Papa Johns Pizza

3644 Main St, Hilliard
(614) 777-4545

Recent Reviews


Never allow papa johns to send sms texts! After accepting I get texts all time of day and night from asking for my cc info to fat loss diets. Make it stop!

Samantha Rose

The food was cold when we waited over an hour : we're less then 2 miles away.


Did this location close? You literally can't order online for delivery or pick-up at this location. It's listed in Google, I went to the website by clicking the link for this location. I tried to place an order I selected carry-out. The site asked me to choose a location and this location is not on the list. I tried the same with delivery and the same issue. This location is either not there, or it doesn't offer carry-out or delivery. Maybe only walk-ins but that ain't no good. This is preposterous service. I want to talk to a manager. Won't someone get me a manager?

lisa marie bowers

Was told my order would be delivered in 35 mins... over an hour and 15 mins later it showed up.... cold.. gross and unedible..... never again.. sooo unhappy and disappointed

Ryan Sandman

Horrible service horrible pizza papa johns

Madeline blanton

Called and placed an order for delivery on 11/5 at 10:20 pm estimated delivery time was 30-40 mins. It is now 11:35 pm the pizza has not yet been delivered and I waited on the phone on hold with this location over 15 minutes and nobody answered. I drove to the location only to find out it’s closed now when I call the number I can’t even get an update on my eta for delivery. This was my first time ordering from this location and I never will again. It is now 11:39 and my door was just now knocked on while writing this review. This pizza is lukewarm and doesn’t even taste fresh. The pizza itself looks like it has sat out for a while before delivery. I understand there is a nationwide shortage of workers but this is a bit ridiculous. Not worth my $17 and some change.


Ordered my pizza well done and it wasn’t, the check out girl was really friendly!


Delivery order was very late, like maybe an hour late and not very warm. The chicken poppers were honestly one of the worst things I’ve ever had. I normally hate to be wasteful and will not throw anything away, but these were literally awful and I could not choke the rest down.

Robert Schoen

The pizza was done quickly, and it was absolutely great.

Dee Holleran

Not one person wearing a mask in the entire restaurant. Won't be ordering from there again ... they can keep their COVID.

Robin Virgin

fast friendly and pleasant workers and the pizza was great

Antonia “AJay” Severino

Really good pizza. Great deals. I love that my pizza was straight out the oven fresh!!

Kyle Smith

On hold for 20 mins. After dealing with another location out in Westerville. Papa John’s is a jokeUpdate now have been on hold for 30 mins.

Sean Stump

They get my order right every time, the food gets here fast honestly this location is the best quality papa John's I ever experienced. I've been extremely satisfied on every occasion

David Fontaine

Definitely the best chain pizza in Hilliard

Load More