had children and this is now the place I either pick up a personal pizza to go and eat in my car or dine in and share memories with My children, (notsomuchsonow) or meet adult friends. My favorite thing to order then was the greek pizza and now I'm sort of a plain pepperoni knind of girl. It's loud friendly, they have high chairs, and local and domestic adult beverages and fountain drinks. They employee teens or young adults that have the right attitude and make it a great place to continue to visit.

Chris B.

The ultimate is what pepperoni and mushroom pizza dreams are made of!! Very good pizza that is clearly made with high-quality ingredients. Made in the style of many traditional Columbus area pizza shops with a thin and crispy crust. However, the crust is much more fluffy and lighter on the inside than others. Very good and I can't wait to come back!

Trip Wuellner

Great local pizza. Has quickly become a new favorite

ErinHugh Ball

They have an amazing topping selection, and a wonderful array of house pies.

Mike L.

Great pizza! Best in Bexley! Had a wonderful experience with my Grandma and family. Truly a local gem, if you have not been i highly recommend.

Angela Eason

Quaint atmosphere hidden away in Bexley, OH. The place smells amazing when you walk in. Very clean and staff were all absolutely wonderful. Upon entering staff was on the phone, another team member jumped in immediately and got my pick up squared away. The staff member on the phone was speaking with an elderly individual, she repeatedly showed the caller kindness above and beyond your every day service. When hanging up was still the epitome of professionalism, commenting on how she loves her job and the customers she gets to serve. I want people like this always making my food. I deliver for a service here in the city, so I didn't get to see or taste the pie but as I told the customer I dropped it off to, You are definitely going to enjoy this pie, especially if it's anywhere close to ranking as high as their customer service.

cindi pochatek

This has to be the worst pizza I’ve ever ever had. A pizza from a box, or a slice at a gas station is far better. Bought Pizza for watching the osu game and my friends said it’s usually much better. If quality goes that far down at busy times, that’s not worth the risk of wasting your money. Terrible pizza. Thick rock-hard crust, miniscuel toppings on any of the edges.I don’t understand how the price matches the quality on this.

Eric Zimmerman

Great pizza and more. Awesome lunch specials.

Andres Rodriguez

I ordered a philly steak pizza, mega meat pizza and a deluxe chef salad.. omg food was amazing!! Definetly would recommend..

Bridget Perry

Nice little place down the road. Pizza was very good. Clean and tide seating.

Load More