Mishelle Handy Cakes

1315 E Danforth Rd, Edmond
(405) 359-8308

Recent Reviews

Megan Winter

This business was great to work with! The cake turned out so stinking cute! On top of that it was DELICIOUS! Such a moist perfect cake, which you don’t always get when it’s more decorative. I highly recommend.

Greg Gesell

My sister loved her cake. Excellent taste. The color and design were perfect.

Laura McPherson

Perfect cake for our daughters 40th and we ordered from Michigan and they made this cake EXACTLY as asked

Carmen Wilson

This review is about cookies and a not custom cake. I walked into Michelle Handy Cakes to inquire about cookies for my daughter’s birthday. After discussing a few options with the worker, I decided to get soccer balls on half of the cookies and another design on the other half. I pre-paid for my order and agreed upon a time to pick them up. A day and a half later, I received a message from the bakery saying there was an “issue” with my order. I call back the same day but no one answers so I leave a message. I received a call back the NEXT day (the day of my daughter’s birthday). I was told that they can’t do soccer balls designs. Then asked what design I would want instead. What!? It’s the day of my daughter’s birthday, I’ve already planned around the soccer theme. So I felt forced to choose something else so I wouldn’t be stuck without any cookies! When I went to pick them up, there was another woman there (I assume the owner). She said “oh we stopped doing soccer ball designs on cookies over a year ago”. What?! Why didn’t your staff know this. Nothing was offered for my inconvenience (no discount, nothing). Just an overall terrible experience with this business. Not to mention the cookies were terrible.

Audrey Samaras

Mishelle made me the most FABULOUS cake for my 21st birthday! She was so welcoming and wonderful to work with. The cake was complemented all night and everyone loved it! I highly recommend ordering from Mishelle!

Danielle Amos

Mishelle was so easy to work with and truly made the best cake I have ever had! I met with her one night to go over my vision, and she had plenty of ideas to help boost and mold what I was thinking for the wedding and groom’s cake. The cake’s were truly stunning, but the taste could not be beat! We did a vanilla cake with layered Bavarian creme and raspberry filling for the wedding cake, and a coconut cake and filling for the groom’s cake. I could eat those cakes every day and never get tired of them! She also delivered to the venue with cake stands which helped take more off our plate!

Montana Blevins

Thank you for providing the best customer service AND the cutest cupcakes for my mother in laws birthday today!!

Amy Thomas

Thank you so much for making my parents' 50th anniversary wedding cake. It looked and tasted amazing! It was a big hit with everyone! I will definitely be coming back for any other events I have!

David DobsonTucker

Mishelle creates every cake for every occasion for my family. Birthdays, anniversary, pretty much everything. Every order is exactly how we discussed. And the taste is so amazing!!!

Crystal May Choate

Surprised my husband with a couple of different cheese cake slices. He loved all three and can’t wait to try more. He said it was the best cheese cake he’s ever had. The young lady that helped me was super sweet. We will be back!


Absolutely incredible customer service and quality products!! I had some cupcakes for my significant other in advance from another place, the dog literally ate all of them and I called up here, let them know what I needed and they had it ready literally in minutes! I had everything set up, the dogs got the door open and I called up here, basically frantic, lol, and they did a wonderful job, flavors are incredible designs are incredible! She threw in some candles and everything, just in the nick of time! It was my first time using them but I had heard great things about them and they are all true so definitely check them out!

Isabelle Kearney

Mishelle’s cakes are just gorgeous! She allowed me to text inspiration pictures of cakes to her, which she used to craft mine. She did an excellent job!

Heather Morgan

Mishelle did an AMAZING job on my daughter's birthday cake. My daughter absolutely loved it and I will definitely be getting all my future cakes from Mishelle.

Jacob Holmes

Made both our wedding cake & wedding guest cupcakes, and they. Were. Divine!!! Helped add to the magic of our July wedding.We're still eating the frozen cupcakes over a month later, and they are still just as good as they were that night.We will 100% be coming back for more!

paige lee

Beautifully decorated and was delicious! I will definitely be ordering from Mishelle again.

Load More