Usually visit this Tavern once a year while working in Ohio. The food is outstanding, some of the best Shepherd's Pie that I've ever eaten and a great beer selection. HomeTown feel and everybody's very friendly.
Mike E.
Our first visit here on a Saturday evening with a party of four.. Busy but still a couple of open tables. We sat in the back room away from the music so we could have a conversation.Our server was Neal, a little curt but attentive and efficient. There were no service missteps.I had a Smithwick's draft to start. I intended to order the shepherd's pie, but when I found out the daily special was a 12 oz piece of prime rib with potatoes and broccoli for only 18 bucks, I got that. A real bargain and it tasted great. Very little fat. I started with fried pickle spears which tasted good, but all the breading fell off, so they need to adress that dish. The bowl of chili was HUGE. It was obviously homemade--not much spice but it was marginally OK. Everyone else liked what they ordered. Two of us got bread pudding for dessert. A little on the dry side, but OK. All in all, I would give this place 3 and 1/2 stars and I would like to return and get the shepherd's pie or maybe meat loaf.
Stephanie B.
Service is lacking, minimal contact by server and had to request everything (condiments, more drinks). The food sucks.
renee furyes
Nice Irish bar with great food. Ordered Irish stew and Corned Beef Boxty. Previously had shepards pie. Service was good, food was tastee and hot.
Rudy Gruenke III
The food was amazing! Everyone in our group chose a different selection and everyone said theirs was delicious. Friendly servers made it a great meal. We will all go back again.
Andrew Ricks
These guys are great! Very personable and friendly! We went to see Dulahan, a Dayton band that does traditional Irish and Scottish. Staff was very professional. Selection was about a 9 of 10. I mean if you have more than one selection of Tullamore Dew you’re on your game. Macallan 18, JW Blue, and Red Breast. Truly devoted to the spirits. Food was good too and quickly done. These guys rock!
Dora M.
I've been to this pub a few times and have really enjoyed the food and drinks. The atmosphere is a great pub environment. Service was a bit slow the last 2 times I've been there, but nice servers. A bit pricey on the drinks. Food is average price.
mike schramm
1st time there and it was amazing. Great food.our waitress was exceptionally good. Our food came out quick and our drinks never went empty. I will definitely recommend anyone to stop in and get something to eat
Todd F.
Awesome food and service. Came in to town Beer Fest weekend and had to stop at an Irish Pub, this one did not disappoint. Clean establishment and friendly staff. We tried the fish and chips and smothered pork fries, both solid recommendations.
Amanda Montemayor
We went on Saturday 3/18 - they were very busy with St Patrick’s Day, but they were attentive the whole time we were there. Our food was amazing - we hade some of their St Patrick’s day specials and the haddock was overflowing on the plate it was so big! 10/10 experience there!
My friend and I drove up here for the day from Columbus. We did some shopping and went here for lunch! Very extensive menu and I had researched it online! So very disappointed in the food! We got the fish and chips(Haddock). It was unlike any I had ever had! Very very greasy. Have had better at chain restaurants and since they were an Irish pub was expecting amazing! The fries were great and the coleslaw way to much mayonnaise! Will not recommend it!
lindsay paramore
Medina in general has some of the nicest people we have ever met but especially at Sully’s! We’ve been here a few times now and have enjoyed it every single time. Last time they let us crash a private party because we didn’t realize it was closed that day but it was snowing a lot outside and they were so welcoming. Absolute 5 star service and their food is so great too!!!
Josh Adam
Awesome service and great staff. I got the angry leprechaun burger, best burger I've ever had the fries were also great. The live music they had was phenomenal too!
Gerald W.
Waited 45. Minutes and no food, very disappointed. Use to like this place how ever last time was not to par .
Andrea Stockle
Our office is on Medina Square, so we order out quite a bit. Ordered office lunch today and everything was amazing. Pot pie was to die for. Girls said the Turkey Rachel and Chicken bacon Ranch wrap were fantastic. The best lunch we have ordered in a long time.Thank you Sully's !!
Usually visit this Tavern once a year while working in Ohio. The food is outstanding, some of the best Shepherd's Pie that I've ever eaten and a great beer selection. HomeTown feel and everybody's very friendly.
Our first visit here on a Saturday evening with a party of four.. Busy but still a couple of open tables. We sat in the back room away from the music so we could have a conversation.Our server was Neal, a little curt but attentive and efficient. There were no service missteps.I had a Smithwick's draft to start. I intended to order the shepherd's pie, but when I found out the daily special was a 12 oz piece of prime rib with potatoes and broccoli for only 18 bucks, I got that. A real bargain and it tasted great. Very little fat. I started with fried pickle spears which tasted good, but all the breading fell off, so they need to adress that dish. The bowl of chili was HUGE. It was obviously homemade--not much spice but it was marginally OK. Everyone else liked what they ordered. Two of us got bread pudding for dessert. A little on the dry side, but OK. All in all, I would give this place 3 and 1/2 stars and I would like to return and get the shepherd's pie or maybe meat loaf.
Service is lacking, minimal contact by server and had to request everything (condiments, more drinks). The food sucks.
Nice Irish bar with great food. Ordered Irish stew and Corned Beef Boxty. Previously had shepards pie. Service was good, food was tastee and hot.
The food was amazing! Everyone in our group chose a different selection and everyone said theirs was delicious. Friendly servers made it a great meal. We will all go back again.
These guys are great! Very personable and friendly! We went to see Dulahan, a Dayton band that does traditional Irish and Scottish. Staff was very professional. Selection was about a 9 of 10. I mean if you have more than one selection of Tullamore Dew you’re on your game. Macallan 18, JW Blue, and Red Breast. Truly devoted to the spirits. Food was good too and quickly done. These guys rock!
I've been to this pub a few times and have really enjoyed the food and drinks. The atmosphere is a great pub environment. Service was a bit slow the last 2 times I've been there, but nice servers. A bit pricey on the drinks. Food is average price.
1st time there and it was amazing. Great food.our waitress was exceptionally good. Our food came out quick and our drinks never went empty. I will definitely recommend anyone to stop in and get something to eat
Awesome food and service. Came in to town Beer Fest weekend and had to stop at an Irish Pub, this one did not disappoint. Clean establishment and friendly staff. We tried the fish and chips and smothered pork fries, both solid recommendations.
We went on Saturday 3/18 - they were very busy with St Patrick’s Day, but they were attentive the whole time we were there. Our food was amazing - we hade some of their St Patrick’s day specials and the haddock was overflowing on the plate it was so big! 10/10 experience there!
Restaurantji Recommends
My friend and I drove up here for the day from Columbus. We did some shopping and went here for lunch! Very extensive menu and I had researched it online! So very disappointed in the food! We got the fish and chips(Haddock). It was unlike any I had ever had! Very very greasy. Have had better at chain restaurants and since they were an Irish pub was expecting amazing! The fries were great and the coleslaw way to much mayonnaise! Will not recommend it!
Medina in general has some of the nicest people we have ever met but especially at Sully’s! We’ve been here a few times now and have enjoyed it every single time. Last time they let us crash a private party because we didn’t realize it was closed that day but it was snowing a lot outside and they were so welcoming. Absolute 5 star service and their food is so great too!!!
Awesome service and great staff. I got the angry leprechaun burger, best burger I've ever had the fries were also great. The live music they had was phenomenal too!
Waited 45. Minutes and no food, very disappointed. Use to like this place how ever last time was not to par .
Our office is on Medina Square, so we order out quite a bit. Ordered office lunch today and everything was amazing. Pot pie was to die for. Girls said the Turkey Rachel and Chicken bacon Ranch wrap were fantastic. The best lunch we have ordered in a long time.Thank you Sully's !!