Extremely friendly people, superb service and great food. The wings are tremendous, highly recommend and of the few various pies we've had all are great. Highly recommend 10/10!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Shore French Fries - New - Cheddar Fries, Mama Marie's Wings, Chicago Deep Dish Pizza 14, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit, The Cheesesteak Deluxe Pizza 14, Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
sean kulp
This is the most carefully crafted pizza I think I’ve had in my life. We ordered the Philly Sicilian and 12 piece wings. The sauce carries throughout the surface area of the pizza and the cheese has so much flavor. The wing meat also falls off the bone,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan Hettinger
This is with out question the best deep dish pizza I have ever had. There is a restaurant in Lou, KY called Wicks Pizza that is very popular and similar but Nicky’s is even better in my opinion. The owner (Tim) is a super nice guy and is very passionate about his business and his products. I order a deep dish from him about once a week so that I can grab a slice from time to time during the week. I will close and just say love Nicky’s Pizza and look forward to my next slice!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Barry Bauman
Pizza was fantastic. Location was unconventional, but the food and staff are great. Love the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill Mullen
Delicious pizza and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashlee Robertson (VampiressNite)
Ordered online through Grub Hub. When my order got delayed on a busy night, the owner reached out personally to let me know about the delay (which was not a problem) and even threw in some free sodas! Over the top customer service. Pizza arrived piping hot and was absolutely amazing! Definitely will order/visit again. Thanks!!!
This Guy's pizza is absolutely fire! Great customer service! Definitely someone that should be supported by his community! You've got a fan for life in me!Thanks for carrying Reading soda!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pappa Nicky's Signature Style - 14 Chicago, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit
Sam Bower
I arrived on time knocked on the door and advised I was here to pick up my order. A very nice gentleman answered the door and apologized as it was going to take longer for my order and offered me a soda while i waited. I said no thanks, I'd wait in my truck. I ordered a detroit and a meat lovers. My guess is that the Detroit was the issue as its not an easy pizza to make. Most places I have gotten it from cook the pizza in the pan for a while, then add cheese and sauce to finish it. I will say the meat lovers were very generous on toppings, and man, was it filling. Great flavor overall, but I'd probably skip the green peppers if I got meat lovers again. The Detroit had good flavor, but it was coming apart. We had to recut both pizzas and had a ton of leftovers. I would like to try the NY style pizza next. And I would consider take and bake as well. The French fries were great as well! Lower ratings were not quality related, just time wasted waiting. I'd say they need to give themselves more time for order processing.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Philly Sicilian Pizza, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit
Brian Penn
Just ordered for the first time and had the Chicago deep dish and an order of fries. Both were delicious. I love the fact these are homemade pizzas. Even my 9-year-old commented on how good the sauce was. We will definitely be ordering again. Thank you!
I came here to give it a try because of the rave reviews so I ordered the Chicago deep dish. Unfortunately, the entire crust was very hard from being overcooked. When the pie was cut, it didn't go all the way through, so I had to cut it again after I got home. The sauce and cheese was good. Don't think I'll be going back here.Edit: I engaged in a conversation with Tim and provided them with a second opportunity. The pizza they prepared was delectable, leaving me with a satisfactory experience during my second visit. Tim exhibited exceptional courtesy and adaptability. I intend to return to the establishment in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina B
Wow. This pizza continues to be the best. Close to impossible to find non dairy options in the burbs. We Had the best pizza tonight, half non dairy. Half "normal". Delicious. Love the new non dairy cheese!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Korey Constable
Best pizza I have ever had. Been getting pizza from here for almost two years now. I usually get the New York and Detroit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Hackman
I highly recommend this place. We ordered the Chicago Deep Dish and it was incredible. The robust sauce and fresh pizza crust carried this pie. You can tell when food is made with love and care. We will definitely be ordering again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pappa Nicky's Signature Style - 14 Chicago
Randy D'Angelo
It is one of the best Pizzas I have ever had. Nevermind that you will be picking it up at a house. IYKYK.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pappa Nicky's Signature Style - 14 Chicago, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit
Extremely friendly people, superb service and great food. The wings are tremendous, highly recommend and of the few various pies we've had all are great. Highly recommend 10/10!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Shore French Fries - New - Cheddar Fries, Mama Marie's Wings, Chicago Deep Dish Pizza 14, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit, The Cheesesteak Deluxe Pizza 14, Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
This is the most carefully crafted pizza I think I’ve had in my life. We ordered the Philly Sicilian and 12 piece wings. The sauce carries throughout the surface area of the pizza and the cheese has so much flavor. The wing meat also falls off the bone,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is with out question the best deep dish pizza I have ever had. There is a restaurant in Lou, KY called Wicks Pizza that is very popular and similar but Nicky’s is even better in my opinion. The owner (Tim) is a super nice guy and is very passionate about his business and his products. I order a deep dish from him about once a week so that I can grab a slice from time to time during the week. I will close and just say love Nicky’s Pizza and look forward to my next slice!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Pizza was fantastic. Location was unconventional, but the food and staff are great. Love the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered online through Grub Hub. When my order got delayed on a busy night, the owner reached out personally to let me know about the delay (which was not a problem) and even threw in some free sodas! Over the top customer service. Pizza arrived piping hot and was absolutely amazing! Definitely will order/visit again. Thanks!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pappa Nicky's Mozzarella Sticks, Philly Sicilian Pizza, Pizza Bianca White Pizza
This Guy's pizza is absolutely fire! Great customer service! Definitely someone that should be supported by his community! You've got a fan for life in me!Thanks for carrying Reading soda!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pappa Nicky's Signature Style - 14 Chicago, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit
I arrived on time knocked on the door and advised I was here to pick up my order. A very nice gentleman answered the door and apologized as it was going to take longer for my order and offered me a soda while i waited. I said no thanks, I'd wait in my truck. I ordered a detroit and a meat lovers. My guess is that the Detroit was the issue as its not an easy pizza to make. Most places I have gotten it from cook the pizza in the pan for a while, then add cheese and sauce to finish it. I will say the meat lovers were very generous on toppings, and man, was it filling. Great flavor overall, but I'd probably skip the green peppers if I got meat lovers again. The Detroit had good flavor, but it was coming apart. We had to recut both pizzas and had a ton of leftovers. I would like to try the NY style pizza next. And I would consider take and bake as well. The French fries were great as well! Lower ratings were not quality related, just time wasted waiting. I'd say they need to give themselves more time for order processing.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Philly Sicilian Pizza, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit
Just ordered for the first time and had the Chicago deep dish and an order of fries. Both were delicious. I love the fact these are homemade pizzas. Even my 9-year-old commented on how good the sauce was. We will definitely be ordering again. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza! Thank you ?
Restaurantji Recommends
I came here to give it a try because of the rave reviews so I ordered the Chicago deep dish. Unfortunately, the entire crust was very hard from being overcooked. When the pie was cut, it didn't go all the way through, so I had to cut it again after I got home. The sauce and cheese was good. Don't think I'll be going back here.Edit: I engaged in a conversation with Tim and provided them with a second opportunity. The pizza they prepared was delectable, leaving me with a satisfactory experience during my second visit. Tim exhibited exceptional courtesy and adaptability. I intend to return to the establishment in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow. This pizza continues to be the best. Close to impossible to find non dairy options in the burbs. We Had the best pizza tonight, half non dairy. Half "normal". Delicious. Love the new non dairy cheese!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Best pizza I have ever had. Been getting pizza from here for almost two years now. I usually get the New York and Detroit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I highly recommend this place. We ordered the Chicago Deep Dish and it was incredible. The robust sauce and fresh pizza crust carried this pie. You can tell when food is made with love and care. We will definitely be ordering again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pappa Nicky's Signature Style - 14 Chicago
It is one of the best Pizzas I have ever had. Nevermind that you will be picking it up at a house. IYKYK.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pappa Nicky's Signature Style - 14 Chicago, Detroit Pan Pizza - 14 Detroit