Sicilian pizza once was good after that every other pizza was not good the dough was too thin they put oregano on top of the cheese oregano doesn't go on top of the cheese take a bite in the pizza and pull away you notice that all the cheese on that slice comes off very plain tasting won't buy there again as an Italian from New York I know what's good pizza and this is not good pizza there's probably two Cooks there one of them cooks very good with the pizza and the other one is not good at all and $25 for Sicilian pie is way overpriced get it in Port Jervis for $20 and it's really good
Alan Villa
Great service and food. Nice atmosphere, but cold. Turn the heat on.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Janet Hurwitz
Not a lot of atmosphere, just tables and chairs with paneling. Big bar. Waiter was very nice and helpful. Eggplant Parm was very fried and not a lot of sauce. Cheese covered the top but not the pieces that were partially layered. Friend had fish which she said was ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Luke Hensel
Food and service are top quality. Naturally leavened pizza crust. Delicious entrees- my eggplant was sliced and cooked perfectly. Gelato and coffee is made in house - delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristi Calldowngirl Sherwood
My husband and I went for pizza tonight. This was our first time here. Just the aroma when entering was enough to make you mouth water. The atmosphere is so nice. The building is beautiful and esthetically pleasing. A soft relaxing ambiance. The pizza (extra cheese, mushroom, onion and garlic NY style) was amazing!!! The crust is thin with a nice crisp. The sauce was seriously on point. One of the best pizzas I have ever had. We will be back!
Dawn Strawser
Great food, good quality, well prepared and so flavorful Worth the stop
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jean-Philippe Mercier
Superb place, great quality stuff. Looking forward to going back in the future when I'm up that way again. The cold coffee drinks are amazing, and their gelato is a no-brainer order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eve Hernandez
Best restaurant around!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Guada Lupe
If I could give them more stars I would. They make the best pizza! The staff is super nice. They make everything from scratch. I really recommend this place. You can tell when someone loves what they do. I wish there was one Carini in every state.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don E
Delicious pizza. We especially liked a few of the speciality pizzas.
Double check if they open - they dont update opening hours on google. Very inconvenient to drive 30’ and see closed door.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Vincent haas
Sort of stumbled on this place, but what a find! If it had nothing more than a great beer list (several Trappist beers!), we’d have loved it. But the Brooklyn pizza was exceptional…thin crust baked crispy, excellent sauce, and mozzarella that tastes like it was just made that morning. The young lady who took care of us was pleasant and efficient (she seemed to be working alone but was totally on top of her game). Can you get a cheaper pizza or meal somewhere else? Sure. But this was a quality experience and worth every penny. We’re looking forward to going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Normann
Great food and ambience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua Anderson
For drinks, we got an iced cappuccino and an iced mocha. For food, we got a Mediterranean shrimp salad and a sausage and green pepper pizza, well done. The salad was excellent, and the NY style pizza was on point. Foldable with a good crunch on the dough.
Everything we ate was excellent, the service was great, and we enjoyed the ambiance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BB Lynn
Food was decent but overpriced in my honest opinion. Pizza was made fresh and from scratch. Brick oven, authentic Italian pizza. The pizza is what I’d imagine I’d get if I went to Italy. Wasn’t over the top fancy but it was good and you can tell it was fresh ingredients. Dough is homemade sourdough and thin crust but that’s by design and it was quite tasty. Fried calamari actually didn’t taste premade. Appeared to be breaded and fried at the restaurant and not premade prebought. They claim the Gelato is homemade on site as well. That was good as well. Atmosphere and service was great. Not busy at all on a Friday night. Only 5 of us in the whole restaurant…. Not sure what to make of that honestly. All food pictured cost $50. We got water.
Sicilian pizza once was good after that every other pizza was not good the dough was too thin they put oregano on top of the cheese oregano doesn't go on top of the cheese take a bite in the pizza and pull away you notice that all the cheese on that slice comes off very plain tasting won't buy there again as an Italian from New York I know what's good pizza and this is not good pizza there's probably two Cooks there one of them cooks very good with the pizza and the other one is not good at all and $25 for Sicilian pie is way overpriced get it in Port Jervis for $20 and it's really good
Great service and food.
Nice atmosphere, but cold. Turn the heat on.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Not a lot of atmosphere, just tables and chairs with paneling. Big bar. Waiter was very nice and helpful. Eggplant Parm was very fried and not a lot of sauce. Cheese covered the top but not the pieces that were partially layered. Friend had fish which she said was ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Food and service are top quality. Naturally leavened pizza crust. Delicious entrees- my eggplant was sliced and cooked perfectly. Gelato and coffee is made in house - delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I went for pizza tonight. This was our first time here. Just the aroma when entering was enough to make you mouth water. The atmosphere is so nice. The building is beautiful and esthetically pleasing. A soft relaxing ambiance. The pizza (extra cheese, mushroom, onion and garlic NY style) was amazing!!! The crust is thin with a nice crisp. The sauce was seriously on point. One of the best pizzas I have ever had. We will be back!
Great food, good quality, well prepared and so flavorful
Worth the stop
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Superb place, great quality stuff. Looking forward to going back in the future when I'm up that way again. The cold coffee drinks are amazing, and their gelato is a no-brainer order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best restaurant around!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If I could give them more stars I would. They make the best pizza! The staff is super nice. They make everything from scratch. I really recommend this place. You can tell when someone loves what they do. I wish there was one Carini in every state.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza. We especially liked a few of the speciality pizzas.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Double check if they open - they dont update opening hours on google.
Very inconvenient to drive 30’ and see closed door.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sort of stumbled on this place, but what a find! If it had nothing more than a great beer list (several Trappist beers!), we’d have loved it. But the Brooklyn pizza was exceptional…thin crust baked crispy, excellent sauce, and mozzarella that tastes like it was just made that morning. The young lady who took care of us was pleasant and efficient (she seemed to be working alone but was totally on top of her game). Can you get a cheaper pizza or meal somewhere else? Sure. But this was a quality experience and worth every penny. We’re looking forward to going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and ambience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For drinks, we got an iced cappuccino and an iced mocha. For food, we got a Mediterranean shrimp salad and a sausage and green pepper pizza, well done. The salad was excellent, and the NY style pizza was on point. Foldable with a good crunch on the dough.
Everything we ate was excellent, the service was great, and we enjoyed the ambiance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was decent but overpriced in my honest opinion. Pizza was made fresh and from scratch. Brick oven, authentic Italian pizza. The pizza is what I’d imagine I’d get if I went to Italy. Wasn’t over the top fancy but it was good and you can tell it was fresh ingredients. Dough is homemade sourdough and thin crust but that’s by design and it was quite tasty. Fried calamari actually didn’t taste premade. Appeared to be breaded and fried at the restaurant and not premade prebought. They claim the Gelato is homemade on site as well. That was good as well. Atmosphere and service was great. Not busy at all on a Friday night. Only 5 of us in the whole restaurant…. Not sure what to make of that honestly. All food pictured cost $50. We got water.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...