No one was around and it's basically pay on the honor system. They were good but too small for the price. $12.00 a pie seems steep. I could understand for some of the specialty flavors but not traditional ones. And honestly not much difference in taste than most other pie places.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
R H
Ok, first off, the pies are fine; even good. But they are incredibly small and SHOCKINGLY expensive. Basically , it's $12 for one SMALL pie that is not as good as at many restaurants, for more money.They are personal pies, like the size of frozen chicken pot pies. You get the pies out of a standing cold case in an upstairs vacant room. A bit awkward and difficult to find.It's kind of a fun thing to try once, but I don't think I'll go back...now, if the pies were $6 per pie, I would buy 6 pies in a heartbeat.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Sadie Rockford
The pies alone deserve 5 stars, even 3 days later it still has perfect crust but the simple easy atmosphere and little samples just make it so much better. So grateful for this small business, truly the best pies on the coast!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple, Strawberry Rhubarb
Mitch H.
Never experienced something like this place. Not the easiest to find the entrance, but wow! The pies were fantastic and to have a business with an honor system is just so refreshing. They also had samples! We liked the brumble pie.
Ashli E.
Came here during the ice storm so a lot of businesses were closed but not Pie Girl Pie Guy! Sampled a few of the pies and they were all so good it was hard to make a choice! We ultimately got razzleberry and a chocolate cream and they were insanely good!! Worth every penny and if you don't want to fork out the $12 for a pie, they even have some day olds for $5 and it was seriously so good!! The honor system is definitely a new vibe but overall it was super cute! There's even a little guest book to sign! Definitely will be a must have anytime we are in cannon beach!
Chris L.
Such a find. We'd never noticed Pie Girl Pie Guy even though we come to Cannon Beach a couple times per year. Looks like they opened around 2020. We stopped in and sampled a few of their pies - all delicious. At least when we were there, it was on the honor system. Pies are pretty pricey ($12 for a small) but they had a handful that were $5 each so we picked up an apple (excellent) and a pecan (very good). Will totally come back again on our next trip.
Melinda Ferdig
Best pie I've ever had! Highly recommend. Will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blueberry Peach
Grace T
loved the chocolate cream pie!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sarah B.
Amazing!!!! Stopped by here in Sept. 2023 and grabbed a chocolate cream pie and a pumpkin pie, both were amazing. Love the honor system, sort of hard to find but worth it!
Denise T.
Fabulous find in Cannon Beach for dessert. So glad I found them on Yelp as they are kind of hidden upstairs. We tried the Banana cream and Peach crumble mini pies. My husband loves banana cream and this one was on point with a delicate crust with a silky custard and a luscious whipped cream topping. I enjoyed my peach crumble pie because of the perfectly spiced peaches and light toasted crumble on top. Nice to know they are opened into the evening for a late night treat in the future.
Cute shop tucked away upstairs. Sampled the razzle and Marion berry pies. Their Pies were available on the honor system, so there wasn't anyone to ask if their crust had butter, lard, or other shortening. Perhaps their nutritional information, allergy information could be better indicated.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Abbi Wood
Seriously very good. Even though I sampled, we only came home with two and I wish we would have picked up a whole bunch ? next time! Love love love everything about this place and will be sure to stop by every visit x
Derek Yates
Loved the atmosphere and setup in pie room. Strawberry Rhubarb was amazing as well. ??
Aaron Shearman
Quirky little off the beat pie place! Tucked up in a corner it’s a little bit goofy to find. The pie selection was very good. As others have said bring cash.
Sarah Finley
This pie is amazing!!! We had a little trouble catching them being open on time, but it was so worth it. We had coconut cream, chocolate pecan, and brambleberry. Already dug in to the first two listed and they were delicious. We had a rough trip and some bad experiences and so this was a shining star moment. They also have day-olds for 5 bucks, but the 12 is a perfect share for two!
No one was around and it's basically pay on the honor system. They were good but too small for the price. $12.00 a pie seems steep. I could understand for some of the specialty flavors but not traditional ones. And honestly not much difference in taste than most other pie places.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ok, first off, the pies are fine; even good. But they are incredibly small and SHOCKINGLY expensive. Basically , it's $12 for one SMALL pie that is not as good as at many restaurants, for more money.They are personal pies, like the size of frozen chicken pot pies. You get the pies out of a standing cold case in an upstairs vacant room. A bit awkward and difficult to find.It's kind of a fun thing to try once, but I don't think I'll go back...now, if the pies were $6 per pie, I would buy 6 pies in a heartbeat.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
The pies alone deserve 5 stars, even 3 days later it still has perfect crust but the simple easy atmosphere and little samples just make it so much better. So grateful for this small business, truly the best pies on the coast!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple, Strawberry Rhubarb
Never experienced something like this place. Not the easiest to find the entrance, but wow! The pies were fantastic and to have a business with an honor system is just so refreshing. They also had samples! We liked the brumble pie.
Came here during the ice storm so a lot of businesses were closed but not Pie Girl Pie Guy! Sampled a few of the pies and they were all so good it was hard to make a choice! We ultimately got razzleberry and a chocolate cream and they were insanely good!! Worth every penny and if you don't want to fork out the $12 for a pie, they even have some day olds for $5 and it was seriously so good!! The honor system is definitely a new vibe but overall it was super cute! There's even a little guest book to sign! Definitely will be a must have anytime we are in cannon beach!
Such a find. We'd never noticed Pie Girl Pie Guy even though we come to Cannon Beach a couple times per year. Looks like they opened around 2020. We stopped in and sampled a few of their pies - all delicious. At least when we were there, it was on the honor system. Pies are pretty pricey ($12 for a small) but they had a handful that were $5 each so we picked up an apple (excellent) and a pecan (very good). Will totally come back again on our next trip.
Best pie I've ever had! Highly recommend. Will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blueberry Peach
loved the chocolate cream pie!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Amazing!!!! Stopped by here in Sept. 2023 and grabbed a chocolate cream pie and a pumpkin pie, both were amazing. Love the honor system, sort of hard to find but worth it!
Fabulous find in Cannon Beach for dessert. So glad I found them on Yelp as they are kind of hidden upstairs. We tried the Banana cream and Peach crumble mini pies. My husband loves banana cream and this one was on point with a delicate crust with a silky custard and a luscious whipped cream topping. I enjoyed my peach crumble pie because of the perfectly spiced peaches and light toasted crumble on top. Nice to know they are opened into the evening for a late night treat in the future.
Restaurantji Recommends
Cute shop tucked away upstairs. Sampled the razzle and Marion berry pies. Their Pies were available on the honor system, so there wasn't anyone to ask if their crust had butter, lard, or other shortening. Perhaps their nutritional information, allergy information could be better indicated.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Seriously very good. Even though I sampled, we only came home with two and I wish we would have picked up a whole bunch ? next time! Love love love everything about this place and will be sure to stop by every visit x
Loved the atmosphere and setup in pie room. Strawberry Rhubarb was amazing as well. ??
Quirky little off the beat pie place! Tucked up in a corner it’s a little bit goofy to find. The pie selection was very good. As others have said bring cash.
This pie is amazing!!! We had a little trouble catching them being open on time, but it was so worth it. We had coconut cream, chocolate pecan, and brambleberry. Already dug in to the first two listed and they were delicious. We had a rough trip and some bad experiences and so this was a shining star moment. They also have day-olds for 5 bucks, but the 12 is a perfect share for two!