Jimmy's Ice Cream

1946 W Main St, Stroudsburg
(570) 476-8860

Recent Reviews

milagros l.

So many great choices and selections to choose from. We tried four different flavors and each one of them were unique tasting and delicious. The environment was lovely despite the fact that it was a colder day, the indoor seating was ample and comfortable. Courtney helped us with our selection of ice cream-- she was incredibly sweet and had a great attitude. Her service was really what made our ice cream stop so pleasant!

Desiree F.

I was really in the mood for ice cream and found this spot. When I arrived I parked in the private lot. I walked in, and there was a bit of a line. When it was my turn, I ordered the coffee ice cream and the soft vanilla ice cream with oreo and Reese's and whipped cream to top it off. It took a few minutes. It looked so yummy. I paid about $4 and left. When I dug in, I really liked the vanilla with the oreo and Reese's. I wasn't a fan of the coffee ice cream, so I didn't eat that part. All in all, I had a decent experience!

Jose Yuqui

So good ?

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane Saponara

Ice cream is always too soft. The last time we went my boyfriend was sick shortly thereafter. I mean sick! We won’t go back. We gave it one last try. Ice cream is always melted!

Jeffrey Michael

Kind of pricey, and the soft serve ice cream gave me an immediate stomachache. Must not be very high quality. Very kind and attentive staff though.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

kim conville

oh my, this place is filthy. Family owned business. Take pride in your business. Display freezer, windows, floors around machines just filthy. Don't even want to think about, how it looks in the back, where you make gelato.

Kerri Turner

Gelato is delicious, but low inventory and so dark inside, light bulbs need replaced. I use to love going to Jimmy's!

Joe Capone

The hot fudge was good, so was the icecream.

Ewa Radziszewska

Filthy as it can get. Mold is a health concern.

Galina Niyazov

Enormous variety of flavors. Though a bit too sweet for me

B Sln

Good ice cream but way too busy for those 2 young girls to serve everyone! It got packed quickly. Tip those girls generously!

Rick S.

Ok, so here's the lowdown on Jimmies. Picture a place that looks like it hasn't seen a broom or paintbrush in decades. Spiders? Yeah, they're practically staff members here. But don't let that spook ya. Walk inside and you'll spot an air hockey table. Random? Absolutely! But it adds to the whole vibe.We hit up Jimmies after a friend's birthday bash. He's got this weird love for their gram cracker flavor. Me? I went for coffee with cookie dough, and man, it was on point! And let me quote one of the boys, "best soft serve ice cream I've had in a while". See, the ice cream here, it's legit!Now, the freezer with the pre-made ice cream sandwiches? Complete disaster! Looked like something outta a horror movie. Kinda like someone mistook it for a bathroom and... well, let's not go there. But somehow, that doesn't stop anyone.And guess who else likes to grab a scoop here? Catherine Mary Stewart! Yeah, THE Catherine Mary Stewart! Even with its shabby looks and that messed up freezer, Jimmies is packed with locals. It's like a tiny slice of real America, no pretense, no frills, just good ol' ice cream.So, despite its faults (and there are a few), I'm giving Jimmies a full 5 stars. It ain't pretty, but it's got heart. Can't wait to go back!

David Biegner

Ice cream was very good, service was good, milk shakes not so good. We ate here twice, it's that good!

susan gonzalez

Great ice cream great service and great price

Kevin “Smooth G” Rodney

The location is ideal and the people are friendly. They have a very nice selection of ice cream and gelatos. You have to try the tiramisu and the cannolis pretty good too.

Load More